A lot of 50 steers (the numbers are invented) averages 300 kg (660 lb) at one weighing and 315 kg (694 lb) 30 days later. The scale says it gained 0.50 kg a head a day. But at the first weighing the steers had just eaten hay and carried 10 kg (22 lb) more feed and water in the rumen and intestines (the gut fill). Without that extra, the real gain was 0.83 kg a head a day. So to know how much weight a lot really gained, compare only weighings taken under the same conditions: the same feed beforehand, the same hour of gathering, and the same fasting, or none. Write those conditions beside each weight on a weighing sheet, one sheet per lot.
A lot is a group of cattle kept and handled together. If you weigh your cattle now and then and want to know whether the animals are really gaining, or only reading heavier or lighter because of how they were weighed, the sheet is for you. Which animals belong to the lot is a decision of its own, and a written rule for who shares a lot comes before the first weighing.
How do you work out a lot’s average daily gain?
Average daily gain, ADG, is the lot’s average weight at one weighing, less its average weight at the previous weighing, divided by the days between them. The result is kilograms per head per day. A kilogram is about 2.2 pounds.
To keep the average comparable, weigh the same animals both times, either the whole lot or the same identified animals. If an animal entered or left between the weighings, write the date on the sheet, because a newcomer changes the average without anyone gaining a gram.
The example has one lot of 50 steers. Every figure is invented, and none is a weight or a gain measured on a real lot.
A farmer who sees 0.50 and then 0.87 may conclude that the lot sped up. The weights alone cannot tell that apart from a change in gut fill, because the feed also changed between the first two weighings. So on the sheet you mark the first interval as not comparable, and take the second, with both weighings off the same pasture, as the lot’s gain.
Why can the scale show a gain that is not there?
The weight on the scale is the animal’s body plus whatever its gut holds. Even animals kept 20 hours in a pen without water or feed still had gut content, and more of it the less digestible the forage was. This comes from trials at the General Villegas experiment station of INTA, Argentina’s national agricultural research institute, reported in an Argentine technical text published by Agritotal, a farm news site.
That text cites a 1981 estimate by Ávila and Marchi for a 279 kg steer. On an alfalfa pasture of 60 percent digestibility (the share of the forage the animal can digest), the gut content was 28 kg, 10 percent of its weight. On a winter cereal forage (a sown winter crop for grazing, such as oats) of 80 percent digestibility, it was 11 kg, 3.9 percent.
To check how much this matters, the station weighed a lot of 500 calves in 1998, first on pasture and again 39 days later on the cereal forage. The two weighings differed by 17.5 kg a head, a gain of 0.450 kg a head a day on the scale. To separate fill from gain, the station took 50 calves that weighed the same on average at the start and split them in two halves. It penned and weighed one half just before the calves went onto the cereal forage, and the other half nine days after they had gone onto it.
The two halves differed by 7.33 kg (16 lb) in average weight. Later the station weighed them again, and by then they weighed the same. If the nine extra days on cereal forage had added real weight, the halves would still have differed, so the 7.33 kg was gut fill, not gain. With that fill taken out, the gain was 0.561 kg a head a day on pasture and 0.971 on the cereal forage. The scale had read 0.450 across the change, lower than the real gain on either feed.
In a second trial, the animals were eating round bales of fair quality at the first weighing, and their fill was 11 kg. Spread over 30 days, those 11 kg make the gain on the scale 0.366 kg a day lower than the real one.
The trials show that the feed before weighing changes the fill. So to know how animals gain on a forage, take the first and the last weighing on that same type of forage. Many farmers weigh just when the animals change feed, to see how the new feed is working, and that first interval after a change of feed is the one to mark as not comparable.
Which weighing conditions matter, and does fasting fix them?
In the studies below, four conditions moved the weight. These are what the animals ate before, how long since they ate and drank, the hour they were gathered, and how they were handled (for example, how long they were moved around the corral).
A 2017 fact sheet from the Oklahoma State University extension service, the service through which the university advises farmers, is about shrink, the weight cattle lose between gathering and sale. Its authors, Barnes, Smith and Lalman, report that cattle held in a pen for 24 hours without feed or water lost 8.1 percent of their weight. Six hours after going back on wheat pasture, they had almost regained it.
The hour of gathering counts too. The authors cite a study from Kansas State University on grazing yearling steers. In it, steers gathered at 6 a.m. had lost 6.2 percent by 3 p.m., against 3.3 percent for steers gathered at 9 a.m. They also say to expect a further 0.5 percent loss, on top of the shrink, for every 30 minutes cattle are moved around a corral. Shrink is not gain, but it shows the scale moving for reasons that have nothing to do with growth.
