A grain system that costs $500,000 to replace is insured for $300,000. A storm does $125,000 of damage, and the policy pays $93,750, only 75% of it, so the farmer pays the other $31,250. The policy paid exactly what its clauses say: the farmer insured less than the policy required, and the policy cuts every partial payout by the same share. The gap costs nothing until the claim, so the time to find it is before the next renewal, while the policy can still change. List every asset on the farm at what it would cost to replace today, write beside it what the policy covers and for how much, and mark what the policy leaves out.
Two kinds of gap show on the sheet: the asset insured below its value, and the asset or activity the policy never listed. The choice of insurer and the size of the premium (the price of the policy for a year) stay outside it. The figures come from U.S. university extension guides, and other countries set other rules for an asset insured short.
Why can a renewed policy pay less than the asset is worth?
A policy pays less when the insured amount (the most it will pay for that item) is below what its co-insurance clause requires. The clause is the policy’s rule that the farmer must insure a minimum percentage of the asset’s replacement cost (what it costs today to buy or build the same thing new). Ohio State University Extension puts that percentage at 80% to 100% for most policies. It says the clause generally applies to outbuildings, dwellings and farm personal property insured under a blanket limit (one limit for a group of items, not one per item). If your machinery sits under a blanket limit, ask the broker whether the percentage is tested item by item or on the group.
The insurer sets the premium from the list and the values the farmer gives it. A value that falls behind replacement cost, on purpose or by drift, means the insurer charged for less than it now covers. The clause lets the insurer correct that at the claim, and Purdue Extension notes that nothing happens before then. The adjuster, the insurer’s claims inspector, compares the amount carried with the amount that should have been carried and cuts the payout by the ratio.
Purdue gives the formula: the amount carried, divided by the amount that should have been carried, times the loss. The result is the payout, less the deductible (the part of each loss the policy leaves to the farmer). Its example is the grain system of the opening, under an 80% clause.
A partial loss pays 75% here because the farmer carried 75% of what the clause required. A total loss meets a second limit. The policy pays at most the insured amount. If the whole system is lost, it pays $300,000 at most and the farmer carries at least $200,000 of the $500,000. Ohio State shows the same cap in its own example, a $300,000 limit on a $350,000 loss.
The rule changes by country. Brazil’s Law 15,040 of 2024, in force since December 2025, says a partial loss is not prorated because the insured amount is below the value of the interest, unless the policy provides otherwise. It also caps the indemnity at the amount guaranteed. Find out whether your policy carries a clause like Purdue’s before you count on either rule.
Which assets and activities go on the sheet, and with what values?
One row per asset and one per activity. If you have already ranked the farm’s risks, as in the article on which of your farm risks come first, start from the top of that list. Each row has five columns. The first is the replacement cost today, which is a dealer’s price for the same model new or a builder’s quote to rebuild. The other four are the insured amount on the policy, the amount the clause requires, the most the policy pays if the asset is lost entirely, and the difference. That last one is what the policy leaves out.
The most the policy pays on a total loss is the insured amount, or the replacement cost when that is lower. The 80% in the table follows the Purdue example. Use the percentage printed in your own policy.
| Asset | Replacement cost today | Insured amount | Required by an 80% clause | Paid on a total loss | Left out |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tractor | 100 | 60 | 80 | 60 | 40 |
| Grain system | 500 | 300 | 400 | 300 | 200 |
| Machine shed | 150 | 150 | 120 | 150 | 0 |
| Combine harvester | 785 | not on the policy | not applicable | 0 | 785 |
| Stored grain | 120 | not on the policy | not applicable | 0 | 120 |
| Total | 1,655 | 510 | 1,145 |
Of the $1,655,000 of replacement cost, $510,000 is paid on a total loss and $1,145,000, about 69%, is left out. The left-out sum has two origins: $240,000 from assets insured short (the tractor and the grain system) and $905,000 from assets the policy does not list (the combine and the stored grain). Each origin has its own fix, which is to raise the insured amount or to add the asset.
Why does this asset add to the left-out sum?
The asset is not on the policy
Add the asset to the policy
The combine and the stored grain: $905,000 left out
The asset is insured short
Raise the insured amount
The tractor and the grain system: $240,000 left out
The combine row is the one figure here taken from a price list. The University of Illinois lists a 470 horsepower combine at $784,500 in August 2025, rounded to $785,000 in the table. The header, the cutting attachment, is sold apart, from $79,300 for a grain platform to $173,500 for a corn head, so a farm that needs one adds its price to the row. Your own dealer quote for your model replaces this figure.
