Skip to content
Assessment
LibraryMarketing

What interest rate is hidden when inputs are paid in grain?

The supplier's offer lists no interest, but there is one inside it. Divide what the bushels are worth on delivery day by the cash price, subtract one, and test the answer with the grain price 10 percent higher and lower.

Published Updated 16 min read
In this article

To find the interest hidden in inputs paid with grain, divide what the bushels are worth by the cash price of the same inputs, subtract one, and turn the result into a yearly rate. Nobody knows today what the grain will be worth on delivery day, so today’s bid for that month stands in for it. Here is an example, with invented prices, quantities and days. Before planting, a supplier offers one package of seed, fertilizer and chemicals two ways: $240 an acre in cash, or 22 bushels of soybeans an acre, due at harvest 210 days later. The farmer takes the inputs now and delivers the bushels later, so the second offer is a loan, though no line on it says interest. At a bid of $12.00 a bushel (the price a grain buyer offers today for delivery that month) the 22 bushels are worth $264.00. That is $24.00 more than cash for the same package, which is 10.0 percent of $240.00 over 210 days, about 17.4 percent a year.

That rate is not fixed. The bushels are fixed, but what they are worth in dollars follows the grain price. With grain 10 percent lower or 10 percent higher, the same offer runs from −1.7 to 36.5 percent a year. Run the calculation at those two prices too, then set the rate beside what a bank loan would cost and what your own money would earn. The arrangement is called barter in Brazil and canje in Argentina.

Does paying in grain cost interest?

Yes, and it is written in bushels instead of a rate. Alvim, Rossi and Saito of Markestrat Group, a Brazilian agribusiness consultancy, explain in a 2026 article that the price of a barter sits in the exchange ratio. That is how much grain the farmer delivers for the package, and it can be stated per acre. Every ratio carries an implied grain price, and doing barter amounts to selling that grain ahead to the supplier.

An Argentine accounting paper on canje (Goytia, Marcolini and Verón, 2008) describes the invoice as written in kilograms of grain at the grain price of the day of the deal. The authors add that an invoice not paid on delivery does not seem to be a cash price, because interest may be inside it. In the accounts, that interest has to be separated from the price of the input. A Brazilian review of barter, own capital and bank financing for soybean inputs (Trentin, Menezes Filho and Ventura, 2022) starts from the same point: every credit operation has a cost. Lenders charge different rates, and paying from your own capital costs what that money would have earned elsewhere.

Studies from the United States also find the cost inside the price. Fiechter and Ifft, of Cornell University, found in 2019 that the interest of seed companies was comparable to the rates on operating lines from banks. It was often between the prime rate (the benchmark lending rate of US banks) and prime plus 1 percent. The difference was in the discount. For most companies, a buyer who financed got about 5 percentage points less off the base price than a buyer who paid cash. The authors say that gap may help cover the cost of offering the financing. Those are loans in money for seed, not grain deals, so they serve here only as a yardstick for the bank comparison below.

Figure: The same package of inputs, per acre, in cash and in grain at the $12.00 bid. Example values; bars start at zero
The grain price is $24 above the cash pricePer acre: $240.00 in cash, or 22 bushels at a $12.00 bid, worth $264.00. The gap of $24.00 is the interest written in bushels.Same inputs, two prices, per acreIn cash: $240.00In grain: 22 bu × $12.00 = $264.00Price of the package in cashThe gap: $24.00 an acre

How do you work out the rate from two prices?

Ask the supplier for two prices for the same package, both in writing and both quoted with taxes included or both without: the cash price, and the price in bushels. Tax rules differ by country and are not covered here. Then ask your own buyer for today’s bid on grain delivered in the month the bushels are due. The cash price must be one the supplier would really accept; where it will not quote one, ask a second supplier for the same package.

