The US Department of Agriculture (USDA) reported Oklahoma auction prices for October 9, 2026. Steers of about 526 pounds (239 kg) sold at $3.20 to $4.35 a pound, which makes $1,683 to $2,288 a head. A farmer who culls a cow nobody can vouch for may be sending away a cow that weans a calf like that every year. Five entries on each cow’s card are enough to give the herd a history. They are her own permanent tag, her calving date, her calf’s sex, the calf’s weight at weaning, and the date of each health event.
The first number to write is how many cows have no card at all. Count them on the next handling day, the day the cows go through the chute. Then write the date by which each one will have a card.
What does it cost to cull a cow nobody can vouch for?
The price comes from the USDA’s Oklahoma weekly cattle auction summary of October 9, 2026, which lists 280 steers of 500 to 549 pounds, averaging 526, at $320 to $435 per hundredweight. A hundredweight is 100 pounds. Multiplying the average weight by the price per pound gives the value of one calf at the low and the high end of that range. The price is for steers. The same report lists 384 heifers of 501 to 548 pounds, averaging 529, at $310 to $387, so a mixed set of calves is worth less than the steer range.
In a herd of 200 cows, the cows to cull are named from memory when no card says when each one last calved or what her calf weighed. The box below puts a number on one wrong call, with example counts.
The opposite mistake costs too. A cow that has not weaned a calf in two years keeps eating, and nobody notices because nothing is written down. Whoever keeps cards sees both the good cow that was about to go and the one that should have.
Which five entries does each cow’s card need?
The first entry is the cow herself. The University of Kentucky’s extension publication on production records for beef herds says the first step is to identify each cow, with any combination of marks that is readable from a short distance and permanent. Alabama Extension pairs two marks: an ear tag that is temporary and easy to read, and a permanent mark such as a tattoo. Kentucky describes three methods, and all of them pair marks. They are identical tags in both ears, a tag and a tattoo, or a tag cross-referenced to the vaccination tag. So a cow that loses one tag can still be named. A single tag is not permanent. Without a number that survives, nothing else on the card can be tied to the cow.
The second entry is the calving date, which Kentucky marks as required and accepts as an estimate within three days. The third is the calf’s sex, which Kentucky places in its top category (the most important entries) among the weaning entries. The fourth is the calf’s weight at weaning, written with the date of the weighing. Kentucky puts it bluntly: “Production records are of little value without a weaning weight.” Alabama Extension recommends weighing calves between 160 and 240 days of age and adjusting the weights to 205 days. That correction restates each calf’s weight as if all had been weighed at the same age. The calving date and the weighing date give the age in days, which is what that adjustment needs.
The fifth entry is the date of each health event: a vaccination, a treatment, a pregnancy check. Alabama Extension lists dates, product and dose among the health records a herd keeps, and Kentucky says the pregnancy check shows which cows did not conceive, so that culling options come sooner. The figure shows one cow’s card with example data.
Five entries are a choice, and the choice has a cost. Kentucky also ranks the calving ease score and the cow’s weight and condition score as very useful, and birth weight as useful. It puts a management code and a contemporary group code (a label shared by calves born and handled alike) in its top category, because they let you compare calves on equal terms. With five entries, a light calf may mean a poor milker, a bad pasture year or a first-calf heifer, and you cannot tell the three apart from the card. This article starts with five and adds the others once the five are filled in for two seasons in a row. Before that, a longer card mostly adds blanks.
How do you count the cows with no card?
Read the last calving season’s card of each cow against the five entries. A card is complete when all five are written, partial when one to four are, and absent when none is. A cow that did not calve gets “no calf” and the date of her pregnancy check in the calving, sex and weight entries, and that counts as written. A cow whose calf died before weaning gets the date of the loss and “died” in the weight entry, and that counts as written too.
The Beef Improvement Federation guidelines keep disposal codes for this case, with “born alive, died before weaning” split into disease and other causes, so a lost calf has an entry in a standard system.
Where a cow has been through the herd without anyone writing when she last calved, write “unknown” and never a date from memory. An entry marked unknown is not written, so it counts as empty. Kentucky’s system has a code for the same case, a mark for information the record needs and nobody has.
Do the count on that handling day, with each cow in the chute: read her tag, find her card, and tally the cows in three piles. The weaning rate (calves weaned per cow that was with the bull) asks for the list of cows that were with the bull and the list of calves weaned, and both come from these cards. A cow with no card is a cow whose calf cannot be counted, which is why the weaning rate by season starts from a list of cows. The box below shows a count of 200 cows.
Counting gives you the size of the gap before any cow is tagged, and the date beside the count gives the gap a deadline. The cows already in the herd start their cards on that day. Their past stays “unknown” until the next calving, when the card fills for real.
What can you not read from the card?
You cannot read why a cow failed to calve. Nutrition, health and breeding management are the farmer’s and the veterinarian’s to work out, and no entry on the card diagnoses them. You also cannot rank cows by genetic merit, which needs more entries and more years than the five here.
You can read which cows calved, when, and what their calves weighed at weaning, cow by cow instead of by memory. Alabama Extension says individual animal statistics speed up culling of cows and heifers on performance measurements. That is the use here: with the card, a cull list can be checked against what was written.
A note on the evidence. Both technical sources are extension guidance from universities, and Kentucky’s was issued in 1996. Neither tested whether keeping cards changes the results of a commercial herd, which was not shown and was not refuted either. No source opened for this article counts how many herds keep individual cards, so the number that matters is the one from your own count.
What do you write first, and by when?
The count comes first, on the next handling day, before any tag is bought.
The count needs no extra day, only a tally sheet on a handling day already on the calendar. Count again on the first handling day after the deadline and compare the two counts to see whether the gap closed. The cull rule reads from these cards, as shown in a cull rule written before the cow is open. The dates the bulls stayed are kept in the breeding season, planned against done. For other work with the herd, see the production articles; for the farm as a whole, see farm management. Related: How do you know how much weight a cattle lot really gained?