A single head-per-hectare figure for the whole year hides the two things that change: the animals’ weight and the forage of the season. One Brazilian trial (a field experiment) shows it. Animals on the same four pastures gained 0.75 to 0.86 kg per head per day in the wet season (the rains). In the dry season the result ran anything from a loss of 0.06 kg to a gain of 0.24 kg per head per day.
So keep one record sheet for grazing, with a block for each pasture and each season. In each block write the stocking rate (how many animals graze each hectare), the animals’ average weight and one forage reading. The reading is a simple measurement taken the same way every time, such as grass height.
Two terms matter here. The stocking rate is the number of animals on each hectare (a hectare is about 2.5 acres). The load is the live weight of those animals on each hectare, in kilograms. Countries also count the load in animal units, each built on a reference animal, a standard animal of a set weight. They are the UA (animal unit) in Brazil, the UG (livestock unit) in Uruguay, the EV (cow equivalent) in Argentina and the AU (animal unit) in Alberta, Canada. The sheet records the unit you use, with its reference animal.
What does a stocking rate count, and in which unit?
Counting head misleads, because a steer of 300 kg and a steer of 420 kg are one head each but very different loads. INIA, Uruguay’s national agricultural research institute, keeps the two measures apart: its example is 2.5 calves of 200 kg per hectare, a stocking rate of 2.5 head and a load of 500 kg per hectare. INIA also notes that in general use its two Spanish words for these, dotación (animals per area) and carga (kilograms of live weight per hectare), are used interchangeably. In this article, stocking rate always means head per hectare, and load always means kilograms of live weight per hectare.
Each country counts animals in its own unit, built on its own reference animal. The four below are not the same:
- Brazil: the animal unit (UA) is 450 kg of live weight, the unit that Martha Junior and colleagues of Embrapa, the Brazilian public agricultural research company, use.
- Uruguay: the livestock unit (UG, unidad ganadera) is a breeding cow of 380 kg, according to INIA.
- Argentina: the cow equivalent (EV, equivalente vaca) is the feed that a 400 kg cow needs in a year while she rears a calf to weaning, according to Bavera’s compilation, a university course text.
- Alberta, Canada: the animal unit (AU) is a cow and her calf together, weighing 1,000 lb (454 kg), says Alberta Agriculture and Forestry, the Alberta provincial government’s agriculture department.
Use the unit of your country and write its reference animal beside it, because a figure in UA, UG, EV or AU cannot be compared with another farm’s without it. Whatever the unit, use the same one in every block. If your country is not in the list, write the load in kilograms and name the reference animal you chose.
The head count also hides the animals’ growth. In this example, one pasture keeps the same 60 steers through the year.
Written as one yearly figure, this pasture is 1.5 head per hectare. Written as two entries, one for each date, it had 450 kg of live weight per hectare at the start and 630 kg six months later, 40 percent more.
One yearly figure
1.5 head per hectare
- Same on both dates
- The steers gained weight and the figure does not show it
Two dated entries
The load at each date
- Start of the rains: 450 kg per hectare
- Six months later: 630 kg per hectare
- The load rose by 40 percent
Why do animals on the same pasture gain differently in the rains and in the dry season?
Because what a pasture can feed changes with the season, and the herd still has to eat every day. Martha Junior and colleagues, from Embrapa Cerrados (Embrapa’s center for Brazil’s central savanna region), grazed four varieties (cultivars) of Brachiaria brizantha, a tropical pasture grass. The cultivars are Marandu, Arapoty, Xaraés and Capiporã, in a 2007 conference paper.
The trial ran on 16 hectares in Planaltina, in the Federal District of Brazil, from December 2004 to September 2005, with the low soil fertility and low stocking of an ordinary Cerrado farm. The rains lasted 181 days and the dry season 97. In kilograms gained per head per day, the four cultivars gained 0.83, 0.86, 0.82 and 0.75 in the rains. In the dry season Marandu and Arapoty gained 0.15 and 0.24, while Xaraés and Capiporã each lost 0.06. The trial had two replicates, and its table gives no test for the daily gain in each season, so read these as the trial’s averages, not as proven differences between cultivars.
Over the whole period of 278 days the animals gained 165 kg a head on Marandu, 179 on Arapoty, 143 on Xaraés and 130 on Capiporã. The authors write that Xaraés and Capiporã in particular could not sustain animal gain in the dry season, and that this substantially cut the productivity obtained in the rains.
Mind the trial’s limits. Each cultivar carried its own head per hectare, so the differences come partly from the grass and partly from how many animals each pasture held. Capiporã went from 1.61 to 1.25 head per hectare for the dry season and still lost 0.06 kg a day, the same loss as Xaraés, whose herd went only from 1.57 to 1.50. So cutting the head count did not by itself bring the gain back. The 278 days run from December to September, not a full year.
The forage also varies between years. Manley and colleagues, in a 1997 study of natural grazing land near Cheyenne, Wyoming, in the United States, measured each year from 1982 to 1994 the most forage standing in the field. Forage is the grass and other plants the animals eat. That maximum ranged from 540 to 1,740 kg per hectare, so the worst year had about a third of the best year’s forage. Take the same 1.5 steers of 300 kg per hectare in both years, which is 450 kg of live weight per hectare each time. That load is light on 1,740 kg of forage and heavy on 540. The study did not make this comparison; it is an illustration.
