Count the calves weaned and divide them by all the cows exposed to breeding. That means every cow that was with the bull in the season, whether or not she conceived, never only the cows found pregnant. Do it for each breeding season, and separately for first-calf cows and for older cows. In the hypothetical example below, the same 152 weaned calves are 76 percent of 200 cows exposed and 89 percent of 170 cows found pregnant.
Count also the cows found pregnant at the pregnancy check (the exam that finds which cows are pregnant) and the calves born alive, over those same exposed cows. With the three counts you can see where the herd fell short of a calf per cow. Either the cow did not conceive, or the calf was lost between the check and birth, or it was lost between birth and weaning.
In 71 herds of the Salado basin (a cow-calf region of Buenos Aires province, Argentina), per 100 cows, 89 were found pregnant, 83 calved and 79 weaned. The source does not say which cows it based the percentages on; this article reads them as cows exposed. The largest loss was the cows that did not conceive. You write these counts on one sheet for each breeding season, eight lines each, which you can start from the tags and dates you already have.
Which weaning rate should you count, and over which cows?
The weaned calves divided by the cows exposed, and by no other count. Rasby and Meyer, of the University of Nebraska-Lincoln (a US public university), take the first three measures (cows exposed, pregnancy and live calving) from the guidelines of the Beef Improvement Federation, a US cattle-industry association. They divide weaning by the cows exposed as well. The pregnancy rate is the cows diagnosed pregnant divided by the cows exposed. The live calving rate is the calves born alive divided by the cows exposed. The weaning rate is the calves weaned divided by the cows exposed, which they call percent calf crop.
The exposed cows are counted at the start of the season. A cow that dies, or is marked to be sold or moved out, before she calves comes out of the count. A pregnant cow you bought, who will calve this season, goes in even if she was never with your bull. The adjustment that matters most is an exception to those exits: a cow found open (not pregnant) and sold is not subtracted, so the rate still counts the fact that she did not conceive. The calculation below uses a hypothetical herd.
The 89 percent is higher than the 76 only because the open cows left the count. Whoever sells the open cows every year and divides only by those that stay sees the rate rise without weaning one more calf. A rate divided by one group of cows cannot be compared with a rate divided by another, between seasons or between farms. So write, beside each rate on the sheet, which cows it was divided by.
At which step does the herd fall short of a calf per cow?
Mostly at the first step: in the cows that did not conceive. Maresca and colleagues, of INTA (Argentina’s national agricultural research institute), report, with data up to 2007, three sets of breeding herds in the Salado basin. Per 100 cows, the first set (herds followed for about twenty years) had 88 pregnant, 83 calved and 81 weaned. The second (herds followed for ten years) had 91, 86 and 85. The third (71 herds studied by INTA) had 89, 83 and 79.
Subtracting step by step, the cows lost per 100 are 9 to 12 at conception, 5 to 6 between the pregnancy check and calving, and 1 to 4 between birth and weaning. The authors write 2 to 4 for the last step.
These are herds of one region, so they show where calves were lost there, not on your farm. The source does not state which cows it divided these percentages by; this article reads them as cows exposed. The same authors, from INTA’s monitoring of breeding herds, name the nutritional state of the cows at the start of breeding as the main cause of low pregnancy. They report that over three production cycles 26 percent of the cows reached breeding with body reserves (body condition) below the optimum. Correcting that is not covered here; take it to your veterinarian.
A severe drought can pull pregnancy down. In INTA’s 2023 report on 936 herds and 283,309 cows in 24 districts of the northeast of the same basin, pregnancy was about 82.4 percent after a drought in spring and summer. That is 4.8 points under the average of the last five years. The herds with a delayed breeding season were the most affected.
Rasby and Meyer write the same about the United States: the greatest loss of calves that could have been weaned comes from cows not becoming pregnant. Galindo and Vargas simulated a cow-calf and fattening system in Costa Rica and compared several factors. They found that pregnancy rate had the largest effect on kilograms of calf weaned per cow exposed and on net income. It is a model of one system, not a trial on farms.
The cow that did not conceive shows up open at the pregnancy check, months before a calf lost after birth shows up at weaning. The dates of your checks therefore set how late you learn of a loss. How long a farm takes to find out about any loss is the subject of how long it takes you to find out something went wrong. With the pregnancy rate alone, the loss after the check does not show. So the sheet has the three counts, each over the same exposed cows.
Do first-calf cows, and cows that calve late in the season, conceive like the others?
No, in the studies that measured it, and the herd average does not show it, because it mixes these cows with all the others. Vieira and colleagues followed 468 Nelore cows (a zebu breed common in Brazil) in the Cerrado (the savanna of central Brazil) over four breeding seasons of three months each, on Brachiaria (a tropical pasture grass). First-calf cows were 69 percent pregnant, cows with five to eight calvings were 90 percent, and the rate fell to 80 percent at twelve calvings.
