Somebody needs the grease gun before the planter leaves the shed, and it is not on the bench. The search takes minutes that appear in no record. In an example shop (the numbers are made up), 14 searches of 20 minutes each in two weeks come to 4 hours 40 minutes.
A written list of places fixes this. It has one line for each tool, spare part and input in the shop and in the input store (the room where seed, fertilizer and chemicals are kept). Each line says where the item is kept and who puts it back. On a date you set in advance, say the first Monday of each month, one person you name walks through the shop and the store with the list. That person marks what is missing or out of place.
Nobody has measured how much time a list like this saves in a grain-farm shop. Studies of 5S, a method of five steps for putting a workplace in order, report smaller inventories on some farms and no sign of better safety. The sections below say which numbers were measured and which were not.
How long does a search take in a shop?
No source used for this article timed searches in a grain-farm shop, so the only measured figure comes from outside farming. In 2007 WardsAuto, a magazine for car dealers, reported that a Mercedes-Benz dealership in Manhattan had its shop foreman record 21 searches. They were for specialty tools that were not on the pegboard or in the storage closet. The average search lasted 30 minutes, and 57 percent (12 of the 21) ended without finding the tool.
That is one car dealership, with about 600 specialty tools, and 21 searches reported in a trade magazine. It shows how to measure (write down each search and time it with a clock), and it gives no number for your shop.
The farm evidence is smaller still. PRO-DAIRY, the dairy extension program of Cornell University, ran a project on lean management, a way of cutting wasted steps from routine work. In its 2022 report, one dairy farm cut 12 minutes off the preventive maintenance of a skid steer by loading all the tools and supplies on a rolling cart before starting. The report gives the result for one farm and does not say how the time was measured.
So the figure that counts is your own. For two weeks, write every search on a sheet by the shop door: what was looked for, and the minutes until it was found or the word “not found”.
What did 5S change on the farms that tried it?
Farms that used 5S reported smaller inventories and the things they use most kept within reach, and none of the sources reviewed found better safety. The main source is a survey of 54 farms in Sweden, run by Andersson and colleagues with a questionnaire and interviews and published in 2020 in Agronomy Research, a scientific journal. The farms were in dairy, eggs, chicken, pigs, beef, grain and plant nurseries.
The 54 farms were in three groups. Two were in lean programs, a way of cutting wasted steps from routine work: one program ran 18 months (the survey came in its fifth month) and the other a few days. The third group was farms chosen because they were inclined to improve. The authors report that inventories and storage shrank on the farms that applied 5S: they needed less space and kept fewer items. The farms in the 18-month lean program more often reported organizing storage, removing material not needed for years and placing the most-used material on the most convenient shelves. The authors also write that having the right tools where they are needed, in standardized places, reduces physical movement.
On safety the study found no sign: the authors found no sign that 5S had improved safety at work on the farms surveyed, and they call the empirical evidence for such an improvement limited. Read the results with two limits in mind. The farms were not drawn at random, and the study reports what farmers answered, not what a clock measured. The sample spans seven kinds of farm, so what it says about a grain-farm shop is carried over from other kinds of farm.
This article uses only sources that are free to read and say how they measured. Journal pages that refused access, and claims from industry with no method stated, were left out. What remains is reports from farms and one car dealership with timed searches, and none of them compares a grain farm with and without 5S. Not finding such a comparison here does not mean 5S does not work.
| Source | Setting | What it reports | What it leaves open |
|---|---|---|---|
| Andersson et al., 2020 | 54 farms in Sweden, seven sectors | Smaller inventories, storage organized, fewer movements; no sign of better safety | Answers given by farmers, not timed; farms not drawn at random |
| Cornell PRO-DAIRY, 2022 | One dairy farm in an extension project | 12 minutes off skid steer maintenance with a rolling cart | One farm; no timing method described |
| WardsAuto, 2007 | One car dealership, 21 timed searches | 30 minutes per search; 57 percent without the tool | Not a farm; a trade magazine |
In what order do the five steps go?
Start by clearing out: if you organize things that nobody uses, you only give them a better place. The five steps, in order, are sort (clear out what you no longer need), set in order (give each thing a marked place) and shine (clean the shop). Then come standardize (decide who does what and make it routine) and sustain (keep the shop from sliding back, for example by checking it on a set date).
