Holding fed cattle 14 more days, from day 166 to day 180, lost $7.39 a head in a trial of 7,000 head, priced as a live sale. On a lot of 1,000 head that is $7,390. The same 14 days earned $7.25 a head priced by carcass weight. A lot should leave on the day its last pound of gain costs more to produce than that pound sells for, and the sum changes with the way you sell. Write it, with the price you assume, before the lot enters the pen, and list every animal you sell outside it.
A lot is a group of cattle kept and handled together, and days on feed are the days it spends in the pen eating a ration you pay for. If you keep a lot a few days longer than planned and cannot say afterward whether it paid, the sheet below is for you.
When is the last pound of gain not worth its feed?
The last pound of gain is the pound the lot adds in its final days before leaving. Its cost is what the lot costs to keep in those days, divided by the pounds it gained in them. Its value is the price of a pound of cattle on the day you sell. While the value stays above the cost, another day pays. Once the cost passes the value, each further day loses money, even though the lot still weighs more than the day before.
A 2023 article by Grant Crawford in the American Hereford Association’s Handle on Health reports a trial of 7,000 head of feedlot cattle, fed for 166, 180, 194 or 208 days. The costs it counts are feed and yardage, the daily cost of the pen that is not feed. It does not list interest among them. The calculation below takes its live-sale figures and divides them.
The gain in the sum is the lot’s average daily gain, and it is only as good as the weighings behind it. The trial starts at day 166, so it cannot say whether leaving a day earlier would have paid better. It says only that, on a live sale, none of the later days did.
Does the way you sell change the day the lot leaves?
Yes, and the same trial shows it. The cattle and the 14 days were the same, and only the price list changed. Sold by carcass weight, the weight of the animal after slaughter, at $2.20 a pound, the first 14 days earned $7.25 a head and the next lost $0.43. Sold on a grid, the first lost $6.11 and the next lost $27.73.
A grid is a price list for carcasses. It adds premiums for quality and subtracts discounts for the yield grade, a score from 1 to 5 in which grades 4 and 5 are discounted, and for carcasses above a weight limit. Cattle kept longer graded better, but they ran into those discounts.
A 2000 paper by Greer and Trapp of Oklahoma State University points the same way. They ran 467 steers through a growth model, a simulation, under seven real grids and under a flat price paid on every animal. The stay that paid most was 200 days at the flat price and 141 days on average on the grids. On the base grid there was a window of about one week, give or take, in which the lot could leave with no large change in profit.
So a target weight copied from a neighbor can fail, because the neighbor may sell on a different price list. In the rule you write, you name the way you sell.
Why does the last pound cost more than the first?
The animal changes what it grows. Crawford writes that fat gain rises and protein gain falls as cattle mature, and fat holds more energy than muscle, which is mostly water. In the trial he reports, the lot ate about the same each day, 22.5 to 22.8 lb of dry matter. Yet between the 166-day group and the 208-day group, daily gain fell from 3.88 to 3.67 lb, and the feed per pound of gain rose from 5.80 to 6.20 lb. Those are averages of the whole stay, so they hide how bad the end is.
The rise can be steeper. A thesis summary from the National University of Mar del Plata, in Argentina, fed 64 British steers (308 kg at the start) for 64, 91, 119 or 147 days. Backfat, the fat over the ribs, went from 8.0 mm at day 64 to 13.8 mm at day 147. Between those days the feed per kilo of live gain, weighed after an 18-hour fast, went from 9.98 to 15.76 kg. The summary calls it daily feed conversion and does not say whether each figure is that day’s or cumulative from day 0. The author found that the cost of the last pound of gain stayed above the selling price, and recommends selling at 8 mm of backfat.
In Brazil, Embrapa fed young bulls to 400, 440 or 480 kg of live weight. Daily gain fell from 1.56 to 1.44 kg, and the return per month fell from 1.0 to 0.6 percent. Yet the cost of an arroba (15 kg of carcass) produced rose only from R$ 39.14 to R$ 40.49. That average cost rose 3.4 percent while the monthly return fell by 40 percent, so the sum has to be run on the last pound and not on the average.
Which costs belong in the sum besides feed?
Three belong, and one does not. Feed and yardage belong, as in Crawford. The interest on what the animals are worth belongs too, because each day the lot stays you wait for money you could take today. The Greer and Trapp model charged 8.75 percent a year; use your own rate. The money already spent on the lot stays out. It is the same whether the lot leaves today or in two weeks. That is the rule of the break-even price per acre: before you plant every cost counts, and afterward only what is left to spend.
Use your own cost of gain, because the figure moves between farms. In a 2017 note, Karl Hoppe of North Dakota State University worked out $0.32 a pound of feed and $0.48 in total for calves gaining 3 lb a day. He wrote that each feedlot has its own cost structure.
The price matters as much as the cost. Hoppe notes that the price per pound of calves usually falls as they get heavier. If the market dropped $5 at every weight during two or three weeks of feeding, the extra gain was worth having in only two of the weight ranges. The price in your sum is the one you expect on the exit day.
What the sources support, and what they do not. They are feedlot trials and simulations, with prices of 2000, 2001, 2017 and 2023, and they show that the answer moves with the way you sell and that the last pound costs most. None tests whether writing the rule before the lot enters improves a farm’s result, and we found no study that does. The cost per pound of gain above is our own division of the trial’s totals, not a figure the authors report.
What do you write before the lot enters, and what do you keep when it leaves?
Write the rule on one sheet per lot, dated, before the cattle arrive. It holds the way you will sell and the price you assume for that sale. It holds the cost of keeping the lot one day and the gain you expect in its last weeks. It ends with the date on which you will redo the sum.
When the lot leaves, the sheet gets a second part: the list of animals sold on a day outside the rule. Each line has the animal or group, the day or weight the rule gave, the day or weight of the sale, and the money difference. The difference is the value of the pounds gained in those days, less what those days cost; a minus sign is a loss. An example row follows, built on the live-sale figures of the trial.
| Animal or group | Day the rule gave | Day sold | Days past the rule | Value of the gain, less cost of those days | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lot 12, 1,000 head | 166 | 194 | 28 | $111.78 - $131.78 a head | -$20.00 a head, -$20,000 in the lot |
After a few lots, you can read in that list whether the extra days paid on your farm. It is the same habit as writing the lowest price you can take on soybeans before the buyer calls. For grain in a bin the matching question is store or sell now.
Before the lot enters
The rule, dated
- The way you will sell and the price you assume
- The cost of keeping the lot one day
- The gain you expect in the last weeks
- The date on which you will redo the sum
When the lot leaves
Animals sold outside the rule
- The animal or group
- The day or weight the rule gave
- The day or weight of the sale
- The money difference, with a minus for a loss
Before the next lot enters, take the records of your last lot. Divide the cost of each of its last few two-week stretches by the pounds it gained in them, and fill the first four lines. With the records at hand it takes about an hour. If you have no weighings to take the pounds from, start with the average daily gain of that lot. The feed bill of those stretches can be checked against the ration in feed delivered against the ration by lot. More on this side of the farm: farm management and the production library.