Count the days from the date the inputs arrive to the date the bushels are due. If the inputs arrive in parts, work out each part with its own days. The conversion between year and period works in both directions. An Argentine thesis on canje (Kuhn, 2026) goes from the year to the period: the rate for the period is the annual rate times the days over 365. In the thesis’s case, the invoice was in dollars and carried the rate in writing: 9 percent a year, set by the invoicing company, which over 205 days came to 5.05 percent. A price in bushels does not carry that rate in writing, and it is what this article looks for. This article runs it backwards, from the period to the year: the rate for the period times 365 over the days, as in the 10.0 percent times 365 over 210 above. Use the simple version (no interest on interest) to compare with a bank quote that is also simple, and the compound one (interest on interest) if the bank quotes it that way.

The same example offer read two ways, per acre and 210 days
Reading Calculation Result
Rate for the period $264.00 ÷ $240.00 − 1 10.0%
Rate per year, simple 10.0% × 365 ÷ 210 17.4%
Rate per year, compound 1.10 to the power of (365 ÷ 210), − 1 18.0%
Grain price the supplier’s offer implies $240.00 ÷ 22 bu $10.91 a bushel
Gap to the $12.00 bid ($12.00 − $10.91) ÷ $12.00 9.1%

The last two lines show the same offer from the grain side. In that offer, the supplier values each bushel at $10.91 ($240.00 divided by 22), while a buyer is bidding $12.00 for that month. In effect the farmer sells the 22 bushels ahead to the supplier at $10.91. The 9.1 percent between the two prices may cover the credit and the supplier’s own risk, and how much goes to each is a matter for negotiation. The two prices are the numbers to bring to it.

Figure: From two prices to one rate, per acre. Example values
Two prices give a rate of 10.0 percent in 210 daysCash price $240.00. Grain value 22 bushels at $12.00, which is $264.00. Gap over cash 10.0 percent in 210 days. Simple rate per year 17.4 percent. The offer implies a grain price of $10.91 a bushel.From two prices to one rateCash price$240.0022 bu × $12.00 bid$264.00Gap over cash, 210 days10.0%Per year, simple17.4%Grain price the offer implies$10.91Rate = grain value ÷ cash price − 1Example values, per acre

What happens to the rate when the grain price moves?

It moves with it, because the bushels are fixed and the dollars are not. The 10.0 percent holds only if the bid proves right and the grain is worth $12.00 on delivery day. The same happens in an Argentine canje. The invoice is written in kilograms, and at delivery the supplier values the kilograms at the price of that day. Then it issues a debit note, a bill for the difference from the price of the day of the deal. Either way, the grain price on delivery day decides what the package cost. With the grain price 10 percent lower or higher than the bid, paying for the package in grain costs between $237.60 and $290.40, against $240.00 in cash.

What the 22 bushels cost if the grain price moves, per acre and 210 days
Grain price on delivery day Value of 22 bushels Rate for the period Rate per year, simple
$10.80 (10% below the bid) $237.60 −1.0% −1.7%
$12.00 (the bid) $264.00 10.0% 17.4%
$13.20 (10% above the bid) $290.40 21.0% 36.5%
Figure: Simple rate per year for the same offer at three grain prices on delivery day. Example values
The same offer costs between −1.7 and 36.5 percent a yearSimple rate per year for 22 bushels per acre against a $240 cash price: −1.7 percent with grain at $10.80, 17.4 percent at the $12.00 bid, 36.5 percent at $13.20.Rate per year, simple−1.7%17.4%36.5%−10%$10.80Bid$12.00+10%$13.20Grain price a bushel on delivery day

Alvim, Rossi and Saito describe the operation as a trade where, after the contract, what one side gains from the grain price the other loses. The package was priced as if the grain were worth $10.91 a bushel. If the grain ends above that, the supplier comes out ahead, and if it ends below, the farmer does. In the example, grain at $10.80 makes the package cost $237.60, less than the $240.00 cash price. Johann, Cunha and Wander surveyed input resellers in Goiás and Mato Grosso in 2015, and 39 answered (13 percent of those contacted). Asked to rank three risks of barter (price, credit, pests and rain), 41 percent put price risk first and 36 percent credit risk. The survey asked resellers, not farmers, and the sample is small.

