Skip to content
Assessment
LibraryProduction

When do you cull a cow? Write the rule before she is open

A cow found open still eats for another year. With the order of culling criteria, the cost of keeping a cow and a date written before the breeding season, each cull is checked against the sheet and not decided at the chute.

Published Updated 18 min read
In this article

Keep ten open cows “one more year” and the variable cost alone (feed, minerals and veterinary care) comes to about US$7,000 before a single calf is sold. That is ten times the yearly variable cost of one cow. The Noble Research Institute, a US agricultural research institute, puts it near US$700, from a 2016 report on about 90 herds in Kansas. A cow found open (not pregnant at the pregnancy check) still eats for another year. So write three things before the breeding season starts: the order in which cows leave the herd, the yearly cost of keeping one cow, and the date you will apply both. At weaning, write beside each cow that left which line of the rule you applied, and beside each heifer that came in, where she came from.

To cull is to take a cow out of the breeding herd and sell her. The breeding season is the weeks the bulls run with the cows. The decision is easy to make badly at the chute (the narrow passage where cattle are held for handling), with the cow in front of you and a buyer waiting. If the list was written months earlier and carries a date, you are not deciding at that moment; you are applying it.

In what order should cows leave the herd?

In the order of a list you wrote before you saw the cows. The Noble Research Institute publishes one, by a retired agricultural economics consultant of the institute. It names eight criteria and says to cull in that order until the herd reaches the size you want. A bred cow in the list is one found pregnant.

Figure: The order of eight culling criteria in the Noble Research Institute article
Eight criteria in order: disposition first, open females second, bred cows of 3 to 9 years lastCull in this order until the herd reaches the size you want: 1 disposition, 2 open females, 3 structural soundness, 4 age, 5 bred cows older than 9 years, 6 replacement heifers, 7 phenotype, 8 bred cows of 3 to 9 years.Cull in this order, until the herd is the size you want1Disposition (aggressive animals)2Open females3Structural soundness (feet, eyes, udder)4Age (broken or missing teeth first)5Bred cows older than 9 years6Replacement heifers7Phenotype (how alike the cows look)8Bred cows of 3 to 9 yearsOpen females, in orange, come second

Two points of the order are worth keeping. The open cow comes second, after an aggressive animal and before any cow with a physical fault. And the list runs only until the herd reaches the number you chose, so the rule also needs a count of cows to remove.

Other sources rank differently. Ohio State University’s extension begins with open cows and calf losses, then late calvers, genetics and records, old cows and the physical exam. Embrapa, Brazil’s agricultural research corporation, names reproductive failure as the main criterion: a cow open at the end of the breeding season, found by a pregnancy diagnosis about 30 days after the season ends. The three lists put the open cow first or second. They differ on temperament and on age. Take a published list as a draft and change it to fit your pastures, your handling and the cost of a replacement.

What does it cost to keep a cow that does not wean a calf?

At least her variable cost, which is every cost that stops when she leaves, such as feed, minerals and veterinary care. Noble gives one figure: near US$700 a year, from the Kansas report above. Ohio State’s extension adds a way to see it. An open cow, it says, needs the net return of two to three productive cows to pay for her upkeep. The box shows the calculation that turns the cost into a rule.

Figure: The yearly variable cost of one cow, the value of a calf and the chance of weaning that pays the cost. Hypothetical calf value
A cow costing US$700 a year needs a 35 percent chance of weaning a calf worth US$2,000Calf worth US$2,000 against a yearly variable cost of US$700 per cow. The cost divided by the calf is 35 percent, the lowest chance of weaning a calf that pays the cost.US dollars per cow, one yearCalf weaned (hypothetical)2,000Variable cost of the cow700Chance of a calf that pays the cost35%700 divided by 2,000 is 0.35

The figure depends on the cost you use and on the calf you can expect. The calf value is a round figure for a calf of about 500 pounds. Steers of 505 to 548 pounds sold between US$4.10 and US$4.57 a pound at the Tulsa auction in Oklahoma on 6 October 2026. The cost is not out of line: the USDA Economic Research Service puts the 2025 operating cost at US$676 per cow for the United States. Read 35 in 100 as a floor, because it counts only the cost that stops and not the replacement. With a cheaper calf the threshold climbs: at US$1,100 the same cost needs 64 in 100. A farm that knows its own cost per cow replaces the Kansas number with it and gets its own threshold. The cost comes from the books of the cattle, as in the result of a crop and a cattle enterprise. The same division for a crop, cost over yield, is in the soybean break-even price.