One way to make the gut hold about the same at every weighing is to fast the animals first, and another is limited feeding (a short period on a small fixed ration). These studies do not show that either is needed. A University of Nebraska team, in a paper in the Journal of Animal Science, pooled 18 experiments. In them, cattle were weighed eating as much as they wanted. They were weighed again after limited feeding, which was at least five days on a ration estimated at 2 percent of their body weight, with the weights of two consecutive days averaged.
For single animals, the weight on full feed was sometimes lower and sometimes higher than the weight after limited feeding, by as much as 39 kg lower and 44 kg higher. With the two consecutive limited-feeding days averaged, the differences were as much as 23 and 24 kg. Daily gains worked out from the two kinds of weight differed by up to 0.29 kg a day one way and 0.31 the other. One gain worked out from full-fed weights reached 1.62 kg a day on a forage diet, which the authors judge likely due to gut fill, not to muscle and fat.
The authors suggest that handling the cattle the same way at every weighing does more than limited feeding to reduce the variation between weights. Limited feeding does get closer to the animal’s weight without the gut content, and an earlier Nebraska report had found limited-fed weights more accurate than full-fed ones. In short, limited feeding improves accuracy, and the same handling keeps the weights alike.
A 2020 doctoral thesis by Silva at the Universidade Federal de Viçosa, a Brazilian federal university, pooled 214 observations from five feedlot experiments and three on pasture. In those experiments, a fast before weighing changed neither the gain estimates nor how widely they scattered.
Put together, these studies point one way: what makes two weighings comparable is that the conditions were the same, not that the animals fasted. No single study says it in those words, and all were run at research stations with controlled feed, not on commercial lots. If you fast the animals, fast them for the same number of hours at every weighing. If you do not, do not fast at any weighing, and write on the sheet which you chose.
What goes on the sheet, and how far apart do you weigh?
The sheet has one line per weighing. Each line has the lot, the head count, the date and the average weight. It also has the hour of gathering, the feed in the days before, the hours without feed or water (or “not fasted”), who handled the animals, and how the scale was checked. It ends with the days since the previous weighing and the gain. A last column says comparable or not comparable, with the reason. A line is comparable with the one before only when the columns for conditions are the same in both. The feed column comes from comparing what left the store with what each lot’s ration calls for.
The scale needs the same care. In a text from Scot Consultoria, a Brazilian agribusiness consultancy, Sergio Raposo de Medeiros separates accuracy (reading the true weight) from precision (reading the same value every time). A scale that always reads 360 kg for a 300 kg steer is precise and wrong. His checks fit a sheet. Before starting, weigh three or four adults one by one and then together. Repeat every so often during the weighing, and see whether the single readings add up to the joint one.
He adds that dirt keeping the platform from moving freely makes the scale read low, so keep the scale and platform clean. He asks that the next animal in line not lean on the platform and that hands stay off it. And he suggests writing each animal’s previous weight on the weighing list, so that an unexpected weight warns you of a misread tag.
How far apart you weigh matters because of simple arithmetic. A weighing error is divided by the days between weighings. If the lot’s average is off by 10 kg (22 lb), the gain is off by 0.33 kg a day when the weighings are 30 days apart. When they are 90 days apart, it is off by 0.11. That is arithmetic, not a finding from a study. No source listed here sets a minimum interval between weighings, so write down the interval you use and keep it.
What the sources support, and what they do not. They show how weighing conditions move the number, in experiments and field trials with cattle. They do not show that keeping the gain of each lot changes the result of a commercial operation, and they give no gain to expect by category, season or breed. The Nebraska ranges above are for single animals, and no source listed gives the size of the error on a lot’s average. That is a test nobody has run, not a sign that the record fails.
What gain a lot should make, and what to do about a low one, stays with the farmer and the veterinarian or animal scientist. A low gain in the dry season may be a forage count that ran short, and the forage stock set against the demand of each lot shows it before the diet is cut.
Where to start
The sheet can be started at the next weighing, with the lots already in the corral. The weighing day is usually also the day for the herd’s vaccines, so write on the same day the vaccine dates and the head with no record.
The same habit of writing the reading beside the conditions it was taken under runs through how a field’s yield is kept season by season and through the soil reading taken with moisture noted.
Once the weights are trustworthy, they carry into the sale, where the price your buyer bids is multiplied by the lot’s weight. The cattle price history of your own buyer’s bids is the matching record for the price side. The day the lot leaves is better decided before it arrives: see when to sell the lot.
Keeping the sheet is part of farm management, and more on records of the production side is in the production library.
For the pasture these lots graze, see Stocking rate: how much is each pasture carrying, and when?
For the cows behind the calves, see Calf crop: count weaned calves on the cows you exposed.
The dates the bulls stayed set how far apart the calves of one lot were born, and the breeding season, planned and done, is where those dates are kept. The dam of each calf is on the cow’s card.