A field can take soybeans or another crop option. In a margin count (revenue less the costs that go out only if you plant the crop), soybeans leave $20 an acre more than the second option. But in a bad year, with a soybean yield 10 percent lower, they lose $56 an acre of that margin. The $20 gap is smaller than the $56 loss, so you cannot choose between the two from the table: they tie.
So rank each field’s crops by contribution margin per acre, which is that same margin. Then compare the gap between the top two with the drop, which is the margin the top crop would lose in a bad year. The order is reliable only where the gap is larger than the drop. Where it is smaller, the choice depends on what the ranking leaves out. You finish with one table, a row for each field and crop, with the drop written beside each row.
How do you rank the crop options of each field?
Contribution margin is what a crop leaves after its variable cost, the money that goes out only if you plant it, such as seed, fertilizer and fuel. That margin then has to pay the costs that go out whether or not you plant, such as machinery payments, labor and rent. A row of the table is one crop option for one field, given the crop grown there last. Take a field called North that grew corn last: it has two rows, soybeans, and corn after corn.
Wheat followed by soybeans in the same year is also one row. Those are double-crop soybeans, planted in the same field after the wheat harvest, so the two margins are added, because the sequence uses the same land in the same year.
The unit is the acre: each field has a fixed number of acres, and each crop option would use those acres for the same year. OpenStax, a publisher of free textbooks, gives this rule in its managerial accounting text: when one resource limits what you can do, rank the options by margin per unit of that resource. The rule assumes that resource is the only limit, and on a farm labor, machinery and rotation can add limits of their own.
The example has three fields, North, South and East. All the figures are invented and describe no real farm or market.
Inside a field, the top row is the crop with the highest margin and the first one to consider planting: soybeans in North, corn in South and soybeans in East. The figure lists all six rows in one list just to show their margins side by side; each decision stays inside its field, between its top row and the runner-up.
Which cost lines count, and what does the margin leave out?
Two farms can both write “margin” and mean different things. The cost guide for 2026 from Purdue University counts these as variable cost: fertilizer, seed, pesticides, dryer fuel, machinery fuel, machinery repairs, hauling, interest and insurance. The cost of owning machinery, family and hired labor and cash rent are left out of the margin, as overhead.
The same word can cover different sums. Epagri, a farm research and extension agency in the Brazilian state of Santa Catarina, subtracts a wider set of costs. That set includes labor, financial expense and taxes, and Epagri still calls the result “margem bruta”, gross margin. The Anguil station of INTA, part of Argentina’s national agricultural technology institute, counts rent, crop-specific labor and direct depreciation among its direct costs and also calls the result gross margin.
So you cannot tell from the word “margin” which costs went in. Write the cost lines you count, the same for every row, and name the ones left out. Rows computed with different lines cannot be compared.
What the margin leaves out is the overhead it has to cover. Take continuous corn (corn after corn) in Purdue’s 2026 guide, per acre. Its margin is $116 and government payments add $50. Overhead is $409. The result is a loss of $243. The other three crops in the guide (rotation corn, rotation soybeans and wheat) also have a positive margin, and all four end below zero. Wheat alone loses $268, but the guide says it is common to add double-crop soybeans (planted after the wheat harvest) to it, and the two together, with a margin of $216, lose $133. A crop high in the ranking pays more toward the overhead; that does not mean it makes a profit.
When can you trust the order between two rows?
The order is reliable when the gap between the top row and the runner-up is larger than the drop of the top row. When the gap is smaller, the two crops tie and the table does not choose for you. The drop is the margin the top row would lose in a bad year. A simple way to estimate it is the margin lost at a yield 10 percent lower, with the percent taken from your own yield record, as in each field’s yield, year by year.
The test covers one case: a bad year for the top row while the runner-up is untouched. Other years can hit both rows. Take East, where the gap is $20. If soybeans yield 10 percent less, that row falls to $184 and the wheat then double-crop row, at $220, is ahead by $36, so reading the $20 as a firm order would have been wrong. If instead the soybean price falls by $1.00, soybeans fall to $184 and the wheat then double-crop row, which also earns from soybeans, falls to $178. Soybeans still lead, but by $6, not $20. In both cases East stays a tie.
For a tie, the choice rests on what is not in the table: the planting window, the labor in the double-crop weeks, the lease and the agronomist’s view of next year’s soil.
Is the gap to the runner-up larger than the drop of the top row?
The gap is larger
The order is reliable
North and South in the example
The gap is smaller
The two crops tie
Choose on what is not in the table: planting window, labor, lease, agronomist
Published figures show the same pattern as the East field in the example: two crops with almost equal middle levels and a wide range inside each. The station INTA Pergamino (Fillat and colleagues) publishes each margin at three yield levels. The middle one is the average of the last ten seasons, the low one is exceeded in three seasons out of four and the high one in one out of four.
For 2024/2025, on owned land, first-crop corn (sown early in the season) runs from 263.8 to 733.6 dollars a hectare, with 457.3 in the middle. Wheat then double-crop soybeans runs from 122.1 to 781.4, with 449.4 in the middle. The middle levels differ by 7.9 dollars, while the range from low to high is 469.8 for corn and 659.3 for wheat then soybeans. Against ranges that wide, a gap of 7.9 dollars is a tie.
What does it cost to move a field off its top row?
To see what a change costs, take each field’s gap to the runner-up and multiply it by the field’s acres. In the example, moving North off soybeans costs $155 on 120 acres, which is $18,600. Moving South off corn costs $115 on 80 acres, which is $9,200. Moving East from soybeans to the wheat then double-crop row costs $20 on 100 acres, which is $2,000.
If one field has to change, East costs the least to move, and you and your agronomist decide, on grounds outside the table, whether it is the right one. With each field on its top row, the three fields sum to $75,200 of margin, and the overhead comes out of that sum; it is not profit.
Date the table, because the order depends on the year it was written for. In Purdue’s guide, on average-productivity soil, rotation corn’s margin was on average $38 an acre higher than rotation soybeans’ from 2007 to 2013. From 2014 to 2025, rotation soybeans’ margin was on average $65 higher than rotation corn’s. For 2026 it projects soybeans ahead by $61. A table written on one season’s prices carries that season’s order.
One limit of the method: contribution margin is an accounting method, not a tested rule for choosing crops. The sources for this article include no study on grain farms that tested choosing crops by it against another way and compared the results. That is an absence of a test, not a finding that it fails. The drop test and this reading of the gaps are this article’s own reasoning, not a published method. The rows are only as good as the yields and prices written into them, and which crop goes in a field stays with the farmer and the agronomist.
Where to start
The table can be written in an afternoon from last season’s invoices and each field’s yield record.
If you do not yet have your variable cost lines, how much to sell to break even sets them out. The margin the whole crop should leave once fixed cost is charged is worked out in what should this crop leave you. Once you have chosen the top rows, they go into the three-year production plan, which writes the rotation field by field. Writing the number and its range before deciding is a habit that carries to every decision in farm management. Other articles on farm money are in the finance section of the library. Related: Cost per bushel by field: your invoices over your harvest. Related: Crops and cattle on the same land: which one pays?.