Calving date mattered as well. Take the last 20 days of a calving season of 100 days (the weeks when the herd calves). Of the first-calf cows that calved then, 37.7 percent were pregnant at the end of the breeding season, against 79.9 percent of the cows of seventh calving that calved in those same days. Cows that calved early in the season were above 80 percent whatever their number of calvings.
Sonohata and colleagues, of the State University of Mato Grosso do Sul, followed 111 crossbred cows with Nelore blood on the university’s research farm in Aquidauana, Brazil. The breeding season lasted 108 days, with natural service. They grouped the cows by the month they calved in, counting from the start of the calving season, and counted how many were pregnant at the end of the next breeding season.
Of the cows that calved in the first month, 97 percent were pregnant at the end of the next breeding season, 30 of 31. Of those that calved in the fourth month, 58 percent were, 11 of 19. Male calves from the first two months weighed 170 kg (375 lb) at weaning, and from the last two months 161 and 160 kg (355 and 353 lb). The female calves showed no difference in weaning weight.
Each group had 19 to 33 cows, from a research farm. The report states 111 cows while its table adds up to 104, so the figures above are the table’s. In these studies the calving month goes together with what the cows were eating at the time, so the two effects cannot be told apart.
Inside one calving season, calves born later are younger on the day they are weaned. SDSU Extension, the extension service of South Dakota State University in the United States, gives reference figures from a herd-evaluation program for how quickly cows calve. They are 63 percent of mature cows calving in the first 21 days of the calving season, 87 percent by day 42 and 96 percent by day 63. The page adds that a calf one day younger at weaning can weigh 2.4 lb (1.1 kg) less. For that reason the sheet counts the calves born in the first 21 days.
Early calving also goes with a longer stay in the herd. The study covers 2,195 South Dakota heifers that had conceived in their first breeding season. Those that calved in the first 21 days stayed in the herd 5.1 years on average against 3.9 for those that calved later. That is an association seen in herd records, not an experiment. The study counted as leaving the herd only the heifer found open at the end of breeding.
In this herd at 76 percent, the first-calf cows are at 60 and the older cows at 80. Only counting the groups separately shows it.
What goes on the sheet for each breeding season?
The sheet for one season has eight lines, on paper or in a spreadsheet, whichever you use. Below is one filled in with hypothetical figures. What is kept for each cow, one by one, is in the cow’s card.
First, the season as a pair of dates: the day the bulls went in with the cows and the day they came out, so the season has fixed dates and is not “sometime in spring”. Second, the cows exposed, by tag (or whatever mark tells the cows apart) and by group, first-calf cows apart from the older ones. Write down any cow taken out of the count, with the reason and the date.
Third, the pregnancy count with the date and the method of the check (palpation or ultrasound), and the tags of the cows found open. The check is what separates a cow that never conceived from one that conceived and lost the calf later, so when and how it was done belongs on the sheet. The dates of the season are checked against the plan in the breeding season, planned against done.
Fourth, each calf born alive with its date, which gives the share born in the first 21 days (the span of the SDSU figures above). Fifth, the calves weaned and the weaning date, with the weight if you weigh them. Sixth, the calves lost between birth and weaning, with the cow’s tag and the date, and a cause only if the veterinarian gave one (do not write a guess).
Seventh, the three rates, pregnant, born alive and weaned, each over the same exposed cows, for the herd and for each group. Eighth, the decision: the date, the name of the person who made it and the reason in one line. Which animals go into a lot after weaning is set by a written rule for who shares a lot.
At the close of the season, put the sheet beside last season’s and compare them line by line. Take two hypothetical seasons that both end at 76 percent weaned, with 40 first-calf cows and 160 older cows in each. In the first, first-calf cows are at 60 percent and older cows at 80. In the second, first-calf cows are at 70 and older cows at 77.5. The herd rate is the same, but the first-calf cows did much better in the second season and the older cows a little worse.
Before changing anything in the herd, ask what was different that season for the group of cows that fell behind, and take that question to your veterinarian. Decide what happens to a cow found open before she is found open, with a rule written in advance: see a cull rule written before the cow is open.
A caution on the evidence. The definitions come from an extension article built on the guidelines of a US association. The loss at each step comes from surveys of herds in Argentina. The effects of the cow’s group and of the month of calving come from observational studies, in Nelore cows in Brazil and in herds in South Dakota. Those studies looked at herds as they were, with no trial. The link to income comes from a simulation.
None of this article’s sources tested whether keeping a sheet like this one changes the result of a commercial herd. That has not been shown, and it has not been disproved either. The percentages in those studies come from those herds, not from yours. Whether the sheet pays on your farm, only a test on your own farm can tell. Comparing two consecutive seasons is a start, but it mixes the effect of the sheet with that of the year.
Where to start
The sheet can be started from the list of cows, the tags and the dates of the last season.
The first season’s sheet comes from the lists and dates you already have; the second season’s is the one you can compare with it. A calf sold after weaning has a price to record: see cattle price history for how to record it with a date and a source. For other work on the herd, see the production articles; for the farm as a whole, see farm management. Related: How do you know how much weight a cattle lot really gained?