A dairy ration that cost US$ 5.49 a cow a day on paper cost US$ 6.05 once the typical feed losses were counted, a difference of 56 cents a cow a day. On 80 cows fed that ration that is US$ 44.80 a day, and it reaches the farmer only as a higher feed bill at the end of the month. To see the difference the day it appears, write for each lot and each day how much feed the ration calls for and how much left the store. Then work out the gap as a percentage. Write also, before the first gap, the level at which the ration is reviewed and who decides.
That figure comes from a text on feed center design by Brouk, published on a United States extension site about dairy cows. It marks how large the difference can be, and says nothing of what yours is. A lot is a group of cattle fed together. The ration is the daily amount of each feed one animal is to receive, written by the animal scientist or veterinarian who sets the diet. The store is wherever the feed waits before it goes out: silo, shed, bale stack or bag.
On the sheet you compare those two amounts for each lot and each day. What the ration should contain stays with the animal scientist. Weighing the animals is still needed, because it measures the result.
What goes on the sheet for each lot?
The sheet has one line per lot per day. Each line holds the date and the head count. It holds the amount the ration calls for (the amount per head times the head count) and the amount that left the store. Then come the gap in kilograms, the gap in percent of the planned amount, what is left at the feeder, and a note. The gap is the amount withdrawn less the amount planned, so a gap above zero means more feed left the store than the ration calls for.
Use the same weight basis on both sides: as fed (the weight as it comes out of the store, with its water) or dry matter (the weight without water). Brouk warns that for every 1 percent change in moisture, the dry matter of a feed moves by 1.16 to 2.78 percent. Hay that dries in the shed or takes rain moves the gap on its own.
The withdrawn amount must be a measured weight. A Wisconsin Extension newsletter by Halfman and colleagues advises weighing a few bales of each batch instead of using book values, because bales vary with the baler, the operator and the type of hay.
The example is a lot of 80 beef cows fed round-bale hay in winter. Every amount of feed is invented, and none is measured on a real lot. Only the hay price is real, from one auction.
A line of the sheet looks like this. A Nebraska Extension article by Laborie asks that the bunk records hold the feed deliveries and the bunk readings of at least the previous four days, so keep the lines of one lot together.
| Date | Head | Planned (kg) | Left the store (kg) | Gap (kg) | Gap (%) | Left at the feeder | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Example day | 80 | 1,040 | 1,240 | 200 | 19.2 |
On that line the lot took 19.2 percent more hay from the store than the ration calls for. Where the 200 kg went is the next question.
Where does the gap between the ration and the store go?
The 1,240 kg that left the store split into what the cows ate and what was lost on the way. On the sheet you see only the total. Brouk defines shrink, after Dutton, as the feed on a farm that the rations of the animals do not account for. Brouk lists causes such as errors in the weight delivered, discarded feed, feed scattered by tires and mixing errors.
Brouk also reports that shrink may reach 15 to 20 percent of the total feed cost on a dairy. The same text is the source of the US$ 5.49 and US$ 6.05 above. Halving the loss on each ingredient brought the cost down to US$ 5.75, which is 30 cents a cow a day.
Wisconsin Extension lists typical hay loss by feeder type, from a study it cites. The loss is 20 percent in a ring feeder without a panel, 15 in a cradle feeder and 11.5 in a feeder wagon. It is 6 percent in a ring with a panel and 3 in a cone feeder with a panel. Applied to the example lot, the same 1,240 kg can mean opposite things.
| Feeder (hay lost) | Lost, kg | Eaten, kg | Eaten per cow, kg | Against the 1,040 kg planned |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ring without panel (20%) | 248 | 992 | 12.4 | 4.6% under |
| Ring with panel (6%) | 74 | 1,166 | 14.6 | 12.1% over |
| Cone with panel (3%) | 37 | 1,203 | 15.0 | 15.7% over |
With the ring feeder without a panel, the cows ate less than the ration while 19.2 percent more hay left the store. With the cone feeder, they ate 15.7 percent more than the ration. One line on the sheet can mean a lot short of feed or a lot overfed. The loss values are typical ones by feeder type, not measurements on this lot, so read the table as a range, not as the answer.