Is a second chance for an open cow worth it?

In the Brazilian data, the more open cows a farm kept, the less calf it weaned per cow exposed. CNA and Senar, Brazil’s farm confederation and its rural training service, with Cepea (the economics center of the University of São Paulo), studied 53 typical cow-calf properties in 2026. They grouped them by the share of open cows kept for the next year. Farms that kept up to 10 percent weaned 76 percent of the cows exposed and 137.9 kg of calf per cow exposed (about 304 lb). Farms that kept more than 60 percent weaned 62 percent and 105.2 kg (about 232 lb). Keeping was common: 42 percent of the 53 farms kept more than 60 percent of their open cows, and 32 percent kept about half.

Figure: Kilograms of calf weaned per cow exposed, by share of open cows kept for the next year. 53 typical cow-calf properties in Brazil
Farms that kept more open cows weaned less calf per cow exposed: 137.9 kg, 117.5, 117.7 and 105.2Kilograms of calf weaned per cow exposed and weaning rate by share of open cows kept: up to 10 percent, 137.9 kg and 76 percent; 10 to 40 percent, 117.5 kg and 66 percent; 40 to 60 percent, 117.7 kg and 67 percent; more than 60 percent, 105.2 kg and 62 percent.Kg weaned per cow exposed, and weaning rateOpen cows kept: up to 10%137.976% weanedOpen cows kept: 10 to 40%117.566% weanedOpen cows kept: 40 to 60%117.767% weanedOpen cows kept: more than 60%105.262% weanedKilograms per cow exposed

Do not read this as proof. These are properties observed as they were, not a trial. The report links high retention to farms with no defined breeding season, with the bulls running with the cows all year, and to giving a cow “one more chance”. The two middle groups are level, at 117.5 and 117.7 kg. The pattern still points one way, and it is the pattern the written cost line predicts.

Embrapa treats the second chance as a rule written by class of cow. Its article advises no second chance for a heifer that does not conceive, and none for a cow that failed in the last season and has no calf at her side. A mature cow with a calf at her side may get one on her first failure. The first-calf cow, still growing and the most demanding in feed, deserves the chance to stay if she does not conceive; if she fails again, she is treated as a cow without a calf. How many chances to give, the article says, is a management decision for each property. Ohio State’s extension adds the very young cow: a manager may give an exceptional open cow another chance if she is very young, because of the cost of a replacement. Write one line of the rule for each class: heifer, first-calf cow, mature cow with a calf at her side, cow without one, and the very young cow if you allow her.

Which class is the open cow in?

Heifer that did not conceive

No second chance

Cow that failed last season, with no calf at her side

No second chance

Mature cow with a calf at her side

May get one chance on her first failure

First-calf cow

Stays if she does not conceive

If she fails again, she is treated as a cow without a calf

Exceptional cow that is very young

A manager may give another chance

Because of the cost of a replacement

One line of the rule for each class, as Embrapa and the Ohio State extension describe it. How many chances to give is a management decision for each property.

The counterweight comes from another environment. Nazar Anchorena, an adviser to farmer groups in La Pampa, Argentina, wrote in 2009 about semi-arid natural range. An open cow, he says, costs 0.85 cow equivalent (the forage one cow eats) until she is pregnant again. Raising a replacement from weaned calf to pregnant heifer costs about 2.1. Where a replacement is dear and forage is short, a second chance can cost less than a new heifer. It is the work of an adviser and not a peer-reviewed study, and it concerns that kind of range. The 2.1 and the 0.85 are his figures for his range; check them against what a replacement heifer costs you.

