When crops and cattle share a plot, the result of each (what it sold minus what it cost) depends on how their shared costs are divided. Shared costs are the ones a single purchase covers for both, such as planting fertilizer or herbicide. So the rule for dividing them, the split rule, has to be written before you work out the crop’s result or the cattle’s. This article shows how to fill in a sheet for one plot. It has a column for the crop, one for the cattle and one for the plot, and you check that the first two add up to the third. On the example plot, the cattle end the year with a $200 profit under one split and a $300 loss under another, while the plot stays at $6,200 either way.
Why is one result for the whole farm not enough?
Because the same total can come from very different work. Poffenbarger and co-authors calculated revenue and costs of four systems for a 405-hectare parcel (about 1,000 acres) in central Iowa from 2008 to 2015, using data from a long-term experiment. The work is in a 2017 paper in the journal Agricultural Systems. Two were a two-year rotation of corn and soybeans, with and without cattle. Two were a four-year rotation that adds oats and alfalfa, also with and without cattle. In all four, the net return (what is left after every cost except land and the farmer’s own management) was about the same, around $790 per hectare (about $320 per acre).
The systems with cattle swung more from year to year and needed more labor. The two-year rotation with cattle needed 217 percent more than the same rotation without, which is more than three times the labor.
A French study points the same way. Ryschawy and co-authors, in a 2012 paper in the journal animal, compared 48 farms in a farming region of southwest France. Farms that mixed crops and livestock did not have a statistically higher gross margin (sales minus the costs that vary with output) than specialized farms. They were less sensitive to price swings than dairy farms and crop-only farms. For both papers only the abstract is open, so the figures here come from the abstracts. How much of your revenue rides on a single price is a different calculation, in how many sources your revenue leans on.
In both studies, a similar bottom line came with different labor and different risk. A total alone does not tell you how much each activity added to it. Mendonça and co-authors warned of this in a 2020 paper in the Brazilian journal Revista Brasileira de Zootecnia. Without a detailed account of the cost of each activity, they wrote, the claim that crop and cattle together are economically viable can mislead. The advantage of one activity may conceal the inefficiency of the other. What you need, then, is a result for each activity, side by side, on the same plot.
Which costs and goods do the crop and the cattle share?
Three kinds, and each is handled differently.
The first kind is an input that a single purchase covers for both. In an experiment in the state of São Paulo, Brazil, Mendonça and co-authors grew corn with pasture grass sown alongside it. The planting fertilizer and the herbicide applied before planting served both. They divided each in half between the two activities, and wrote that the division was needed to get a cost for each activity.
The second kind is what one activity hands to the other: manure from the herd that fertilizes the crop, the farm’s own pasture that feeds the cattle, straw the cattle eat. None of it has an invoice, so each needs a price. The FAO handbook on farm cost of production comes from the United Nations food and agriculture agency. It says manure counts as a cost of the crop and as a product of the cattle, both at market prices. The same amount sits on each side, so the plot’s total does not move.
Own pasture is valued at what the farmer would receive by renting the land out for grazing, or at the local rate for commercial grazing. Straw and other feed grown on the farm may have no market at all. Then you set the price yourself and write it down.
The third kind is fixed costs that both activities need: the tractor and shed, the interest on the money invested in them, the fences, the land. They do not rise or fall with what either activity produces. Mendonça and co-authors divided them by the kilograms of product (kilograms of corn plus kilograms of live weight) and wrote that they found no study comparing ways of dividing them. In their experiment the fences, troughs and pens for the herd weighed heavily on the fixed costs.
A basis you can write in one line is enough to start: kilograms of product, months of land use or share of revenue, chosen once, with the reason, and kept the same every year. Choosing the best basis is the subject of another article, The split rule written first; here one written basis is all you need.
Labor is a shared cost too, since the same people work for both, and it also needs a written basis. Take a labor cost recorded as one total, with no split by activity. For a farm mixing crops and cattle, the FAO handbook says gross revenue is the better basis for dividing it, because area shares do not reflect the economic activity of each. A basis that follows revenue has a catch: when the cattle price rises, the cattle are charged a larger share of the labor, though nobody worked more. Write the basis on the sheet and change it only on purpose.
How much can the split change which activity looks like the loser?
Enough to turn a profit into a loss. Take plot 7 of a farm made up for this example: 100 acres (about 40 hectares) of corn with pasture grass sown alongside it, which the cattle graze after the harvest. Start with each activity’s own margin, what it sold minus the costs only it caused: $9,000 for the corn and $3,200 for the cattle.
Two inputs serve both: planting fertilizer at $4,500 and herbicide at $1,500, $6,000 in all. The plot as a whole ends the year at $9,000 plus $3,200 minus $6,000, or $6,200. Mendonça and co-authors divided inputs like these in halves in their experiment. Here the $6,000 is divided two ways.
Neither cattle result is the true one. Each follows from its rule, and the arithmetic alone cannot say which rule to pick. So write the rule before the result and keep it for next year. Then, when the cattle result changes from one year to the next, you know the cause was not a new way of dividing the costs.
In the São Paulo experiment, the pasture cost less per year (its cost spread over the years it lasts) in the systems that mixed crops and cattle than in the cattle-only system. The authors attribute this to the planting fertilizer and the herbicide being divided with the corn. There a cattle figure changed with the way an input was divided, and a written rule is what lets you see when that happens.
How solid is the evidence behind this sheet?
The evidence is thin, and none of it tests the sheet itself. The sheet rests on the arithmetic of the accounts and on four cost and economic studies. The São Paulo experiment of Mendonça and co-authors covered one corn cycle and looked at cost only, leaving revenue out. The others are the Iowa analysis and the French survey of 48 farms. The fourth is a comparison by Reis and co-authors in a 2017 paper in Portuguese of the economics of a crop-and-cattle system and a crop-only system in Mato Grosso, a Brazilian farming state.
The crop-only farm there is a typical one worked out on paper from regional cost surveys, and the crop-and-cattle farm is a reference unit followed by Embrapa, Brazil’s public agricultural research agency. Some of the authors work for a network that promotes crop-and-cattle farming, so read that paper as a claim to check, not as an independent test.
None of these studies compares a farm that works out a result for each activity with a similar farm that does not, and none looks at a grain farm outside that one reference unit. That none of them tests the sheet does not mean it fails. It means the sheet rests on plain arithmetic, which works wherever crops and cattle share land, and not on a trial.
What goes on the sheet, and where do you start?
Start with one plot and one year. A plot that carries only a crop or only cattle needs no split, so the sheet is for plots that carry both in the same year. First get the plot’s result before dividing anything: everything the plot sold in the year minus everything it spent, crop and cattle together. On plot 7 that is $6,200. Then fill in three columns: the crop, the cattle and the plot. The planting and grazing dates, or the rotation plan if you keep one, tell you which crop and which pasture the plot carried that year.
If a tractor works for both, note its hour-meter reading at the start and end of each job. Use what repairs cost per machine to turn the hours into a cost per hour, and charge each activity the hours it used at that cost.
The example sheet below carries only the shared inputs, to keep the arithmetic short. Each good that passes between the two, each share of labor and each fixed cost gets a row of its own in the same way, with its rule written beside it. The other records a farm keeps beside this sheet are in the farm management section.
A cattle result with its rule written beside it can be compared with next year’s; one without the rule can only be believed. The cattle side takes two more rules written first: whether the feed each lot gets matches the ration and when a cow is culled. Other articles on farm money are in the finance section of the library. Related: Rank fields by contribution margin, then test the order. Related: Income statement by crop: three results, not one.