Ohio State’s tractor is one of the two assets insured short. It cost $80,000 five years ago, the farmer insured it at $60,000, and a similar one costs $100,000 today. The 80% clause requires $80,000, so the farmer carries 75% of the requirement. In Ohio State’s example, a $100,000 fire loss pays 75% of it, $75,000, with no cap. If the policy states $60,000 as the limit on that tractor, it pays at most $60,000. The table counts $60,000, the lower of the two, as the most it pays. The broker can confirm which your policy applies.
Activities go on the sheet as rows too. Ohio State says most farm policies cover traditional crop and livestock activities automatically and may leave out the non-traditional ones. Its list of such activities includes agritourism, farm markets, hauling crops for others, custom planting or harvesting, using rented equipment, and seed or inputs bought and not yet delivered. The list is about liability (the farm’s responsibility for harm to others), and almost any item can be added by an endorsement, an added clause in the policy. Mark each activity of your farm as listed or not listed, and take the marked rows to the broker, the agent who sells and services the policy.
What do you copy from the policy, and what does it not say?
Copy six lines from the policy beside each asset. The first is the causes of loss covered (fire, wind, theft, breakdown). The other five are the insured amount (the limit for that item), the co-insurance percentage if there is one, the payout basis, the deductible, and the dates the policy runs. Write the causes row by row: a shed on the policy may still be unprotected against wind, and a combine that breaks down is covered only if breakdown is listed. The payout basis moves the figures more than the other lines. A replacement-value policy pays what it costs to replace the asset. An actual-cash-value policy pays the asset’s depreciated value, which Ohio State says is commonly lower.
Ohio State’s example is a tractor bought in 2020 for $300,000, worth $200,000 today after wear, and selling new for $350,000. Replacement value pays $350,000 and actual cash value pays $200,000, a difference of $150,000. A $300,000 limit caps the first payout at $300,000. The same tractor receives three different payments under three policies.
What the policy does not say is a second list, and it goes to the broker as questions. Achmea, an Australian insurer, puts four checks among its questions in its review checklist. One compares the sums for buildings with the cost of rebuilding, and another the sums for stock and hay with grain and livestock prices. A third sets vehicles at market value or at an agreed value (a figure fixed with the insurer in advance). The fourth asks whether business interruption cover exists, which pays for lost income while the business is out of action. Achmea points out that rebuilding can sometimes take longer than expected, and income stays lost until the business is running again. The checklist comes from an insurer, so use it as a list of questions and not as advice to buy a product.
Insure each asset at least up to the percentage the clause requires. Below it, the premium saved comes back as a cut on every partial claim. The cost is a higher premium, which the broker quotes. Raising the grain system from $300,000 to $400,000 would have paid the whole $125,000 loss instead of $93,750, a gain of $31,250 on that one claim. Weigh that gain against the extra premium for $100,000 of insured amount, with the broker’s quote in hand. On an asset you cannot get through a season without, the larger insured amount is the safer side of the trade. On a spare machine, the extra premium may not pay back.
What the policy does not pay comes out of the farm’s cash. Count the months of reserve to see how long the cash lasts without income, then read the left-out column to see how much of that cash one loss can take. When the largest left-out sum is bigger than the cash on hand, raise that row’s insured amount, or add the asset to the policy, before the next purchase.
What do you write first, and before which date?
Open the policy and find the renewal date, because every change you can still make has to be made before it. Then start with the asset that costs most to replace, since its row holds the largest possible gap. The job takes one afternoon with the policy, a dealer quote or a current price for each machine, and the list of what the farm does.
Write the replacement cost from the price of the same model new today, not from the purchase invoice. Ohio State warns that a policyholder may fail to keep up with the replacement value of property. Its tractor went from $80,000 at purchase to $100,000 to replace in five years. A new row belongs on the sheet every time the farm buys a machine or builds a structure. The written investment plan is the place to add the line “insure it” before the purchase.
Call the broker with the marked rows and ask for two quotes on each: the premium at today’s insured amount and at the amount the clause requires. The difference between the two is the price of closing that gap, and it is the number to decide on. Keeping the farm’s assets and their cover written down is part of managing the farm as a business; other articles on farm money are in the finance section of the library. Related: How bad a year can your farm take before it loses money?, for how much of a bad year the farm absorbs before it loses money. Related: In which month will your farm’s cash run lowest?, for the sheet that finds the month the account runs lowest.