Skip to content
Assessment
LibraryFinance

Is your farm's margin really behind a public reference?

Your margin is 12% and a published figure for farms like yours is 15%: are you behind? One table answers it, with your number for each of three to five years beside the published figure for the same year, and how each side counts cost.

Published Updated 18 min read
In this article

Last year your farm’s margin, what was left of the year’s production after costs, was 12%. A public reference (also called a benchmark: the published margin of a group of similar farms) says 15%. Are you behind? You cannot tell yet. First check that the reference counts cost the way your books do, then check whether the same gap, your number minus the reference, shows up in your other years.

A gap to a public reference means something only when you read it year by year, over three to five years, with the same definition of cost on both sides. One year misleads because the farms at the top keep changing. Of 601 Kansas farms, only 18 (3.0%) stayed in the top margin quartile, the quarter of the farms with the highest margin, in each of the five years from 2015 to 2019.

At the end you have one table with a row per number. Each row holds your figure for each year and the reference for the same year. It also holds how each side counts cost and result, and the decision the gap supports with the name of the person who answers for it. The table does not prove that comparing improves results. It keeps you from acting on a gap that comes from a different definition of cost or from one unusual year. The examples come from Kansas, England, Argentina and Brazil.

Why read your own series before anyone else’s number?

Because a good or bad year moves most farms’ numbers together, and your own years (your series, the same number for each year) are the one comparison that keeps the same farm on both sides. Michael Langemeier, an agricultural economist at Purdue University, defines benchmarking as comparing a farm with its own past and with the performance of other farms.

In Kansas cattle records, a year alone moves a number a long way. From 1975 to 2017, the cow-calf farmers of the Kansas Farm Management Association (member farms that keep records) averaged $75.05 per cow over variable costs. The worst year was 2009, at -$76.40, and the best was 2014, at $576.95. The authors attribute the swings to the cattle cycle and to input costs and demand, and note that factors of this kind reach all farmers in a similar way.

Whole-farm margin swings the same way. The margin used here is the operating profit margin. The calculation starts from net farm income (the farm’s earnings after all its bills, interest included). Add back the interest and subtract a wage for the unpaid labor of the family and the operator. Then divide by the value of farm production. The value of farm production is what the farm produced in the year, sold or stored (counting it is covered in the revenue produced in the year). In words, it is what was left of the year’s production after every cost except interest, with unpaid labor costed at a wage. In the records of the Kansas Farm Management Association for 2008 to 2017, the average margin was 12.1% and the top quartile’s 23.4%. Langemeier and Yeager, the authors of that study, recommend a margin of at least 20%, and add that it was easy to reach in 2008, 2010 and 2011 and very hard from 2015 to 2017.

So a single year of your margin mixes your farm with the year. Subtracting the reference for the same year removes the part of the move that reached farms in general. A gap that repeats over several years is more likely to come from your farm, or from how you and the reference count. Write the gap in the table, not only your level.

Figure: Gap between the farm's margin and the reference group's, year by year, with invented values
The farm was ahead of the group for four years, then fell behindGap to the group's margin, in points: year 1, +3; year 2, +3; year 3, +2; year 4, +1; year 5, -3. The average gap is +1.2 points, and the gap fell in each of the last three years.Gap to the group, in points of marginYear 1+3Year 2+3Year 3+2Year 4+1Year 5-3Average gap: +1.2 pointsThe gap fell in each of the last three years

Not every number is read this way. Liquidity (cash on hand against bills due) is read against your own history only. So are solvency (what you own against what you owe) and repayment capacity (whether the year’s earnings cover the debt payments). Langemeier advises reading profitability and efficiency against your history and against other farms. So the check of whether the debt fits what the farm earns uses your own years only.

Does the reference measure the same thing you do?