If you already keep each field’s yield year by year, the pasture sheet is the same practice. It keeps the load and the forage reading of one season, to compare with the same season of the next year.
Does a heavier stocking rate pay more per hectare?
Not always, and the answer changes from one year to the next. More animals on the same area lower the gain of each animal and, past a point, lower the gain of the whole pasture. Jones and Sandland, in a 1974 paper, pooled the results of many grazing trials, tropical and temperate, and found that gain per animal falls in a straight line as the stocking rate rises. Gain per hectare is the gain per animal times the animals per hectare. So gain per hectare rises, flattens and then falls, and its highest point comes at half the stocking rate at which each animal would stop gaining.
With invented figures, say each animal gains 180 kg a year minus 60 kg for every head per hectare. At 1 head per hectare each animal gains 120 kg and the hectare 120 kg. At 1.5 it is 90 and 135. At 2 it is 60 and 120. At 3 it is 0 and 0. The peak, 135 kg per hectare, comes at 1.5, half of 3.
FutureBeef, the Queensland Government’s beef information site in Australia, describes a grazing trial at Galloway Plains. Per year, one animal per hectare gained 59 kg a head and 59 kg a hectare. One animal per two hectares gained 108 kg a head and 54 kg a hectare. One animal per four hectares gained 133 kg a head and 33 kg a hectare.
Going from 1 animal per hectare to 1 animal per two hectares cost 5 kg a hectare and gave each animal 49 kg more. Going from 1 animal per two hectares to 1 per four cost another 21 kg a hectare and gave each animal 25 kg more. In this trial, then, the most animals still gave the most kilograms per hectare, with the least for each animal.
More weight gained is not more money earned. Manley and colleagues put prices on their Wyoming trial of steers a year old (yearlings), in a spreadsheet simulation, at three stocking rates: light, moderate and heavy. The most profitable rate moved with prices. In a year of favorable prices it lay between the moderate and the heavy rate, and in average or unfavorable years it was near the moderate rate or below it. The authors add that, when prices are favorable, the rates most profitable in the short run may be high enough to reduce the condition of the range.
A Queensland steer trial that FutureBeef reports shows the answer changing from one group of steers to the next. One pasture was split in two, at 2.5 hectares a head (0.4 head per hectare) and at 5.0 hectares a head (0.2). The first group of steers ran from December 1998 to December 2000. The more heavily stocked half earned a gross margin (income minus variable costs) of 66.10 dollars a hectare (the report does not name the currency) against 52.30 for the other half, a gap of 13.80. For the second group, from December 2000 to July 2002, the order reversed: 77.00 against 80.20.
The two comparisons are not identical, because the heavier pasture was destocked for the second group and the two rates became 3.0 and 4.0 hectares a head. The report adds that all the lighter-stocked steers graded Jap Ox (beef for the Japanese market), so they could expect a price premium of 15 cents a kilogram. These figures leave the premium out; counting it narrows the first gap to about 5 dollars a hectare.
So the sheet has the load beside the year it applies to, and no recommended rate. The rate that pays is the farm’s own, in that year’s prices and forage. Prices and costs have their own records: a dated price record, as in cattle price history, and costs counted by a declared rule, as in how much to sell to break even.
What goes on the sheet for each pasture and season?
One block for each pasture and each season. The block has six parts. Below the list, one block is filled in with invented figures for the North pasture, with the gain per head blank because the animals were not weighed again.
- The pasture, its area, and the season with its start and end dates, so a season is a pair of dates and not “the rainy months”.
- The animals: class, head count and average weight, with the date of the weighing or a mark that the weight is an estimate.
- The stocking rate in head per hectare, the load in kilograms of live weight per hectare, and the load in your unit with its reference animal written beside it.
- One forage reading taken the same way every time, such as grass height, the residue (the height left after grazing) or a photograph from the same fence post. In the Wyoming study, Manley and colleagues write that monitoring methods need not be elaborate if used consistently. The Embrapa trial set a residue of 30 centimeters, give or take 5, as the target for those Brachiaria grasses. That number is for those grasses, not for yours.
- Gain per head, filled only when the animals were weighed again.
- The decision: the date you kept or changed the animals on the pasture, who decided and why in one line.
At the close of each season, put the block beside the same season of last year. In the first year there is nothing to compare with, and the block becomes the starting point. If the head per hectare is the same as last year but the weight or the forage reading differs, ask why before changing the number of animals. Take the North pasture: 1.5 head per hectare of steers of 300 kg is 450 kg of live weight per hectare, and 525 kg if they weigh 350 kg. The sheet does not give the answer; you give it, with your agronomist or animal scientist if you have one.
The sheet is a record. The support for it comes from grazing trials with steers: the Cerrado trial at a research center, and the Wyoming and Queensland trials on trial pastures. None of the sources consulted for this article reports a test of whether keeping a sheet like this changes results on a commercial farm. That is a gap in the research, not a finding that the sheet fails. The sources also include no trial from Argentina or Uruguay relating gain to stocking rate, so those countries enter only through their units.
Where to start
Start the sheet from the records the farm already has of areas and animals.
The sheet follows the order of a crop budget written before planting: you write the number down first and compare it with the result afterwards. Weighing the animals and working out the gain of a lot is the subject of How do you know what a cattle lot really gained? More on production is in the production articles. How the farm’s land, animals and money are used toward its goals is the subject of farm management.