Before you buy a put option, work out the price floor it really gives you and set it beside your cost of production. The strike price on the broker’s screen is not that floor. The strike price is the sale price written into the option. The floor is the strike price minus the premium you pay and minus the basis, the gap between your elevator’s bid and the futures price, the exchange price of the grain. You pay the premium whether prices rise or fall. In the example, a $5.00 strike price leaves a floor of $4.25 a bushel, against a cost of production of $4.00.
A put option is a contract that gives you the right, not the duty, to sell a futures contract at a set price, the strike price, until a set date. What you pay for that right is the premium. The basis is the gap between what your elevator bids and the futures price.
Take a hypothetical case. December corn futures are at $5.00 a bushel, your elevator bids 50 cents under futures, and you buy a put with a $5.00 strike price for a 25 cent premium. If prices fall, the put gains whatever futures lose below $5.00, and you end with $5.00 minus 25 cents minus 50 cents, a floor of $4.25, not $5.00. If prices rise, the put expires unused and the 25 cents is gone all the same. If you cover 50,000 bushels, the premium is $12,500, paid when you buy and not at expiry.
The figures are a hypothetical example for an Iowa farm that expects 100,000 bushels of corn and covers 50,000 of them, not market quotes. Options on corn futures trade at CME, the Chicago exchange, and each futures contract is 5,000 bushels, so 50,000 bushels is 10 contracts.
At the end you have a premium-against-floor sheet, one page on paper or in a spreadsheet. On it you write three strikes with their premiums, the floor each one gives, your cost of production beside them, the total premium in dollars, and what you receive per bushel at five local prices. Fill it in before you buy: the broker’s screen shows the strike and the premium, and neither your basis nor your cost.
What floor does a put option give you?
The floor is the strike price minus the premium, minus the basis you expect, minus trading costs (the broker’s commission and the exchange’s buy-sell spread). The example leaves trading costs out until the section on them below, so each floor it shows is about 1.2 cents a bushel higher than the floor you would net. Hofstrand, an Iowa State University extension specialist, writes the floor the same way for a farmer who has not yet priced the grain and buys the put. CME Group’s guide gives the same arithmetic: the strike minus the premium, adjusted by the basis you expect at delivery. The basis is the one number the put does not lock.
The put protects the futures part of your price. If futures fall below the strike, the put gains and offsets what the grain loses. If futures rise, the put expires unused and you sell the grain at the higher price, minus the premium. Hofstrand adds that the real floor differs from the estimate only if the basis at delivery differs from the one you expected, not because of the futures price. The strike covers futures only. Your elevator pays you the local price, which is futures plus the basis (here, 50 cents under), and that gap is outside the put.
Check the arithmetic from both sides. Say futures end at $3.50, so the local price is $3.00. The put pays $1.50 (the $5.00 strike minus $3.50), and $3.00 plus $1.50 minus the $0.25 premium is $4.25. Say futures end at $6.50, so the local price is $6.00. The put expires, and $6.00 minus $0.25 is $5.75, which is well above the floor because you sold the grain high and spent only the premium.
How wide the basis can get before the floor falls under your cost is the break-even basis, the strike minus the premium minus your cost. Here, $5.00 minus $0.25 minus $4.00 is $0.75, so 75 cents under. With an expected basis of 50 cents under, you have 25 cents a bushel of room. If the basis comes in wider than 75 cents under, the floor drops below what the corn cost to grow. Your expected basis comes from a price record with a source, and the lowest price you can take is how you set the cost per bushel you compare the floor with.
What do you pay for the floor, and what does it give back?
You pay the premium in every case, and the put pays only when the local price ends under $4.50. In the table, each row is a local price at delivery, and the columns give what you receive per bushel with no protection and with the put, on the bushels the put covers.
| Local price at delivery | No protection | With the put | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| $3.00 | $3.00 | $4.25 | $1.25 more |
| $4.00 | $4.00 | $4.25 | $0.25 more |
| $5.00 | $5.00 | $4.75 | $0.25 less |
| $6.00 | $6.00 | $5.75 | $0.25 less |
| $7.00 | $7.00 | $6.75 | $0.25 less |
With no protection, what you receive varies by $4.00, from $3.00 to $7.00. With the put it varies by $2.50, from $4.25 to $6.75. The put beats no protection only when the local price ends under $4.25, the floor itself. Above a local price of $4.50 it costs the 25 cent premium, and nothing else changes; between $4.25 and $4.50 it costs less than that. A University of Kentucky extension publication on put options as price insurance is about dairy farmers, so milk and not grain, but its point carries over. It makes the point in its opening lines: the main benefit is less variation in income, not more gross income.
The most you can lose on the option is known before you buy. On 50,000 bushels the premium is $12,500, and that is the most the option itself can lose. CME Group’s guide notes that an option buyer has limited loss, the premium paid, and puts up no margin, the cash deposit a broker holds against a futures position. So no margin call, a demand to add cash, can reach you. That is the contrast with selling futures, where a rally draws cash from that deposit before the grain is sold. The premium still leaves your bank right when you buy, not at expiry.