Often it does not, and the way each side counts cost can matter more than the gap you came to measure. Take 437 Kansas farms, averaged over 2010 to 2019: their costs came out as 0.804, 0.919 or 1.099 of the value of production, depending on what was counted. Each figure is an expense ratio, the costs divided by the value of production, so 0.804 means that 80.4 of every 100 of production value went to costs. The three ratios differ in what counts as cost, not in the farms. The first, the total expense ratio, counts cash costs and depreciation (the wear on machines and buildings). It also counts accrual adjustments (booking each bill and sale in the year it belongs to). The second, the adjusted ratio, adds a wage for the unpaid labor of the family and the operator. The third, the economic ratio, also adds a charge for what the farm’s own capital would earn if invested elsewhere (its opportunity cost). A ratio below 1.00 means the production value covered those costs.

A farm clears each of the three with different odds. Of the farms, 94.3% had a total expense ratio below 1.00, 63.8% had the adjusted one below 1.00, and 11.9% had the economic one below 1.00. A farm that writes “my costs are covered” against the first definition and finds a reference built on the third has compared two different statements.

Figure: What is left of 100 of production value under three definitions of cost, Kansas farms, 2010 to 2019
The definition of cost moves the result by 29.5 pointsPer 100 of production value: 19.6 left after costs and depreciation, 8.1 left after adding a wage for unpaid family labor, and 9.9 missing after also adding the return on the farm's own capital.Left of 100 of production valueAfter costs and depreciation19.6Adding unpaid family labor8.1Adding return on own capital-9.9Same farms, same year, three answers

Brazil shows the same problem, because two public sources publish production costs there and each splits cost in several ways. Campo Futuro is a project of the Brazilian farm confederation (CNA) and its rural training service (Senar). It separates the effective operating cost, the total operating cost (which adds depreciation and the owner’s pay) and the total cost. Conab, Brazil’s national food supply agency, has a cost-of-production methodology norm. It also separates the variable cost, the fixed cost, the operating cost, the return on the farm’s own land and capital (which Conab calls the income of the fixed factors) and the total cost. A cost per sack (the 60 kg bag Brazilian grain is priced in) quoted from either source is one of these costs, so ask which one before you set it beside your own.

England’s Farm Business Survey, the government survey of farm accounts, counts unpaid labor as a cost when it measures economic performance, so that farms with employees and farms run by the family can be compared. Its Farm Business Income does not deduct unpaid labor. In the table at the end of this article, copy a line like that from the reference’s own method page, what it counts as cost, beside your number before you read any gap.

What does the reference describe: measured farms, a typical farm or a yield scenario?

A reference is one of three kinds, and each answers a different question. A measured group is the accounts of real farms, counted and ranked, such as the Kansas association records or the English survey: you see where you stand among farms. A typical farm is one farm that a panel of local farmers and technicians agrees represents the region, such as the Conab and Campo Futuro costs: you see what a common technology costs. A scenario by yield level is a calculation for a chosen yield. The Argentine gross margins from INTA Pergamino (the Pergamino station of Argentina’s national agricultural research institute) are one: you see what each yield leaves. Reading one kind as if it were another gives a wrong answer. The Brazilian and Argentine references in this article are of the second and third kind, so they cannot show where you stand among farms the way the Kansas records do.

Langemeier advises comparing with the top quartile rather than the average. The five-year records show why: in 2015 to 2019, the top quartile averaged a margin of 16.5% against 3.3% for the whole sample. But the farms in the top quartile of one year are often not the same the next. Only 18 farms (3.0%) stayed there all five years. So read your margin against a top-quartile figure averaged over several years, such as the 16.5% above, and not against the top quartile of one year, which is a different set of farms each time.

In the English survey, a ranking by cost alone would mislead. For lowland grazing livestock farms in 2019/20 to 2021/22, the top fifth (the fifth of the farms with the best return) spent £981 a hectare against £818 for the bottom fifth. The top fifth produced output worth £1,496 a hectare against £745. For every £100 spent, the top fifth produced £153 of output and the bottom fifth £91. Langemeier makes the same point: relatively high production may correspond to relatively high cost per unit. Every cost row gets a production row beside it.