So the second chance is not banned; it is written. Say which cows get it, how many times, and with what chance of weaning a calf, using the threshold from your own sheet, which is 35 in 100 with the figures of the box.

Should the rule have an age limit?

Only if your own records show one. Until then, use the body of the cow. The sources part on the number. Noble says cows are most productive from 4 to 9 years and puts broken or missing teeth first when culling by age. Ohio State’s extension says the average cow pays for herself at 6 and urges caution with culling by age when replacements cost a lot. Erol, Dillon and Burdine, agricultural economists, built a model of a cow-calf herd in the southern United States, published in 2024. Its base case, the scenario it starts from, culls cows older than 10 and cows that fail to calve once they reach 7. The best choice changes with fertility, prices, the cost of replacements and the use of pregnancy diagnosis.

Figure: Ages named by three sources, in years. Noble: most productive years. Ohio State: age at which the average cow has paid for herself. Erol and colleagues: age above which the base case culls
Three sources, three ages: most productive from 4 to 9, paid for at 6, cull above 10On a scale of 2 to 12 years: Noble names 4 to 9 years as the most productive; Ohio State says the average cow pays for herself at 6; the base case of Erol, Dillon and Burdine culls cows older than 10.Age of the cow, in years24681012NobleMost productive from 4 to 9 yearsOhio StateThe average cow pays for herself at 6Model, United StatesBase case culls above 10 years

Each figure is right for the farms it came from. A model is not your herd, and an extension article is not your cost. So the position here is this: write an age line only after your own sheet shows it, and until then write a physical test, such as teeth and condition. You can see it on your sheet when the weaning rate is split by age group, as in weaned calves per cow exposed. If cows of 9 years wean as often as cows of 6 on your farm, an age limit of 8 removes cows that still pay.

What do you write first, and in how long?

The cost of one cow and the order of criteria, in an afternoon, from last year’s list of cows that left. The rule has two parts. Before the season: the date, the yearly cost of one cow with its source and the order of criteria. Then the chances an open cow gets, the number of cows to remove and the number of heifers to bring in. Replacement means heifers that take the place of cows that leave. Embrapa sets its ceiling at 20 to 30 percent of the cows a year, because an excess of yearling heifers becomes an excess of first-calf cows the next year. At weaning, for each cow that left: her tag, the date, the number of the criterion you applied and the price received. For each heifer that came in: her tag, where she came from and the date.

Figure: The culling sheet with hypothetical entries, before the season and at weaning
A sheet with five lines before the season and four entries for each cow that leavesBefore the season: date of the rule, yearly cost of one cow, order of criteria, chances for an open cow, cows out and heifers in. At weaning, for each cow that left: tag, date, number of the criterion applied, price received.Before the seasonDate of the rule6 JanuaryCost of one cow, one yearUS$700, NobleOrder of criteria1 to 8Chance for an open cowfirst failure onlyCows out, heifers in20 out, 20 inAt weaning, each cow that leftTag0412Date14 OctoberCriterion applied2, openPrice receivedyour sale slip

Noble advises evaluating all breeding females at least once a year, and weaning is likely the most convenient time. Embrapa places the pregnancy diagnosis about 30 days after the end of the breeding season. The sheet takes both: the open cows are known at the diagnosis, and the other criteria are checked at weaning, against the list.

You see what the record is worth when you count the exceptions. Say that last year 18 cows left: 11 open, 3 for feet, 2 for teeth, 1 for temperament and 1 because she “looked thin”. The last has no line in the list. One cow of 18 left for a reason the rule does not hold. If that happens often, the rule lacks a criterion, such as body condition. Add it for the next season, with a new date, never for the cows that already left.

