In this example, your elevator bids 40 cents a bushel under the December corn futures price on your broker’s screen. The futures price is today’s exchange price for corn delivered in December. On 50,000 bushels that gap is $20,000. The price you keep after selling futures is the futures price you locked, adjusted by that gap, which the trade calls the basis. If the basis comes in 15 cents worse than the 40 cents you expected, the same 50,000 bushels bring $7,500 less. Before you sell any contract, write the price you expect to keep next to your cost of production, and decide from it how many bushels to cover with futures.
The figures are invented for the example, not market quotes. The farm is in Iowa and expects 100,000 bushels of corn. The farm sells December corn futures on CME, the Chicago exchange. Selling futures to fix a price before harvest is what the trade calls a short hedge. In the hedging scenario calculator you enter the same two numbers and get back the price you keep, not the one on the screen.
What you end up with is a hedge sheet, one page on paper or in a spreadsheet. On it you write the price you keep, the worst basis your costs can take, the bushels you hedge and why, and the cash set aside for the broker’s margin deposit. Fill it in before the broker calls, so that the futures quote is not the only number you have on the call.
What price do you keep when you sell futures?
You keep the futures price plus the basis, which is usually negative and so takes from the futures price, because the contract is priced at a delivery point that is not yours. Dhuyvetter, in a basis guide from Kansas State University extension, writes the arithmetic in one line: “Cash Price - Futures Price = Basis”, taken at the same moment. He gives the sign too: “A negative basis implies the futures price is greater than the cash price”. Freight, storage, quality, time of year and local supply open that gap, so a farm far from the delivery point usually sees a negative basis.
You sell futures now and buy them back when you sell the grain. If prices fall, the grain loses value and the futures position gains about the same. CME Group puts the result plainly: “Once you establish a hedge, the futures price level is locked in. The only variable is basis.”
Check the arithmetic from both sides. If the local price at delivery is $6.00 and the basis came in at 40 cents under, futures stand at $6.40. To close the position you buy futures back, at $1.60 more than you sold them for, and $6.00 minus $1.60 is $4.40. If the local price is $3.60, futures stand at $4.00, the position gains $0.80, and $3.60 plus $0.80 is $4.40 again. That price is before brokerage, exchange fees and the interest on the margin cash. Ask the broker for each and write the three next to the price you keep.
What if the basis ends up somewhere else?
Then you keep a different price, because the basis is the one number the hedge leaves open. CME Group states the trade in one sentence: “By hedging with futures, buyers and sellers are eliminating futures price level risk and assuming basis level risk”. In the example, a basis of 55 cents under instead of 40 gives $4.25 a bushel, which is $7,500 less on 50,000 bushels. Only the hedged bushels carry that risk, because the unhedged ones sell at the local price of the day, which already contains whatever basis turned up.
Hedging swaps the price risk for a smaller risk, because the basis moves less than the price. Kansas State says basis levels generally can be predicted with more accuracy than either futures or cash price levels. Less movement is not zero movement. The basis reflects local supply and demand, and in the guide’s wheat example “basis became more negative as the 1990 wheat harvest got underway”.
Your expected basis comes from your own record. Take the average basis for the same week of the year, at the same delivery point and against the same contract month, over three to five years. Kansas State calls this the most common method, “a historical average (3-5 years)”, and its example is a five-year average of weekly basis for soybeans in Topeka, Kansas. The week matters because the basis at one place changes through the year. An average of the last few weeks gives you the basis of now, not the basis of your delivery week.
With only a year or two of your own prices, average the same week in those years and treat the result as a starting point, with more uncertainty than a five-year average. Those years come from a price record with a source: a weekly log of your buyer’s bid, the futures quote and the gap between them. The article on a price record with a source shows the method with cattle. Write the expected basis with the date, the place and the contract month it came from. A basis borrowed from another delivery point or another month is a different number under the same name. A local crop bigger than in the years of the average calls for writing the basis further under, with the size of the adjustment and the reason beside it.
How far the basis can go comes from your floor. The break-even basis is the floor minus the locked futures price: $4.10 minus $4.80 is minus $0.70, or 70 cents under. With an expected basis of 40 cents under, you have 30 cents a bushel of room. If the basis comes in worse than 70 cents under, the hedged bushels bring less than they cost. That room applies to the hedged bushels only, and the unhedged ones keep following the market.
How many bushels should you put on futures?