Figure: Cost and output a hectare, top and bottom fifth of lowland grazing livestock farms in England, 2019/20 to 2021/22
The top fifth spent more a hectare and produced twice as muchCost a hectare: top fifth £981, bottom fifth £818. Output a hectare: top fifth £1,496, bottom fifth £745. For every £100 spent, the top fifth produced £153 of output and the bottom fifth £91.Pounds a hectare, lowland grazing livestockCost, top fifth£981Cost, bottom fifth£818Output, top fifth£1,496Output, bottom fifth£745Output per £100 spent: £153 against £91

A typical-farm reference does not rank anyone. Campo Futuro holds an annual panel in municipalities with a significant share of national output. In it, farmers, technicians and input dealers agree on a typical property, defined as the one that occurs most often in the region. Conab does the same for the most common production unit. Nobody counted the farms above and below that typical farm, so a cost below it does not place you in any quartile. What you learn is whether your technology costs more or less than the usual one in the region.

A yield-level scenario is a third thing. The INTA Pergamino gross margins (revenue minus direct costs) for the 2024/2025 season set a low, a medium and a high yield from the last ten seasons at the experimental field. Each crop also gets a break-even yield, the yield at which the crop just covers its costs. Your yield may fall below, between or above those three, so note in the yield row of the table which scenario you compare yourself with.

What do you do when your number is below the reference?

First find where the gap is, then give it an owner. Langemeier lists six steps: what to compare, who is responsible, the targets, collecting and analyzing the data, acting, and recalibrating. He calls acting when the benchmark is not satisfactory, and recalibrating, the most difficult. The table’s last column exists for that: a decision, and a name.

The gap can sit in more than one place. Return on assets, the profit for each dollar tied up in land, machines and buildings, is the operating profit margin times the asset turnover. Asset turnover is the value of production divided by total assets: how much the farm produces for each dollar tied up in them. In the 2015 to 2019 records, the 18 Kansas farms that stayed in the top margin quartile all five years had a margin of 25.3% and an asset turnover of 0.159. The 601-farm sample had 3.3% and 0.207. The farms at the top on margin were below the sample average on asset turnover. So a margin gap does not say by itself whether the work lies in margin or in turnover; read both before you pick where to act.

Figure: Margin and asset turnover, the 18 Kansas farms in the top quartile all five years against all 601 farms, 2015 to 2019
The farms on top for margin were below average in asset turnoverMargin: 25.3% for the 18 farms on top in all five years, 3.3% for all 601 farms. Asset turnover: 0.159 for the 18 farms, 0.207 for all 601.Kansas farms, 2015 to 2019Margin, 18 farms on top25.3%Margin, all 601 farms3.3%Asset turnover, 18 farms on top0.159Asset turnover, all 601 farms0.207Top in margin, below average in turnover

Size alone does not explain the high margins. The top margin quartile in 2015 to 2019 had a larger average farm. But large farms were not the only ones at the top: about 12% of its farms had a value of production below $250,000. Copy the reference’s size band into the table before you conclude that your farm is too small or too large to be compared with it.

On the production side, Defra, the English government department for farming, includes in its evidence pack research on beef cattle of the same breed. In it, the feed needed for the same growth varied by up to 23% between groups of animals. A cost gap per animal can lie first in how much feed each animal needed, and only then in the price paid for the feed. Your own records by field or by lot, as in each field’s yield, year by year, are where you find out.

Where to start

A morning, with the last three to five years of accounts and the reference’s method page on the desk. Write the table below with three to five rows, one of them for production, and fill the cells with your own numbers, years and references. The values in the example are invented.

Your number against its series and a public reference
Number Your last five years Reference to look up Same definition? Decision and who answers
Operating profit margin, percent of production value 14, 6, -2, 9, 12 Farm-association group for the same years, and the top quartile of the several-year average Yes, if both subtract a wage for unpaid family labor and add interest back Keep the plan or change the next season’s; owner
Output for each 100 spent 118, 104, 97, 109, 113 Survey of farms of the same type, top and bottom fifth No, if the survey counts unpaid labor as a cost and your books do not: recompute Whether the gap is in output or in cost; manager and agronomist
Yield per unit of area 58, 61, 55, 49, 60 (bushels an acre) Experimental-station scenario or group of similar farms Yes, if crop, soil and technology are similar; if not, treat the row as a hint and say so Which input or practice to change or test first; agronomist

How much margin the crop should leave has its own sheet, what this crop should leave you. The money side of managing a farm continues in the finance section of the library.

