An example farm feeds 90 cows and 40 heifers from round bales and a silage bag. Together they hold 327 tons of dry matter, which is what is left of the feed once the water is taken out. The herd will eat 306 tons before the pastures are ready on June 1. The count looks 21 tons ahead. Can the farm reach June 1 without buying feed?
It depends on how you count. On the measured weight alone, 21 tons are left over. If the count takes off what will still spoil in each depot (each place where forage is stored) before it reaches the trough, the forage runs out between April 5 and May 2. Buying 50 to 94 tons of hay would cost about $8,000 to $15,000, at an illustrative $160 a ton.
So count the days the forage lasts this way: the measured weight, minus the loss still to come, divided by what the lots eat each day. Decide the purchase 21 days before the early end of that range, an assumed time for the hay to arrive: March 15 here. This page shows the sheet that gives those dates before the diet is cut.
Three terms first. Dry matter is what remains of a feed once the water is taken out, and it is the weight that lets you compare hay with silage. As-fed is the weight as the feed arrives, water included. A depot is each separate place where forage is stored, such as a stack of bales or a bag. Tons here are short tons of 2,000 pounds (907 kg), and the herd and the prices are invented. Every sum is worked from unrounded values, so a subtraction on the printed figures can differ from the printed result by 0.1.
How much forage is in the barn, in dry matter?
Weigh it, and do not read the weight from a book. A Wisconsin Extension article by Halfman and colleagues says to leave aside book values, bale dimensions and the baler’s settings, because bale weight varies with the baler, the operator and the hay. Weigh a few bales of each batch on a scale and multiply the average by the number of bales in the batch. For forage in a bag, pile or silo, weigh typical loads from the chopper box, full minus empty, and count the loads that went in.
When nobody counted the loads, estimate from the dimensions of the structure. The Iowa Beef Center names three numbers for that estimate: the dimensions, the average dry matter and the density. It measures density by marking a section of the pile, feeding from it for several days, and dividing the weight removed by the volume of the section. It also suggests a dry matter test each week as a starting point.
Then convert each weight to dry matter, because the herd’s demand is counted that way. The example farm weighed its bales at an average 1,250 pounds with 86 percent dry matter, so 400 bales make 215 tons. The silage bag took 311 tons as-fed by counted loads, at 36 percent dry matter, which is 112 tons. The two depots hold 327 tons of dry matter. Both were weighed as they went into storage, so every storage loss and every feeding loss is still ahead of them.
What do the lots eat each day until the grass is back?
Demand is how much the lots eat until the forage is back. It is the dry matter each animal eats in a day, from the ration set for its group, times the animals in the group, times the days until the herd can live on new forage. Wisconsin asks for a separate figure for each group, such as mature cows or weaned calves, because each group’s need changes with gestation, calving and growth. Keep one row for each lot, so that a change in one lot changes one row.
On the example farm, 90 cows eat 25 pounds of dry matter a day and 40 heifers eat 16 pounds, all invented figures. That is 2,250 plus 640, or 2,890 pounds a day, which is 1.445 tons. The herd is fed from November 1 and can live on pasture from June 1, which is 212 days. Demand over those 212 days is 306.3 tons.
Set against the 327 tons of the first section, the barn looks to have 20.6 tons to spare, and that comparison is what makes the stock look ample. The June 1 date comes from the pastures: how many animals each one carries, and from when, is the subject of stocking rate by pasture and season. If the pastures are ready two weeks later, demand rises by 14 days of 1.445 tons, which is 20.2 tons, and that alone uses up the apparent surplus.
How much of the stock will never reach the trough?
Loss is dry matter that spoils, leaks, blows away or is trampled between the weighing and the animal’s mouth. Subtract only the loss still ahead of each depot, the part that has not happened yet, which depends on where it was measured. A bale weighed at the baler has all its storage loss and all its feeding loss ahead. A bag counted by loads at the chopper has the filling, fermentation, surface and feed-out losses ahead.
Holmes and Muck, of the University of Wisconsin, break down the loss of silage bags at 60 to 70 percent moisture. Filling loses 1 to 2 percent, fermentation gas 5, the top surface 2 and feed-out 1 to 5. The total is 9 to 14 percent of the dry matter.
The loss is a range, and for bales the range is wide. A Wisconsin article on feed shrink gives the dry matter that big round bales lose in storage. It is 2 to 10 percent under a roof, 4 to 7 wrapped in plastic on the ground, and 6 to 25 uncovered on the ground with net wrap. The feeder adds its own loss. The Wisconsin article by Halfman and colleagues, citing Buskirk and colleagues, lists 20 percent of the hay lost at a ring feeder without a panel and 6 percent at a ring with a panel.