Two consequences follow for the farmer. First, the 22 bushels are committed from the day the contract is signed. They go on your list of what you have already sold, in bushels and for the harvest month, next to your forward contracts. Without that row, the same bushels can be promised twice. Second, the supplier is owed those bushels at harvest. When you compare what turns into cash with what falls due within twelve months (the current ratio), they count on the due side as a debt, worth the bushels times the $12.00 bid. The list is kept in bushels and the debt is in dollars, so the grain carries one price, the bid; the $10.91 only appears in the comparison above.

How does it compare with the bank and with paying cash?

Compare three ways of paying for the same package over the same 210 days: the bushels, a bank loan, and your own money. Each cost is the extra you pay over paying cash on day one. A bank loan at an example 15 percent a year costs 15 × 210 ÷ 365 = 8.63 percent of $240.00, which is $20.71 an acre. The bushels cost $24.00 at the bid, $3.29 more. With the grain 10 percent higher they cost $50.40, more than twice the bank. With the grain 10 percent lower they cost $2.40 less than paying cash. The 15 percent is an example, not a quote; ask your bank for the real rate. Your own money costs what it would have earned in those days, the opportunity cost Trentin and colleagues describe. To put a number on it, ask your bank for its deposit rate over 210 days and run the same calculation on the $240.00.

Figure: Extra cost over paying cash, per acre, for 210 days. Bank at an example 15 percent a year. Example values
A bank loan costs $20.71 an acre; the bushels cost $24.00 or moreExtra cost over the $240 cash price for 210 days: bank at 15 percent a year, $20.71; bushels at the $12.00 bid, $24.00; bushels with grain 10 percent higher, $50.40.Extra cost over cash, per acreBank, 15% a year: $20.71Bushels at the bid: $24.00Bushels, grain +10%: $50.40With grain −10%: $2.40 less than cash

The order changes with the year and with the offer. Ifft and four colleagues compared seed corn for the 2026 crop across 21 US suppliers in autumn 2025. They compared each supplier’s credit with a bank line at 8.07 percent (the average operating loan rate in the second quarter of 2025) used to pay cash and take the discount. They found that credit from the supplier was slightly cheaper on average, about $5 an acre early, narrowing to $1 or $2 near January 1. This is largely because several suppliers charged 0 percent to buyers who booked early. Among the suppliers that offered both financing and a discount for early payment, their credit beat the bank line in 88 percent of the periods analyzed. With the bank rate averaging 5 percent the two cost about the same, and at 4 percent the bank may have been slightly cheaper. Fees, grace periods and collateral were not counted. In 2019 Fiechter and Ifft worked a hypothetical case with seed at $113.50 an acre. For the seed company’s financing to beat both borrowing elsewhere and taking the early-pay cash discount, its rate would have to be close to zero.

In every one of these comparisons the cost sits inside a price. You find it by subtraction, the way you take the futures price (the exchange price for that month) from a buyer’s bid to find the fee inside a forward bid. Whatever the result, the 22 bushels owed are part of this crop, already promised to the supplier for a set month. Besides your list of what is sold, they belong in your written selling plan, as one more sale on its own row.

The arithmetic here is exact, and the prices, quantities and days are invented. The Brazilian and Argentine sources describe the arrangement, and the US studies measure credit in money. None of the sources cited here measures the implied rate of real barter or canje deals on farms. Use the 10.0 percent as a starting point, not as a market rate: run the same calculation with your supplier’s two prices and your buyer’s bid, with the grain 10 percent higher and lower. The same comparison of two prices works for other marketing offers, and it is a routine part of farm management.

Where to start

The work takes about an hour, with the supplier’s two prices and today’s bid from your buyer in front of you. None of it needs special software or a price forecast.

Figure: The rate in six steps, from the two prices to the filed calculation
Six steps from the two prices to the filed pageTwo prices in writing; the days between the two dates; bid times bushels over cash price minus one; the same with grain 10 percent down and up; the bank and own-money cost; the bushels added to the list of what is sold and counted as a debt, with the calculation filed with the contract.The rate in six steps1Two prices, in writing2Days between the two dates3Bid × bushels ÷ cash − 14Same, grain 10% down and up5Bank and own-money cost6Bushels listed, calculation filed

Related: In which month will your farm’s cash run lowest?. Related: What does a put option’s price floor really cost?.

