Before the first visit of the season, write on the pest scouting sheet the action level of each pest: the pest count at which you spray. Then, at each weekly visit (scouting: a walk through the field to count what is there), write the count beside the level and the decision after it: spray or wait. With the sheet filled in this way, every spray, and every wait, has a count and a reason beside it, and you check it all at the end of the season. In Paraná, Embrapa (Brazil’s public agricultural research company) runs a weekly scouting program. Over 11 seasons, the program’s soybean fields had a pest control cost of 1.8 sacks a hectare, against 3.8 on fields outside it. That compares two groups, not an experiment.
Embrapa Soja, the soybean unit of Brazil’s public agricultural research company, notes that many farmers still spray insecticide by the calendar, on fixed dates, whatever the count. Whoever sprays this way leaves nothing on paper about whether the count was at the level when they sprayed. This article gives the sheet and the rule for filling it. It gives no levels, products or doses: those are local, and they come from your agronomist or extension service.
In Paraná, a state in southern Brazil, soybean fields in Embrapa’s integrated pest management program averaged 1.7 insecticide applications a season over 11 seasons, against 3.6 on fields outside it. The program asks for weekly counts and spraying only at the action level. That compares two groups of fields and is not an experiment, and the program also had trained technicians and weekly visits, so the gap cannot be attributed to the sheet alone.
What goes on the sheet every week?
One row per visit, one sheet per field. The top of the sheet is filled once, before the first visit: the action level for each pest and crop stage, with its source. Each visit then adds one row with the columns below.
| Column | What you write |
|---|---|
| Date and crop stage | The day and the growth stage, on the same scale all season |
| Count | The count at each sampling point (a spot in the field, such as one meter of row), by pest and by size, and the number of points visited |
| Natural enemies | The beneficial insects counted at the same points |
| Defoliation | An estimate of the leaf area eaten |
| Rain since the last visit | Millimeters read from your own rain gauge |
| Action level | Copied from the top of the sheet, for this pest and this stage |
| Decision | Spray or wait |
| Reason | Why you sprayed or waited, in a few words; always written when the count did not decide it |
| Applied | If you sprayed: date, product and dose, copied from the application record |
The Embrapa program runs with the Paraná Rural Development Institute (IDR-Paraná, which provides the state’s rural extension). Its technicians inspect at least weekly and record pest density, natural enemies, defoliation and crop stage on sheets or notebooks. They take at least ten points in each inspection, one meter of row each, spread to represent the whole area. The counting method depends on the crop. In soybean they look at young plants by eye and use a beat cloth, a cloth laid between rows onto which plants are shaken, on older ones. For another crop, ask for the counting method and the number of points together with the level.
Never leave the decision empty: it is the column you will read at the end of the season. When the count is at or above the level and you spray, or below it and you wait, the Reason can simply say so, as in the figure below. When you spray with the count below the level, or wait with it above, write the real reason in a few words, for example rain on the way or a crew that could not come.
Does the action match the count against the level?
Spray at or above the level, or wait below it
The Reason can simply say so
Spray below the level, or wait above it
Write the real reason
In a few words, such as rain on the way
Where does the action level come from, and why not copy one?
The action level comes from someone who knows your crop, your pest and your region. It goes on the sheet before the first visit, with that person’s name and the source. Do not confuse it with a second number, the economic injury level, which is the count at which the cost of control equals the benefit. The definition comes from a chapter on integrated pest management in a pasture manual, by a researcher at INTA, Argentina’s public agricultural technology institute. The action level sits below the injury level, because the pest keeps growing between the visit and the spray.
NC State Extension, the extension service of North Carolina State University, adds a point about return. Spraying at the action level is the approach with the best return on the money spent on control, and it may or may not give the highest yield. Waiting until the count reaches the injury level may give the highest yield, but not necessarily the best return.
Price moves the level. CropWatch, the University of Nebraska-Lincoln’s extension site, notes that the economic injury level falls when the crop price rises, with nothing else changed, and that action levels often sit near 80% of that injury level.
CropWatch gives the soybean aphid as an example. Soybean entomologists in the US Midwest recommended keeping its action level at 250 aphids per plant, despite the price rise of 2008. When that level was set, growers had a week to spray before the pest reached the injury level. At the higher soybean prices, that time fell to four or five days. The rule of this sheet follows from that, and CropWatch does not test it. The levels are revised with your agronomist before each season, with the price of the moment, and are not changed during it.
University of Illinois Extension, the extension service of that public university, says what the level depends on: the pest’s damage, the expected yield, the price, the cost of control and other factors. It does not recommend control when the expected loss is smaller than the cost. A level copied from a neighbor, a flyer or another country carries someone else’s price, cost and crop stage, which is why this article gives none.
Ask for the levels in writing, with the crop stage each one applies to. Which product and which dose are your agronomist’s recommendation, and who pays that adviser is worth writing down before you take the levels as given. A level written before the visit should not be moved to fit what you find that day, the same reason to set your harvest loss limit before harvest.