What separates the cases is a reading at the feeder. In a feedlot it is a reading of the bunk (the trough where the feed is put) before the next feeding. The Embrapa chapter on feeding strategies for beef cattle says leftover feed in the bunk means loss, and that a clean bunk takes more attention and management. So the line carries a column for what is left, and the gap is read together with it.
How big a gap is too big?
None of the sources gives a tolerance for the gap on a beef lot, so the limit comes from the lot’s own record. In the first seven days, write the sheet and change nothing. The example lot had gaps of 17, 21, 19, 20, 18, 19 and 20 percent, 19 on average. That is the usual gap of this lot with this feeder.
A usual gap of 19 percent is reason to look at how the hay is fed and whether the feeder should stay. The table above gives what the same hay would lose in another feeder, and the farmer decides what a change is worth. That decision is separate from the ration.
The limit is for the day the gap leaves its usual range. Set it a few points above the highest day of the first week, which was 21 percent, so 25 percent in the example. Apply it in both directions. A day 25 percent under the plan matters as much as a day 25 percent over, because the lot may be eating less than it should.
For scale, Brouk sets a target of 2 to 4 percent shrink for most ingredients other than forages on a dairy, and under 10 percent for fermented forage. Those targets are for shrink, the feed that no ration accounts for. The gap on the sheet also holds any change in how much the animals eat, so it should not be read against them.
In the example, the gap reached 26, 27 and 29 percent on days 8, 9 and 10. A cold spell could have made the cows eat more, a feeder could have broken, or a bale could have been heavier than the ones weighed. You cannot tell which from the sheet. So write beforehand who looks, and when.
What do you write as the review trigger, and who decides?
If the ration is reviewed only when the weighing shows poor gain, the review comes weeks after the feeding. With the weighing sheet of a cattle lot you learn the result after the feeding is over. With the feed sheet you learn the input every day, and the trigger turns that daily reading into an action with a date.
Three sources show the shape such a rule can take. A North Dakota State University Extension article says that keeping records over the years of what each pound of gain costs and how the steers perform gives the confidence that helps avoid over-reacting. An Argentine guide to reading the feed bunk advises waiting for at least three repetitions of the same reading before raising the feed by 3 to 5 percent in a pen. It notes that a consumption error can take two or three days to show, and it asks for the last five days on the sheet.
The Embrapa chapter calls for the bunk to be read before the first feeding of the morning and at night, between 10 p.m. and midnight, with a score recorded for each lot. In its conservative scheme, each score changes the feed by 1 or 2 kg a head. Those adjustments are a feedlot decision for the animal scientist. The article takes from the three sources only the form: a fixed reading at a fixed hour, a number of repeats before acting, and a named person. The numbers in the trigger below are the example lot’s, and no source sets them.
| Part of the trigger | Written on the sheet |
|---|---|
| Reading | Gap between the hay planned and the hay withdrawn, in percent, every day, with what is left at the feeder |
| Limit | 25 percent over or under the plan |
| Repeats | Three days running |
| First check | Head count, weight of the bales and the feeder, by the person named below |
| Who decides | The manager, by name and phone number, asks the animal scientist to review the ration |
| By when | Within 3 days of the third day over the limit |
After three days over the limit you have checked the cheaper explanations, and you ask the person who can change the ration to look. A cold spell that raises appetite is a good reason to change the ration, and the animal scientist decides.
The sources show how large feed losses can be, in dairy cows in the United States and in hay feeders in Wisconsin. They show how a bunk reading can become a rule with a number of repeats. They do not show that keeping this sheet lowers the feed bill of a commercial lot, and none of them gives a tolerance for the gap. Whether 25 percent is the right limit for your lot is a test you run on your own sheet.
What do you write first, and how soon?
Start this week with the lot that costs the most to feed. You need the ration on paper, a known weight for what you withdraw, and ten minutes a day.
If the store runs out sooner than the ration says it should, enough forage until the next harvest sets the forage stock against the demand of each lot. For the pasture the same lots graze, the stocking rate by pasture and season says how many head it carries. The same comparison of the record against what is in the shed, for the inputs of the cropland, is in does your input stock match the record. To see what the lot earns against what it costs, read crop and cattle result by enterprise. Keeping the sheet is part of farm management, and more records of the production side are in the production library.