The example farm stores its bales uncovered on the ground with net wrap and feeds them in rings without a panel. The best case keeps 94 percent through storage and 80 percent through the ring, which is 75.2 percent in all, so 24.8 percent is lost. The worst case keeps 75 percent through storage and 80 through the ring, which is 60 percent, so 40 percent is lost. The bag loses 9 to 14 percent. These are university table ranges for those storage types, not measurements of this farm, and a range is only as good as the match between your storage and the one in the table.
| Depot | Measured (t DM) | Loss ahead, low case (%) | Loss ahead, high case (%) | Left to feed, low loss (t DM) | Left to feed, high loss (t DM) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Round bales, uncovered on the ground, ring without panel | 215.0 | 24.8 | 40.0 | 161.7 | 129.0 |
| Silage bag, counted by loads | 112.0 | 9.0 | 14.0 | 101.9 | 96.3 |
| Both depots | 327.0 | 19.4 | 31.1 | 263.6 | 225.3 |
In the worst case 31.1 percent of the barn never reaches a cow. A flat 5 percent taken off the whole barn is below the low end of both ranges, 24.8 and 9.
On what date does it run out, and by when must I buy?
Divide the forage left by the daily demand and count that many days from the first day of feeding. The box does it for the example farm, and the table counts the same barn four ways.
| Way of counting | Left to feed (t DM) | Full days it lasts | Runs out on | Against the need of 306.3 t |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Measured stock, no loss taken off | 327.0 | 226 | June 15 | 20.6 t above |
| Flat 5 percent off the whole barn | 310.6 | 214 | June 3 | 4.3 t above |
| Loss ahead, low case | 263.6 | 182 | May 2 | 42.8 t short |
| Loss ahead, high case | 225.3 | 155 | April 5 | 81.1 t short |
The two ends of the range are 27 days apart, and that width is the information. With no loss taken off, the forage lasts to June 15, two weeks past the day the pastures are ready. Take a flat 5 percent and it lasts to June 3, with a surplus of 4.3 tons, which looks safe. Take the loss ahead and it runs out between April 5 and May 2, 43 to 81 tons short. A farmer who trusts the flat percentage finds the gap in April, with the diet already being cut.
Decide on the early end of the range minus the lead time: the days the farm takes to find, price and haul the hay. With 21 days of lead time, an assumption, April 5 gives March 15. Wisconsin gives the reason not to wait: buying early avoids the winter, when forages are usually priced higher, and the scramble for the last days’ worth of feed.
Even the low-loss case is 42.8 tons short, so the first 50 tons of hay are a purchase to make now. The other 44 tons, about $7,100, are the price of the uncertainty. Buying them early risks paying for hay the herd may not need, and waiting until March 15 risks a cut diet. Weigh the remaining stock again and decide on that date.
The hay feeder is the other thing you can change. Changing the ring without a panel for a ring with a panel cuts the feeding loss from 20 to 6 percent. The early end then moves from April 5 to April 21, and the late end from May 2 to May 21. The high-case shortfall falls from 81.1 to 58.4 tons of dry matter, which is 26 tons of hay or about $4,200. Price the panel against that figure.
What goes on the sheet first, and how often do I redo it?
The sheet has three blocks, one for each question above, and every column has a name.
| Block | One row for each | Columns |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Stock | depot | weight and unit; basis (dry matter or as-fed); dry matter (%); date measured; loss ahead, low and high (%); table the loss comes from; dry matter left, low and high (t) |
| 2. Demand | lot | head count; dry matter per head per day (lb); dry matter per day (lb); days until new forage |
| 3. Dates | end of the range (early, late) | forage left (t DM); full days it lasts; run-out date; shortfall (t DM); hay to buy (t); lead time (days); decision date |
Write the basis of every number, dry matter or as-fed. Reading the bag’s 311 tons as-fed as if they were dry matter adds 138 days to the date, and no one would see it in the total.
Redo the sheet once a month, on the same day. Each month some of the loss that was ahead has moved behind. You weigh what is left and test its dry matter again, the loss still ahead is shorter, and the range of dates closes. Redo it at once when the date the pastures are ready moves or a lot changes size: two weeks on that date alone moved 20 tons of demand.
Start the sheet from the weights and the rations the farm already has.
The demand side of the sheet is the same count of animals that the stocking rate by pasture and season sheet keeps for the grazing months. Whether the forage turned into gain is shown by weighing the lot afterwards, as in How do you know how much weight a cattle lot really gained? The habit of counting what is on hand and comparing it with the record also applies to bought supplies, in How to count farm input stock before you reorder. More on production is in the production articles, and how the farm’s land, animals and money are used toward its goals is the subject of farm management.
Tomorrow, take the scale to a few bales of each batch and write the weights in block 1, and send a sample of each depot for a dry matter test. If a lot has no written ration, Wisconsin recommends a nutritionist for anyone not comfortable balancing one. With weights, tests and rations in hand, filling in the sheet takes an afternoon, and the early end of the range is the date to circle on the calendar. The sheet counts what is in the barn. Whether each lot is served what its ration says is the next sheet: Does the feed each lot gets match the ration?