How far these sources reach: they are records of farm groups and public surveys, enough to see that farms differ and that the ranking moves from year to year. They do not show that comparing improves results, because no source assigned farms to compare or not and followed the outcome. The data come mostly from Kansas and England, from cattle and mixed farms, and no source tests a grain farm in the Brazilian Cerrado (the central grain region). Farms that keep records and join an association are not a random sample. The Brazilian references are typical farms agreed by a panel, not measured groups, and the Argentine one is a yield scenario at one experimental field. Related: Cost per bushel by field: your invoices over your harvest. Related: One-page farm dashboard: seven numbers, each dated.

Provenance

Derives from
  1. Langemeier, What Should My Farm Benchmark?, farmdoc daily (8):167, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, September 2018
  2. Langemeier and Yeager, Operating Profit Margin Benchmarks, farmdoc daily (8):159, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, August 2018
  3. Langemeier and Yeager, Operating Profit Margin Benchmarks, Kansas State University Department of Agricultural Economics, January 2021
  4. Langemeier and Yeager, Persistence in Financial Performance, Kansas State University Department of Agricultural Economics, January 2021
  5. Bowman, Pendell and Herbel, Differences Between High-, Medium-, and Low-Profit Cow-Calf Producers: An Analysis of 2013-2017 Kansas Farm Management Association Cow-Calf Enterprise, Kansas State University, September 2018
  6. Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (England), Farm performance and productivity: analysis of the Farm Business Survey, evidence pack, January 2024
  7. Fillat, Cabrini, Llovet and Paolilli, Margenes brutos de las principales actividades agricolas 2024/2025, INTA Pergamino, Indicadores economicos e informes tecnicos No. 3, September 2024
  8. Conab, Norma Metodologia do Custo de Producao 30.302, Companhia Nacional de Abastecimento (Brazil)
  9. CNA and Senar, Projeto Campo Futuro, Confederacao da Agricultura e Pecuaria do Brasil
What this article covers
Writing a cost or margin for your last three to five years, finding a public reference for it, checking that both count the same things, reading the gap year by year, and writing the decision and the person who answers for it.
What it does not cover
It does not work out cost per bushel or the contribution margin of a field, which have their own sheets. It does not say which number is good, set a price or predict a year, and it does not replace the accountant who closes the books.
Published
Updated
Error found
Point out an error and the article is corrected with a note on what changed.

How to cite this article

Rurivia. (2026, October 27). Is your farm's margin really behind a public reference? https://rurivia.com/en/library/finance/your-number-against-your-series-and-a-public-reference/


Keep reading

Finance

Farm machinery cost per hour: own it or hire the job?

Neither the tax return nor a published cost table holds the hourly cost of your own machine. The purchase invoice, the hour meter and the dealer's repair history do, and with them you can tell whether hiring the job out would cost less.

Aug 27, 2026
Finance

Does a machine pay for itself? Payback, NPV and your rate

Two dryers can earn their price back in 2.5 years and still end $227,425 apart in what is left. Judge a purchase by what is left after your own rate, then check the cash against the loan.

Sep 1, 2026
Finance

How do you rank crops by margin and trust the order?

Rank each field's crop options by revenue less variable cost per acre, then compare the gap between the top two with the margin the top one would lose in a bad year. If the gap is smaller, the two crops tie and the choice depends on what the ranking leaves out.

Oct 27, 2026
Finance

Crops and cattle on one plot: what does each one earn?

With the rule for dividing shared costs written first, each result can be checked from one year to the next, and the crop's and the cattle's results add up to the plot's result.

Oct 27, 2026

Farm Management

If this article were a plant, farm management would be the whole field.

Planning, organizing, leading and controlling: the four functions, what each one decides, and a farm example for each, all on one page.