The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) publishes a guide to 5S. It says that the set in order step can only be done once the sort step has cleared the work area. For sorting it describes red tagging: a red tag goes on every item that is not needed, or that is not in the right place or quantity. The tagged items move to one holding area to be discarded, recycled or reassigned. In a farm shop that is the coffee can of loose bolts and the hose nobody has used since the last owner.
In the set in order step you write the list and mark the places: labels and outlines show where each thing goes, on shelves, boards and floor. The list has four columns: the item, its place, how many you keep and who puts it back. One line reads: grease gun, left drawer of the bench by the door, 1, Carlos (the tractor driver).
In the shine step, which is cleaning, the EPA notes that in a clean workplace workers notice leaks, vibrations and breakages sooner. Standardize is the step where the care becomes routine. On the list, that is the name of the person who puts each tool back, and the check becomes part of the regular work. The EPA says the last step, sustain, is often the most difficult of the five: it is the work of keeping the shop from drifting back to the old way.
The list can also have lines for papers. The manual of each machine, the oil invoices and the hour-meter log (the sheet where the hours are written) can be kept in a marked place just like the grease gun. To check a machine against its factory service interval, you need the manual, the invoices and the meter reading side by side. To get the repair total for one machine, you need its repair invoices in one place, and to compare fuel bought against hours worked, you need the delivery slips next to the meter log.
How do you keep the input store and the spare parts in order?
Put the oldest containers at the front of the shelf, where you reach for them first, leave a marked aisle between shelves, and write the date on each container when it arrives. The Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) sets that out in its pesticide storage manual. It says stock should be arranged to use the oldest first, the first in, first out principle. It also asks for clear floor space, with marked aisles 1 m (about 3 feet) wide between shelves or stacks, so that containers can be inspected and a leak seen quickly.
The manual also asks for the date of purchase or arrival on each container, and for labels that stay attached, clean and readable and are replaced when worn.
The manual is written for pesticide stores. Local rules on storing chemicals set their own distances, signs and permits, and those rules take priority over any list. Before moving a chemical, confirm them with your supplier or with the government agency that regulates chemicals where you farm. For spare parts, each line of the list needs the place, how many you keep and the name of the person who restocks the part. To know how many units you have, count the input stock against the record; to know where the units are kept, read the list.
Who checks the list, and when?
One person you name walks through the shop and the store with the list on the date you set, for example the first Monday of each month. That person puts back what is out of place, or changes the line on the list when the new place is better, for instance because it is closer to where the tool is used.
The walk follows PDCA (plan, do, check, act), a four-step cycle from quality management. Applied to the shop, plan is writing the places on the list and do is putting each thing in its place. Check is the walk with the list in hand. Act is correcting what the walk found: putting the tool back, or rewriting the line and dating it. Moen and Norman, writing in Quality Progress, a quality-management magazine, describe this last step: act means going back to the plan if the results are unsatisfactory, or standardizing the solution if they are satisfactory.
Plan
Write the places on the list
One line per tool, spare part or input
Do
Put each thing in its place
Every item at the place on its line
Check
Walk the shop with the list
On the date you set
Act
Put it back or rewrite the line
Date the new line
The EPA lists scheduled five-minute 5S periods and checklists among the tools of the standardize step, and says that the tendency is often to return to the old way. None of the sources reviewed followed a farm shop over several seasons, so no farm study shows how long the order lasts.
Where to start
Spend two weeks writing down searches, which costs a sheet and a pen. Then plan about two hours (a rough estimate, not a measured figure) to sort, write and label the first list for one shop or one store. Begin with the tools that show up most often on your search sheet.
The search sheet cannot tell you where something went. At the check, an item may be missing from its place because it left the shop: a tool lent to a neighbor, or a spare filter already fitted to a machine. Walking with the list, you see which line has nothing at its place, instead of asking around the whole farm. The item goes back or the line changes, and the aim is that the same tool names stop filling up the sheet by the door.
The same three moves work for the input stock and the machine records too: writing down what should be there, comparing it with what is, and fixing the difference. This site’s guide to farm management shows how for the rest of the farm. If the same item keeps going missing, see Which repeat failure deserves a five-whys sheet?, which explains a sheet that asks “why” five times in a row. More records of the production side are in the production library.