Skip to content
Assessment
LibraryProduction

Which animals share a lot, and by what rule?

Fifty calves weaned the same day average 604 pounds, and none of the four groups inside that lot weighs 604. A rule written before the lot is formed, and an animal list checked against it on a date, is what lets the average say something.

Published Updated 15 min read
In this article

Fifty calves weaned on the same day average 604 pounds, and none of the four groups inside that lot weighs 604. A farmer who keeps as replacements (young females raised to become cows) only the heifer calves above that average keeps none, because the heaviest heifer group weighs 600 pounds. Needing eight replacements, that farmer buys eight heifers instead, at an example price of US$2,200 each, for US$17,600. A lot is the set of animals you feed, vaccinate, weigh and sell as one. Write the rule for who belongs to it before you form the lot (sex, birth-date window, pasture and feed, class of dam), then check the animal list against that rule on a date.

Why does the average of a mixed lot fit none of its animals?

The numbers come from the Beef Cattle Research Council (BCRC), the Canadian beef research body. Its example takes 50 calves that came off the same pasture on the same day. It sorts them by sex, by age, and by whether the dam (the calf’s mother) was a first-calf heifer (a young cow raising her first calf) or a mature cow. The lot average is 604 pounds. The four groups weigh 500, 550, 600 and 625 pounds on average, so the average matches no group, and the closest one sits 4 pounds under it.

BCRC calls each of these groups a contemporary group: animals of the same sex and similar age, raised in the same place, on the same feed and pasture, at the same time. A farm lot formed by that test is the same object, and this article calls it a lot.

Figure: Average weaning weight of each group in the BCRC example, against the lot average, in pounds
The 604-pound lot average matches none of the four groupsAverage weaning weight in pounds: heifer calves of first-calf dams, 500; bull calves of first-calf dams, 550; heifer calves of mature cows, 600; bull calves of mature cows, 625. The lot average is 604.Average weaning weight by group, poundsFirst-calf dams, heifer calves (3)500First-calf dams, bull calves (2)550Mature cows, heifer calves (20)600Mature cows, bull calves (25)625First-calf damsMature cowsLot average, 604 pounds
The 50 calves of the BCRC example, by group (the gap is the group weight against the 604-pound lot average)
Group Calves Average age (days) Average weaning weight (lb) Gain (lb per day) Gap to the lot average (lb)
First-calf dams, heifer calves 3 250 500 2.0 104 under
First-calf dams, bull calves 2 250 550 2.2 54 under
Mature cows, heifer calves 20 220 600 2.7 4 under
Mature cows, bull calves 25 220 625 2.8 21 over

The calves of first-calf dams are 30 days older than the others and lighter. Their heifer calves weigh 500 pounds against 600 for the heifer calves of mature cows. Five calves sit 54 to 104 pounds under the lot average. A farmer who has only that average cannot tell whether the cause is the calves, their dams or the mixture. Grouped by dam class, the pattern is plain: the light calves are the ones raised by first-calf dams.

The cut and the price in the calculation box are an example built to show the failure of a mixed lot. BCRC does not recommend that cut, and the group averages are not individual weights, so single calves in a group will sit above or below its average.

What does a lot rule have to say, and where does it come from?

The sources overlap on the ingredients. The Western Beef Resource Committee handbook gives three tests: same sex, similar age with no more than a 90-day spread in birth dates, and management together with an equal opportunity to perform. The handbook spells out that last test as the same pasture time, the same feed and the same weighing dates. The Kentucky extension service adds the dam: if a group of calves, or their dams, get preferential treatment, the calves take a different group code, a label that keeps them apart in the records. Kentucky marks sex and the group code as records that cannot be skipped.

The Beef Improvement Federation (BIF), the US body that sets the guidelines for beef performance programs, says it in one line: a contemporary group is animals that have had an equal opportunity to perform. In Brazil, Embrapa describes the farm lot the same way, as animals born together and kept together on the same pasture, in the same corral and under the same handler until weaning.

That makes four fields, each one a question the farmer can answer from the books or the corral. Sex. The birth-date window. The place and the feed. The class of the dam. The rule names the four, and the farmer checks the animal list against them.

