On the example farm below, field N-04 took three different brands of herbicide in three seasons, and all three hit the weed at the same target. Changing the brand does not change the group. To see it, copy the group number printed on each product’s label into one line per application, next to the field and the date, then read that column down each field.
The invoice carries the brand name, the work order carries the brand name and the folder is filed by brand, so the history reads as three products. The label carries what the brand does not: the mode of action group, the family of products that attack the pest or weed at the same target (the site of action). The numbers here come from an illustrative farm, not from data.
Why does changing the brand not change the group?
Because the resistance committees count groups, not brands. The herbicide committee (HRAC) says that products for the same weed should come from different modes of action in successive applications or in mixtures. Repeating a herbicide, or any other with the same site of action, lets the few resistant plants in a field survive and set seed. After several such sprays the resistant plants can take over the field.
The insecticide committee (IRAC) puts it by generation, in its advice on caterpillar pests (lepidopteran species). Several sprays can fit in one spray window (a block set by the crop stage and the pest’s biology). But it is generally essential that successive generations of the pest are not treated with compounds from the same group. CropLife International, the industry association behind the label icon, says the group lets you identify products with the same mode of action, and these should not be used repetitively.
| Season | Product | Group on the label |
|---|---|---|
| 2023 | Brand A | 15 (K3) |
| 2024 | Brand C | 15 |
| 2025 | Brand D | 15 |
The repeat is not automatically a mistake. The HRAC guideline asks to avoid continued use of the same site of action in the same field, unless it is combined with other weed control practices. A group can also be the only one registered for the crop and the weed, or the only one that fits the budget. Marking a repeat does not condemn it: it leaves the choice, made on purpose, to you and your agronomist.
What goes on each line of the sheet, and where does each entry come from?
Each line is one application on one field, and each entry is copied from a document that already exists. The field code comes from the field register, so that N-04 means the same area in every season. The reason comes from the scouting sheet: write the scouting count of pests that triggered the spray, or write “calendar” or “preventive” when there was none.
The group is the entry that has to come from the label. Insecticides and nematicides use the IRAC numeric groups, fungicides the numeric code of the fungicide committee (FRAC) and herbicides the HRAC numeric groups, so write which system the sheet uses in its header. For herbicides there is a trap: HRAC changed from letters to numbers, and CropLife recommends that countries that already printed letters show both for an interim period, for example Group 15 (K3). A shed holds old and new containers, so copy the number and, when the label prints one, the old letter.
Not every label prints a group. CropLife wrote that group labeling was a regulatory requirement in only a small number of countries, which may have changed since. Brazil is one that requires it, in a ministry act from 2017 that put a group code on the label and leaflet of insecticides, fungicides and herbicides (Carvalho and colleagues, 2019). When your label has no group, look up its active ingredient in the committee’s list, and write that the group came from the list.
Does the product's label print a group?
Yes
Copy the number from the label
On herbicides, the old letter too, if printed
No
Look up the active ingredient in the committee's list
Write that the group came from the list
Copy the PPE from the label too. Each product has its own protective equipment on the label. In the United States the employer must provide handlers the protective equipment the label requires (NC State Extension, on the federal worker protection rule). That rule also sets a use record kept for two years. It lists product, active ingredient, registration number, restricted-entry interval (how long people must stay out of the field after a spray), crop, field and start and end times. The sheet adds the group and the reason to that list. Check the record rule that applies where you farm.
How do you read the sheet for repeats?
Read the group column down one field at a time, and mark the field when a group matches the field’s previous application, including the last application of the season before. On the example farm, five fields received 14 applications last season. Three fields carry a mark.
| Field | Applications | Group matches the field’s previous application | Applications with a count written before |
|---|---|---|---|
| N-04 | 3 | Yes | 1 |
| N-07 | 4 | Yes | 3 |
| S-02 | 2 | Yes | 2 |
| S-05 | 3 | No | 3 |
| E-01 | 2 | No | 2 |
A mark means “look here”, not “wrong”. The limit changes with the pest and the product. For insecticides, the CropLife label example allows more than one spray of the same group inside one application window, recommending no more than two. The window is one pest generation or, when unknown, about 30 days. For herbicides, HRAC asks to limit the number of applications of one site of action in a season. The label and your agronomist’s program set the number. You compare the count with that number, and the date column lets you check the window.
What a mark leads to has a cost. The Brazilian study notes that swapping to another group helps only if the new product matches the efficacy, selectivity, weed spectrum, residual activity and cost the farm needs. HRAC adds that rotating herbicides alone is not enough. Where the weed already resists by breaking the herbicide down (metabolic resistance), that breakdown can span several groups, and such cases need a knowledgeable advisor. Take the marked fields to the visit, and leave the choice of product and dose to the agronomist, as what the agronomist decides explains.
The last column allows a second reading. Three of the 14 applications had no count written before them. They may have been planned sprays, such as a pre-emergence herbicide, but now you hold the list of them, and you check each one against the scouting sheet.
Does keeping the sheet delay resistance?
No source behind this article tests whether keeping the sheet delays resistance. The HRAC guideline lists among the farmer’s duties to keep detailed field records so that cropping and herbicide history is known, and it does not measure whether farms that keep them see resistance later. HRAC is an industry initiative run by agrochemical companies, which sell the products the guideline advises rotating. IRAC and CropLife prescribe rotation by group and the group on the label, and do not test a farm sheet. NC State describes a compliance rule, not a resistance result. The Brazilian study describes the label code and argues that it eases the choice of products, without a field test.
Not having a test is not evidence that the sheet fails. The case for it is smaller and firmer. Without the sheet, the question of whether a group repeated on a field has no answer, because in a folder filed by brand the group is written nowhere. That is a reason to keep it, and not a promise about resistance.
Where to start
One afternoon with last season’s work orders, the invoices and the labels in the shed gives you the first version: one line per application and a list of the marked fields.
Book the agronomist’s visit now and write its date in the sheet’s header: that date is the deadline for the lines to be done and the fields marked. The next job is the sprays that had no count, and it starts at the scouting sheet, where the action level is written before any spray. Knowing what went on each field is part of managing the farm as a business; other articles on the fields are in the production section of the library. Related: How to tell if your crop rotation is working, for the rotation plan this sheet does not replace. Related: How to count farm input stock before you reorder, for the product that leaves the shed with each line.