A caution on the evidence. The order of criteria comes from an extension article by a consultant. The cost per cow is a 2016 average of farms in Kansas. The link between keeping open cows and weaning less comes from typical properties observed in Brazil, where other differences between farms may explain part of it. The age figures come from an article, a model and an extension letter. None of these sources tested whether writing the rule before the season changes the result of a commercial herd. That has not been shown, and it has not been disproved. Whether the rule pays on your farm, only a test on your own farm can tell, for instance applying it for two seasons and comparing the culls with the rule.

The first cull under the rule is the first entry on the sheet. The rule reads each cow’s record from the cow’s card, and the exposure dates from the breeding season, planned against done. For other work on the herd, see the production articles; for the farm as a whole, see farm management. Related: How do you know what a cattle lot really gained?

Provenance

Derives from
  1. Childs, Guidelines for culling cows, Noble Research Institute (undated)
  2. Workman and Boyles, Strategic Culling Methods, Ohio BEEF Cattle Letter, Ohio State University Extension, 17 May 2000, updated 6 August 2015
  3. Nicacio, Qual o melhor critério para descarte de matrizes?, AG: a revista do criador, no. 227, Embrapa, June 2019
  4. CNA and Senar, Ativos do Campo 2026: O custo da improdutividade, vacas vazias e seus reflexos no COT, prepared by Cepea-Esalq/USP, September 2026
  5. Erol, Dillon and Burdine, Optimal Beef Cow Culling Strategies in the U.S.: A Dynamic Linear Programing Framework, Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics 56(3), 463-479, 2024
  6. USDA Economic Research Service, Commodity Costs and Returns, cow-calf operating costs per cow, 2025
  7. USDA AMS, Tulsa Livestock Auction, Livestock Weighted Average Report, 6 October 2026 (the address always shows the latest weekly report)
  8. Nazar Anchorena, Bases para el aumento de la rentabilidad en cría. Nuevos enfoques, CREA Carro Quemado-Luan Toro, Sitio Argentino de Producción Animal, 2009
What this article covers
Writing the culling and replacement rule before the breeding season: the criteria in order, the variable cost of keeping one cow for a year, the chance of weaning a calf that pays for it, the chances you give to an open cow and to which group, the number of cows to remove and of heifers to replace them, the date the rule starts, and a record of each cow that left with the criterion applied and of each heifer that entered.
What it does not cover
Which age is the right one to cull at, because the studies disagree and this article does not choose a number. It also leaves out which genetic criteria to select on, the weaning rate itself (see the article on weaned calves per cow exposed), the individual record of each cow, and which heifers to pick for replacement.
Published
Updated
Error found
Point out an error and the article is corrected with a note on what changed.

How to cite this article

Rurivia. (2026, October 28). When do you cull a cow? Write the rule before she is open. https://rurivia.com/en/library/production/cull-rule-written-before-the-cow-is-open/


Keep reading

Production

How to tell if your crop rotation is working

Checking that the planned crop went into the field tells you the plan was followed, not whether it worked. For that, the plan has to say, field by field, which pest or disease the rotation is meant to hold back, when the result will be measured and what goes in if planting runs late.

Sep 7, 2026
Production

Which animals share a lot, and by what rule?

Fifty calves weaned the same day average 604 pounds, and none of the four groups inside that lot weighs 604. A rule written before the lot is formed, and an animal list checked against it on a date, is what lets the average say something.

Oct 28, 2026
Production

Do you have enough forage to last until spring grass?

A full silage bag and a stack of bales say little about how long the forage lasts. Weigh each depot in dry matter, subtract the loss still ahead of it, divide by what the lots eat each day, and decide to buy at the early end of the date range.

Oct 27, 2026
Production

What goes on a pest scouting sheet for the season?

Spraying by the calendar leaves no record of why. A weekly count written next to an action level set beforehand turns each spray, or each wait, into a decision you can check at the end of the season.

Oct 27, 2026

Farm Management

If this article were a plant, farm management would be the whole field.

Planning, organizing, leading and controlling: the four functions, what each one decides, and a farm example for each, all on one page.