Figure: A lot rule in four fields, written before the lot is formed (example)
A lot rule has four fields, each answered with a value and a dateExample rule for lot H1, written on 2 June: heifer calves only; born 1 March to 30 May, a spread of 90 days; pasture 4 with the same supplement; mature cows only as dams. The rule is checked on 12 September.Rule for lot H1, written 2 JuneSexHeifer calves onlyBirth-date window1 March to 30 May (90 days)Place and feedPasture 4, same supplementClass of damMature cows onlyChecked against the animal list on 12 September

The fields come from sources written for weighing calves and for genetic evaluation. A farm lot also serves a dose, a ration or a sale, so the farmer may need a fifth field, and this article does not say which one. It asks that every field be written down with a date before the lot is formed. None of the sources tested whether writing the rule raises income; they explain how to compare animals fairly, and that is the only claim made here.

How wide can the rule be before the average blurs again?

A wide rule gives a bigger lot, which is easier to run and gives an average from more animals. It also lets animals with different conditions into the same average. Embrapa gives an example. Split the year into two seasons, October to April and May to September. A calf born in May and one born in September land in the same group, yet they did not live in the same environment. Longer periods enlarge the group and lower the chance that all its members shared the same conditions.

A narrow rule has the opposite cost. BIF names both errors. Breeders often fail to assign enough groups to calves that received unequal treatment, and some create too many groups. Its advice is to keep the assignment as simple as possible while still accounting for the major differences in management.

The BCRC example shows how a narrow rule breaks. Split by sex and dam class, the 50 calves make four groups of 3, 2, 20 and 25 calves. The Argentine Angus association, which runs a genetic evaluation, requires at least five animals in a group and says one animal does not make a group. Two of the four groups fall under that floor. The Angus association also cuts its groups by month of birth, while the handbook above accepts a 90-day spread, and this article keeps the 90 days.

Figure: Calves in each group of the BCRC example, against a floor of five animals
Two of the four groups have fewer than five calvesCalves per group: first-calf dams with heifer calves, 3; first-calf dams with bull calves, 2; mature cows with heifer calves, 20; mature cows with bull calves, 25. The floor of five animals is the Argentine Angus association's minimum for a group in its genetic evaluation.Calves per groupFirst-calf dams, heifer calves3First-calf dams, bull calves2Mature cows, heifer calves20Mature cows, bull calves25Under five animalsFive or moreFloor of five animals

This article takes one position. A group under five animals has no average worth reading, so list those animals as exceptions and do not average them. In the BCRC example that means the five calves of first-calf dams are listed one by one, and the lot averages cover the other 45. Five is the floor of one association’s genetic evaluation, and a feeding lot may need a different number. Choose yours and write it beside the rule. How wide each field is stays the farmer’s choice, and that choice is also written down, since the check later uses it.

What do I record when an animal is moved out of its lot?

Animals move. A pasture closes, a sick calf goes to the paddock near the barn, a feed bunk runs out of room. BIF states the direction of the movement for weaning groups. A group never grows after the calving season. It may shrink through culling, injury, sickness, death or reassignment, and it cannot be recombined once animals belong to separate groups. The Argentine Angus association says the same of weaning groups, which may stay equal or shrink.

Those sources write the rule for comparing weights. This article reads it for any figure a farmer works out per lot, such as gain, dose or sale weight. An animal that leaves keeps its line on the animal list, with the date and the reason. An animal that joins after the lot was formed is outside the rule unless it meets all four fields, and its line says so. In both cases the line also says who moved it.

Lot H1 follows the rule in the figure: heifer calves born 1 March to 30 May, on pasture 4 with the same supplement, out of mature cows. The check on 12 September lists four of its animals.

Composition check of lot H1 on 12 September (example; the rule of lot H1 is the one in the figure of the four fields)
Ear tag Birth date Pasture Inside the rule Moved by and date Reason
0412 6 March 4 Yes
0431 19 May 4 Yes
0455 14 June 4 No, born after 30 May Foreman, 3 September Moved from lot H2 to free pasture 7
0470 2 April Barn paddock No, wrong pasture Owner, 5 September Sick calf, kept near the barn

Moving animals to free a pasture also changes how many animals each pasture carries, which the article on stocking rate by pasture and season works out. The two records answer different questions. On the stocking sheet the farmer counts animals per area, and on the composition list the farmer reads which animals the lot average still describes.