Does counting change how often you spray?
In Paraná the group that counted sprayed less, but the comparison cannot say the count caused it. Embrapa Soja compared soybean fields in its integrated pest management program (weekly counts, action levels, selective insecticides, which spare other insects) with fields outside it over 11 seasons, 2013/14 to 2023/24. The totals add up the fields of all 11 seasons: 1,762 program fields and 5,334 comparison fields.
The averages for the 11 seasons (the simple average of each season’s averages): 1.7 insecticide applications against 3.6, and yield 56.8 against 55.3 sacks per hectare (sc/ha, how soybean yield is counted in Brazil). Cost of control was 1.8 against 3.8 sc/ha, a cost in sacks, which changes with the price of the sack. In 2023/24, the report estimates the cost in reais (Brazil’s currency) per hectare and converts it into sacks at the average price of a sack. That year, 89% of the program’s farmers and 75% of the others did not spray any insecticide against caterpillars.
Read the gap with these cautions in mind. The program is more than the sheet: it has trained technicians, weekly visits, action levels fixed beforehand and insecticides chosen to spare other insects, so the sheet cannot be separated from the rest. The authors say the higher yield of program fields may come from other practices, such as sowing date and cultivars.
The comparison fields were surveyed by questionnaire, and 543 farmers answered it in 2023/24, one season of the 11. Among farmers outside the program who know integrated pest management, the authors estimate that 31.4% on average say they use it. So part of the comparison group follows the practice too, which may narrow the contrast. Farms that join a program may also differ from those that do not. The report comes from the program’s own team, which describes the field network as a way to promote and spread the program. None of the sources tests the sheet on its own, or on a large grain farm.
Why would calendar spraying cost more? Two sources describe a mechanism. CropWatch reports growers who added an insecticide to the last herbicide pass to clean up the field. It also killed the insects that eat or parasitize aphids and mites (predators and parasitoids), so more aphids and mites survived and more sprays were needed later. Embrapa describes the same rebound after calendar sprays: the pest coming back in larger numbers. Neither tests the sheet.
CropWatch also gives one exception. Spraying before the pest arrives can make sense, but only for a pest that is hard to find on a visit and causes severe loss. It must also be a pest that cannot be easily controlled once it is injuring the crop, with a relatively high probability of occurring. If you spray before the pest arrives, write that as the reason. Each application on this sheet also has a product. Its mode of action group (how the product acts on the pest) goes on a second sheet: which spray group went on each field, and when.
Where does rain go on the sheet?
In its own column, in millimeters since the last visit, read from a rain gauge on the farm. A count at the level is not always a spray that day: in the Embrapa program the technicians decided on control by the action levels and also by the farmer’s operational concerns and the weather. None of the sources tests whether rain data change the decision to spray. The column is there to record the weather in which each decision was made.
Spraying has a window, like planting, and rain closes it. When the count reaches the level and rain is on the way, the question is which job gets the day. A window for each operation shows how to write that choice before the rush.
For rain alone, a good manual rain gauge is enough, according to the farm weather station guide of the University of Florida’s extension service. It names as an example the gauge of CoCoRaHS, a US collaborative network for measuring rain, hail and snow, which teaches how to measure daily rain by hand. The guide says to place the gauge in the open, as far from obstructions as possible (ideally four times the height of the nearest one, so 20 m from a 5 m obstruction). The collector should be level and open to the sky. Check it weekly, since insects, turf clippings and dirt can plug the funnel.
The NEWA guide, from Cornell University’s farm weather network, also asks for a level gauge and for keeping leaf litter out. For a site among trees it gives a looser rule. A clearing works well because the trees block the wind. The gauge should stand at least half the height of the trees away from them (trees 10 m high, a gauge at least 5 m from them). The manufacturer’s guidelines come first, so follow the manual of the gauge you buy.
What do you write first, and how long does it take?
Start with the levels. Ask your agronomist or extension service for the action level of each pest at each crop stage, and write them at the top of the sheet with the source. Then mark the points to count in each field (at least ten in soybean; for other crops, ask your agronomist), install the rain gauge and fix one visit day for every week. Keep one sheet per field, so that the field’s yield series can sit beside its applications. Setting it up is one sitting, with the levels and last season’s application record on the table. Filling a row takes the minutes after the walk.
At the end of the season, count three things: the visits made, the applications, and how many applications had a count at or above the level on their row. Subtract the third count from the second: what is left are the sprays whose row has no count at the level. Read their reasons before writing next season’s levels on the sheet.
Whoever reads the sheet with the manager and the agronomist at the end of the season has every spray and its reason at hand. For the rest of the field work, see the other production articles, and for the whole farm, farm management.
In the first season the levels come in writing from your agronomist, and with the sheet you can check whether you followed them. After a few seasons, from the Reason column you can see which sprays had no count at the level on their row, and why. Related: How to register each field: code, area and history.