Provenance

Derives from
  1. Alvim, Rossi and Saito, Barter na safra das margens curtas: Quando a troca compensa, Markestrat, October 5, 2026
  2. Goytia, Marcolini and Verón, Las operaciones de canje en la actividad agrícola: su tratamiento contable e impositivo, XXX Simposio Nacional de Profesores de Práctica Profesional, Universidad Nacional de Rosario, 2008
  3. Kuhn, Análisis situacional: canje de insumos en escenario de tasas negativas, Trabajo Final de Carrera de Ingeniería Agronómica, Universidad Nacional del Sur, June 2026
  4. Johann, Cunha and Wander, Operações de barter para financiamento da produção de soja e milho em Goiás e Mato Grosso, Brasil, Revista SODEBRAS 12(143), November 2017
  5. Trentin, Menezes Filho and Ventura, Análise das modalidades barter, capital próprio e financiamento de insumos no cultivo da soja no Brasil, Brazilian Journal of Science 1(12):83-95, 2022
  6. Fiechter and Ifft, Seed Corn Costs: How Do Discounts Work with Seed Company Financing?, farmdoc daily 9:191, University of Illinois, October 11, 2019
  7. Fiechter and Ifft, Seed Corn Costs: Cost of Seed Company Financing vs. Traditional Financing, farmdoc daily 9:194, University of Illinois, October 16, 2019
  8. Ifft, Guetterman, Hughes, Parcell and Roach, Comparing Costs to Finance Seed Corn Purchases: Vendor Financing or Bank Loan, RaFF Policy Brief 2025-12(1), Rural and Farm Finance Policy Analysis Center, December 19, 2025
What this article covers
Working out the interest rate hidden in a price paid in grain, from the cash price of the inputs and the bid for the grain on the delivery date: the rate for the period and for the year, the price per bushel inside the offer, the same rate with the grain price 10 percent up and down, and the comparison with a bank loan and with your own money.
What it does not cover
Whether to sign, which supplier to use, or where the grain price will go, which is a forecast this article does not make. It does not cover taxes, which differ by country and by contract, the legal form of the contract, the supplier's credit risk or the quality terms for the grain, and it interprets no country's law. Locking the grain price with a buyer and the price you keep after hedging are covered in separate articles on marketing.
Published
Updated
Error found
Point out an error and the article is corrected with a note on what changed.

How to cite this article

Rurivia. (2026, October 27). What interest rate is hidden when inputs are paid in grain? https://rurivia.com/en/library/marketing/what-rate-hides-in-paying-inputs-with-grain/


Keep reading

Marketing

Selling as a group: what is written before you deliver?

Two farmers deliver 10,000 bushels each to the same pool and are paid $104,000 and $97,760. One line of the agreement, the grade schedule, explains the $6,240. Three written answers on one dated page show that line before the first load.

Oct 28, 2026
Marketing

Cattle price history: record the bid your own buyer gave you

A public auction report shows what lots sold for. It does not show what your own buyer offered you. Keep that bid in a weekly price record beside the report, with the buyer named and a selling rule written before the first line.

Aug 27, 2026
Marketing

Soybean break-even price: write two numbers first

The break-even price you find published is built from another farm's costs. Write two for your own farm, and you know at once whether an offer covers the cost of growing the crop and whether it also covers the land.

Aug 27, 2026
Marketing

Soybean profit per acre: write yours before you plant

The figure you find online carries another farm's costs, yield and price, and it moves with the date. Yours, written before planting, is the only one that shows at harvest whether the gap came from price, yield or cost.

Aug 27, 2026

Farm Management

If this article were a plant, farm management would be the whole field.

Planning, organizing, leading and controlling: the four functions, what each one decides, and a farm example for each, all on one page.