Figure: What the check does with each animal, in three steps
Compare, write the exception, and mark late arrivalsStep one: compare each animal with the four fields of the rule on a date. Step two: for an animal that fails a field, write the ear tag, who moved it, the date and the reason. Step three: an animal that joined after the lot was formed is outside the rule, with the same four notes.1. Compare each animalwith the four fields, on a date2. It fails a fieldWrite ear tag, who moved it, date, reason3. It joined after the lot beganOutside the rule, with the same four notes

What do I write first, and how long does it take?

For a first lot of about fifty animals, set aside an afternoon with the animal register, or the pasture book if there is no register. Write the four fields and the date, then list the animals one line each. Counting the animals of each lot shows at once whether the rule is too narrow.

Figure: The check in five steps, from the rule to the monthly repeat
Five steps of the lot checkWrite the rule in four fields with a date. List every animal. Mark inside or outside the rule and count each lot. Write who moved each outside animal and why. Repeat the check one day a month.1. Write the four fields, with a date2. List every animal, one line each3. Mark inside or outside, count the lot4. Who moved each outside animal, why5. Repeat one day a monthSteps 1 and 2 once; steps 3 to 5 on every check

Start tomorrow with the lot that disappointed you most: write its four fields, list its animals and count how many fall outside. Once each lot has a rule and a checked list, its gain is a number worth working out. The article on how much weight a cattle lot really gained takes it from there. The feed each lot is then given is checked in feed delivered against the ration by lot. Planning which animals share a pasture and a ration is part of running the farm as a business, and the production section of the library holds the other articles on the herd.

Provenance

Derives from
  1. Beef Cattle Research Council, Animal Health and Performance Record Keeping, Level 3 (web page, accessed 28 October 2026)
  2. Beef Improvement Federation, Guidelines for Uniform Beef Improvement Programs, 9th ed. (revised 2016), chapter 3, Contemporary Grouping for Beef Cattle Genetic Evaluation
  3. Bullock, D. and Laurent, K., Keeping Production Records for the Beef Herd, ASC-150, University of Kentucky Cooperative Extension Service, 2000
  4. Boggs, D., Understanding and Using Sire Summaries, Cattle Producer's Handbook 837, Western Beef Resource Committee, 4th ed.
  5. Cobuci, J. A., Abreu, U. G. P. and Torres, R. A., Formação de Grupos Contemporâneos em Bovinos de Corte, Documentos 87, Embrapa Pantanal, 2006 (in Portuguese)
  6. Asociación Argentina de Angus, Reproductores Angus sin D.E.P. del E.R.A., Sitio Argentino de Producción Animal (undated, in Spanish)
What this article covers
Writing the rule that says which animals belong to a lot (sex, birth-date window, pasture and feed, class of dam) before the lot is formed, listing the animals of each lot, checking the list against the rule on a date, and recording who moved each animal that falls outside the rule, and why.
What it does not cover
Which rule is the best one, a choice of animal handling that belongs to the farmer and the animal scientist. It does not work out the gain of a lot, the stocking rate (animals per area of pasture) or the record of one individual animal, and it does not rank animals for breeding.
Published
Updated
Error found
Point out an error and the article is corrected with a note on what changed.

How to cite this article

Rurivia. (2026, October 28). Which animals share a lot, and by what rule? https://rurivia.com/en/library/production/which-animals-share-a-lot-and-by-what-rule/


Keep reading

Production

New or sick animal: where does it go, and who lets it out?

A farmer who unloads 12 bought heifers into the herd of 150 cows has decided without a card. Four fields written on the day of purchase, days, place, who lets the animals out and who to call, take that decision off the day the truck arrives.

Oct 28, 2026
Production

What share of the cows exposed to breeding weaned a calf?

A pregnancy rate says how many cows conceived, not how many calves reached weaning. With one sheet per breeding season, divided by every cow exposed and split by group, you can see at which step the calves were lost.

Oct 27, 2026
Production

Vaccination calendar: which animals have no record?

A farm of 200 head that cannot say which 32 have no dated dose ends up asking the veterinarian about 200. A calendar by lot, a count and a review date with a name cut the question to 32.

Oct 28, 2026
Production

Does it matter who pays your agronomist?

In a large-scale California study, a commission on the sale was not linked to more spraying; the clearest higher use, of insecticide and fungicide, came from advisers on a farm's own payroll. What you can settle is who decides, on a six-item page you sign with each agronomist.

Sep 5, 2026

Farm Management

If this article were a plant, farm management would be the whole field.

Planning, organizing, leading and controlling: the four functions, what each one decides, and a farm example for each, all on one page.