Trading costs come on top. Urcola and Irwin, two researchers who studied options on US exchanges, illustrate them at about $59 per contract to enter the trade they tested and close it out. About $50 of that is commission, a figure they adopt for a medium-size trader working off the floor. The rest is exchange cost: the gap between the buying and selling prices, and the adjustment of the futures position after exercise. On a 5,000 bushel contract that is about 1.2 cents a bushel. That was a 2011 illustration, so ask the broker for today’s number and subtract it from each floor.
Why does a higher floor cost more?
Because a higher strike gives you more protection, and protection is what the premium sells. A put with a higher strike starts paying earlier as futures fall, so the market charges more for it. A put with a lower strike costs less, leaves you more of a rally, and gives a lower floor. The Iowa State publication says so for out-of-the-money puts, the ones whose strike sits under today’s futures price. CME Group likens the choice to car insurance: the more of the loss you carry yourself, the larger the deductible and the cheaper the policy.
| Strike | Premium | Price floor | Floor against cost of $4.00 | Net price at a local $6.00 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $5.50 | $0.60 | $4.40 | $0.40 above | $5.40 |
| $5.00 | $0.25 | $4.25 | $0.25 above | $5.75 |
| $4.50 | $0.12 | $3.88 | $0.12 under | $5.88 |
The third row, the $4.50 strike, is the trap. That put has the cheapest premium and the best price in a rally, and its floor is 12 cents under your cost of production. If futures slip from $5.00 to $4.60, it pays nothing. If they sink far, it still leaves you $3.88 a bushel, under what the corn cost to grow. Before comparing premiums, drop every strike whose floor is under your cost. What is left is the choice between paying more for a floor with room above cost or paying less for a floor that just clears it.
The market sets the premium, and CME Group’s guide lists what moves it. It has two parts: the intrinsic value, what the put would be worth if used today, plus the time value. With futures at $4.60, for example, a $5.00 put has an intrinsic value of 40 cents, and any premium above 40 cents is time value. Time value is higher when there is more time to expiry and when futures prices swing more. It is also higher for a put whose strike is near today’s futures price than for one far from it. In practice, a put that lasts to your sale date in a jumpy market costs more than a short one in a calm market.
The option has a last trading day, and your sale date has to fall before it. CME Group explains that the last trading day is in the month before the contract month the option is named for, usually the third or fourth Friday. An option on December futures therefore stops trading in November. If you will sell in December or January, ask for the option month that outlasts that date, and write both dates on the sheet. After the last trading day you no longer hold the floor you paid for.
Other exchanges publish their own contract sheets, with their own contract sizes, expiry dates and currencies. The arithmetic of strike minus premium minus basis is the same everywhere. Take the numbers for your exchange from its sheet and from your broker, not from this example.
Is the premium worth paying?
Only your own numbers can say, and the comparison is in dollars: the total premium on the bushels covered, against what the put would pay at the lowest price you could face. In the example the premium is $12,500. If the local price ends at $3.00 (futures at $3.50), the put pays $75,000 on those 50,000 bushels, which is $62,500 after the premium. If it ends at $4.50 or more (futures at $5.00 or more), the put pays nothing and the $12,500 is gone.
Looking back, the put can seem a mistake whichever way prices go. Compare three paths in the example: sell now, hold the grain unpriced, or buy the put. Selling now at today’s local price gives $4.50 (futures $5.00 minus the 50 cent basis). If the local price falls to $3.00, selling now beats the put ($4.50 against $4.25). If it rises to $6.00, holding unpriced beats the put ($6.00 against $5.75). The put came second in both cases, as Hofstrand notes, and that is no flaw to hold against it later. You are paying to be able to wait without risking the whole price.
The same publication adds a condition that bears on the volume. Options have to go with sales of the grain itself, and options used on their own are speculation. So the bushels you cover cannot exceed the bushels you hold and have not yet sold. To count the ones already priced, see the article on the volume already priced.
Now the evidence. The arithmetic on this page is in the CME Group guide and the Iowa State publication, and you can check each line. None of the sources used here tests, on a grain farm, the net price with puts against selling at harvest, so how much a floor is worth over several seasons has not been shown. The nearest evidence comes from exchanges. Urcola and Irwin tested US corn, soybean and wheat options from the mid-1980s to 2009 and found that buying corn and wheat puts returned money on average in the sample, with corn puts looking underpriced. The authors credit most of those gains to the drift of futures prices over the period and conclude that the corn, soybean and wheat option markets are efficient. That means option prices already reflect what the market knows. A cost of about $59 a contract wipes out the gain on 90-day corn puts but not on 90-day wheat puts. That is a study of trading returns, not of a farm’s net price, so it changes no line of the sheet.
What goes on the sheet first?
Your cost of production, before you ask for any quote. Every other line is compared with it. With that cost and the broker’s three quotes in hand, filling in the sheet takes about an hour (an estimate, not a measured number).
The blank line at the bottom is the one that pays off. At the sale you write the price you actually received next to the floor you computed, and after a few seasons you can compare the premiums you paid with what the options gave back. Only you can keep that record. It is part of your marketing, and in farm management it is what your later price decisions rest on. Related: Inputs paid in grain: work out the rate hidden in bushels.