Two farmers each deliver 10,000 bushels of soybeans to the same co-op pool, the channel where the co-op sells all members’ grain together and pays each member from the combined proceeds. One is paid $104,000 and the other $97,760. The $6,240 gap comes from a single line of the marketing agreement, the grade schedule, which sets a price factor for each quality category a lot can fall into. Neither farmer had read it before the first load. Before you deliver to a group that sells together and pays later, get three answers in writing: who decides the sale, how the price is split by grade and volume, and when each payment arrives. Copy them on one page, date it and check it against the contract.
Who decides when the group sells, and can you take a lot back?
In a seasonal pool, the kind that takes a set volume with no price agreed in advance, the farmer hands over the sale. Hammonds studied five U.S. pools, in rice, soybeans, wheat and cotton. In them, price, terms of sale and timing were left to the professional management. Most required the member’s whole crop, declared in advance, and the contracts carried a damage clause large enough to discourage a failure to deliver. Responsibility for the crop passed to the association on delivery. The trade is plain: you give up the choice of day and buyer, and you receive an average price without carrying the timing risk yourself. That trade costs most when your grain is better than the pool’s average.
The 2006 federal rule on cooperative marketing associations describes the same arrangement: the member signs a marketing agreement that gives the association authority to perform the marketing functions on the member’s behalf.
The first answer, who decides, has four parts, and all four go on paper before the first load. Who decides the sale day and the buyer: a name or a body, such as the board or the manager. Whether you can set a minimum price or hold a lot back. What delivering less than the declared volume costs. The last date to give notice if you want out. In the Riceland rice pool that Hammonds describes, a grower who wanted to leave was expected to give notice by February 15, before the harvest.
How much of the crop goes to the pool is a decision for the farm’s own written selling plan, made before the volume is declared. Who decides inside the pool is set by the members’ vote at the assembly. The farm’s co-op membership record shows what it owns in the co-op and the date it last voted, which tells you whether you had a say in the rules.
How is the pool’s price split between a good lot and a poor one?
A pool does not pay the sale price of your bushels. It pays each member out of the combined proceeds, and the contract says how. Grade is the category a lot falls into after inspection, for soybeans by moisture, damaged beans and foreign material. A pool that adjusts by grade pays each member the price of the grade delivered. Hammonds explains when that adjustment arrives: at delivery the price gap between grades is not yet known, so most of the pools he studied paid advances at a fixed level regardless of quality. At the end of the season the association adjusted each member’s whole volume to the price of the grade actually delivered.
The numbers that follow are illustrative, not from any real pool. The pool sells the top grade at a base price of $10.40 a bushel, and the grade schedule pays 94% of that base for the lower grade. Of every five lots in the pool, three are top grade and two are lower, so the average factor is 0.976 and the pool’s average price is $10.1504 a bushel, about $10.15. Each farmer delivers 10,000 bushels. Two ways of splitting the proceeds are compared: under the average rule, every lot is paid the pool’s average price; under the grade rule, each lot is paid the price of its own grade.
| Lot | Grade factor | Paid under the average rule | Paid under the grade rule |
|---|---|---|---|
| Premium lot | 1.00 | 101,504 | 104,000 |
| Lower lot | 0.94 | 101,504 | 97,760 |
Which rule the contract holds decides who gains. The farmer with the cleanest grain gives up $2,496 under one average, and the farmer with the poorest gains $3,744. Neither number appears on the delivery ticket; both come from the agreement. A grade rule is fair only if you can read the schedule before you deliver. Without it, the factor of 0.94 is a surprise in the last payment. The article on pricing a load against the buyer’s discount table shows the calculation; ask the pool for its own table and run last season’s lot through it.
Costs change the same $104,000. In one worked example in Hammonds, storage at 15 cents, interest at 6 cents and other expenses at 4 cents, all per hundredweight (100 pounds), came out of the pool before the final payment. Ask which costs are deducted and whether they are charged per bushel or as a share of the proceeds. In Canada’s price pooling program, a surplus above the guaranteed amount is either kept in the pool or distributed to producers by the grade, variety and type of product each delivered.
When does each payment arrive, and which one can still change?
The typical marketing agreement that the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) described in 2006, for grain, oilseed, rice and cotton associations, pays an advance soon after delivery. The advance rate is usually equal to the federal crop loan rate, the rate of a U.S. government loan with the crop as security. Interim payments may follow during the crop year. The final settlement, the payment that closes the account, comes at the end of it, at a rate that depends on the pool’s total proceeds after advances and expenses. In the pools Hammonds studied, the board fixed the advance each year. In the Riceland pool, the final payment came on or about September 15 of the year after harvest.
On the example farm, the premium lot is paid in three installments. The advance is $70,000 on October 15, the day of delivery, which is $7.00 a bushel. An interim payment of $15,000 follows on January 31. The final settlement of $19,000 arrives on June 30, 8.5 months after delivery.
By January 31 the farm has $85,000, which is 82% of the $104,000. The last 18% comes five months later, and it is the only payment that can still change. If the pool pays advances at a fixed level, the lower lot also gets $70,000 and $15,000. The whole $6,240 gap then lands in the final payment: $19,000 for the premium lot against $12,760 for the lower lot ($97,760 - $85,000). A bill due in March is paid from the $85,000 or from credit, never from the final payment.
Write the final payment on the farm’s list of who still owes you and since when, with the date the contract promises it. A payment that is late has a date to be asked about. Hammonds is from 1976 and describes pools in rice, soybeans, wheat and cotton; the 2006 rule describes the same sequence in the associations USDA then dealt with. Your group’s contract is the only source for its own dates.
What do you ask the group for first, and by when?
Ask for three documents before the date the pool asks you to declare your volume: the marketing agreement, the grade schedule and the co-op settlement sheets of the last two seasons. The settlement sheet is the statement the co-op issues when it closes a delivery, with the final price, the deductions and the advances already paid. In the last two seasons’ sheets you can see the rules applied to real lots.
Then fill one page with three blocks, one per answer. The first holds who decides, the sale day, the buyer and the right to pull a lot out. The second holds the factor for each grade, the costs and any volume tiers. The third holds each payment with its date and its amount per bushel. Next to every line, write the clause of the contract that says it. A line with no clause is a promise made by word, so ask for it in writing.
Tomorrow, write to the co-op office and ask for those three documents, with a date to answer that falls before the volume declaration. When they arrive, fill the page, then run your last lot through the schedule as shown in pricing a load against the buyer’s discount table. Any line the contract does not back goes back to the group in writing before the first load. Working out these rules is part of managing the farm as a business; other articles on selling are in the marketing section of the library.