Fewer than all of them, as a table of prices at delivery shows. Each row is one local price at delivery. Next to it is what the whole crop averages with no hedge, and with 50,000 of the 100,000 expected bushels hedged at $4.80 and a basis of 40 cents under.
| Local price at delivery | No hedge | With 50,000 of 100,000 hedged |
|---|---|---|
| $3.60 | $3.60 | $4.00 |
| $4.20 | $4.20 | $4.30 |
| $4.80 | $4.80 | $4.60 |
| $5.40 | $5.40 | $4.90 |
| $6.00 | $6.00 | $5.20 |
With no hedge, what you receive spans $2.40, from $3.60 to $6.00. With half hedged it spans $1.20, from $4.00 to $5.20. Only the unhedged half still follows the market, so hedging half halves the range and hedging everything leaves only the basis moving. At $3.60 the average of $4.00 is still 10 cents under the floor, because the unhedged half sold at $3.60.
The price of that protection is in the table. At the best price the hedge cost $0.80 a bushel, $6.00 against $5.20. At the worst price it earned $0.40 a bushel, $4.00 against $3.60. You buy a narrower range of income, and the gain you give up in a rally is what you pay for it. The range matters most to a farmer with a fixed loan payment, cash that will not last a bad quarter, or inputs already bought at a set price. With cash to spare and freedom to choose the month of sale, the same protection gives up gains for little use.
The number of bushels comes from the smallest of three limits. The first is a yes-or-no floor test: $4.40 clears the $4.10 floor, so there is a share to hedge. If it did not, the share would be zero, because a hedge that locks a price below cost removes the uncertainty about a loss. The second is the production you are sure of, not the one you expect. In the example the sure production is 85,000 bushels and 20,000 are already sold under other contracts, which leaves 65,000. Count those 20,000 once, with the volume already priced.
The third is the cash you can keep sending to the margin account while the market rises, covered in the next section. In the example, the cash set aside for margin covers a $1.00 rise on 50,000 bushels, or $50,000. The smallest of the three is 50,000 bushels. CME Group notes that “each futures contract equals 5,000 bushels” of corn, so that is 10 contracts. Write the number and the reason it is that one next to it on the hedge sheet, because by next year the reason is what you forget.
Hedging more than you grow turns protection into a bet against the market. Contracts come in fixed sizes, so rounding up on a small crop can pass your expected production. A short harvest does the same: a position sized for the yield you expected covers more than the yield you got. Compare the hedged bushels with the production estimate every time the estimate changes.
In the example, 150,000 bushels hedged against 100,000 grown average $4.80 per bushel harvested if the market ends at $3.60 and $3.60 if it ends at $6.00. The extra 50,000 bushels gain when the market falls and lose when it rises, on grain you do not have. The calculator shows a warning when you enter more than the expected production.
Sometimes the right number is zero even when the price clears the floor. That happens if the basis was never measured at your delivery point, if this year’s production is too uncertain to cover any amount, or if no cash is set aside for a long rally. Measuring the basis, revising the estimate and setting cash aside fix all three.
What cash do you need to set aside before delivery?
When you sell futures, you receive nothing for months and have to send the broker cash first, just as prices rise. CME Group describes the mechanism. When the futures price moves against an open position, funds will be withdrawn from the customer’s margin account to cover the loss. Margin is the deposit the broker holds against your position, and topping it up is what the guide calls receiving a margin call.
When prices rise, the short position loses on the futures side. In the example, a $1.00 rise in the December futures price takes $50,000 out of the margin account on the 10 contracts. The higher price for your grain reaches you only at delivery, months later. You can be protected on price and still run short of cash. The calculator gives you the price at delivery, not the cash you need on the way.
Ask the broker for the margin per contract before you sign, and set aside cash for a rise as large as the market has made before, not the one you expect. In 2008, Cruz Júnior and colleagues surveyed 90 corn growers in the South and Center-West of Brazil and found that they held a perception of risk below the risk of the market. It is one year’s sample, not a portrait of the country. A position you cannot carry to delivery gets closed at the worst moment, with the futures loss already paid and the gain still in the field.
Where do you start the hedge sheet, and how long does it take?
With the futures price you can lock and the expected basis, the two numbers in the sum, your price record and your cost of production in hand. The sheet takes an hour, before the broker calls.
The blank line at the bottom is the one that pays off. Fill it in at delivery and you see how far the real basis landed from the one you expected. After a few seasons your expected basis comes from your own record instead of a borrowed average. Before the sheet itself comes the break-even price, your cost per bushel.
That line, the gap between the exchange quote and your own buyer’s bid on delivery day, is a piece of marketing no one else can keep for you. In farm management, a record like this is what the other decisions on the farm draw on. Related: What does a put option’s price floor really cost?.