Skip to content
Assessment
LibraryFinance

Does a machine pay for itself? Payback, NPV and your rate

Two dryers can earn their price back in 2.5 years and still end $227,425 apart in what is left. Judge a purchase by what is left after your own rate, then check the cash against the loan.

Published Updated 18 min read
In this article

On 12 February 2026, a dealer in Grand Island, Nebraska, shows a corn farmer two grain dryers (an example, with invented figures). The used dryer costs $120,000, the new one $200,000, and the dealer says each earns its price back in 2.5 years. The farmer wants 10% a year back on the money. Once that return is charged, the used dryer is $631 short and the new one has $226,794 left over. Choosing by the dealer’s date alone hides a $227,425 gap. Compare purchases by that leftover, called net present value (NPV), and check that the cash fits the loan. The one-page sheet at the end does both.

The dealer’s date is the payback: the time until the cash a purchase brings in adds up to its price. The dealer works it out on an envelope, price divided by what the machine saves in a year. Nobody is lying, and the date is worth knowing. What happens after it never enters the sum, and the whole gap between these two dryers comes from there.

If both dryers pay back in 2.5 years, why do they end so far apart?

The payback count ends on the day the running cash returns to zero, and that day is rarely the end of the machine’s life. The used dryer saves $48,000 a year for 3 years, $144,000 against a $120,000 price. The new dryer saves $80,000 a year for 8 years, $640,000 against $200,000. Both reach their price at 2.5 years. After that date the used dryer has half a year left and the new one has five and a half.

Money that arrives later is worth less than money in hand, because the farmer could use it sooner. Aswath Damodaran, a finance professor at New York University, publishes his course material openly. He writes that cash flows across time cannot be added up. They have to be brought to the same point in time before aggregation. A simple payback adds them anyway, which is why it is easy to do in your head.

To bring each year’s saving to today’s money, divide it by 1.10 (the 10% a year rate) once for every year of waiting: the $48,000 saved in year 2 counts as $39,669 today. Add the amounts in today’s money, take off the price, and what is left is the net present value (NPV).

Same payback, different value (invented example)
Two dryers, same payback, different valueTwo bars of equal length show the used and the new dryer both paying back in 2.5 years. Below, the used dryer has almost no bar, a loss of $631, and the new dryer has a long bar, adding $226,794.The two dryers at 10% a yearPayback, in yearsUsed dryer2.5 yearsNew dryer2.5 yearsNet present value at 10% a yearUsed dryera loss of $631New dryeradds $226,794
The two dryers in the example, at 10% a year
Used dryer New dryer
Price $120,000 $200,000
Saving per year $48,000 $80,000
Years of use 3 8
Payback 2.5 years 2.5 years
Net present value at 10% a year a loss of $631 $226,794

Graham and Harvey surveyed 392 chief financial officers of companies in the United States and Canada, and payback came out as the most-used technique after NPV and the internal rate of return. They sum up, in one line, the criticism that finance textbooks have repeated for decades: Payback ignores the time value of money and cash flows beyond the cutoff date; the cutoff is usually arbitrary. The cutoff is the longest payback the buyer will accept. Those are corporations, not farms, so the survey shows what finance professionals use, not what a farm should do. You can rebuild both dryers in the payback, net present value (NPV) and internal rate of return (IRR) calculator.

Which rate do you use, and can it change the answer?

The rate is the lowest yearly return you accept from this money, and it can turn a yes into a no without touching the machine. At 9% a year the used dryer adds $1,502. At 10% it loses $631, and at 12% it loses $4,712. The savings are the same in every row; only the rate changed.

The used dryer’s net present value at five rates
Rate per year Net present value
8% adds $3,701
9% adds $1,502
10% a loss of $631
12% a loss of $4,712
14% a loss of $8,562

The rate where the answer turns is 9.7% a year. It has a name, the internal rate of return (IRR), which Damodaran defines as the discount rate that sets the net present value equal to zero. It is the rate at which the table’s remainder reaches zero, this table read backwards.

The used dryer at five rates (invented example)
Used dryer: net present value at five ratesBars to the right show gains at 8% and 9% a year; bars to the left show losses at 10%, 12% and 14% a year. The answer turns near 9.7% a year.Net present value by yearly rate8% a yearadds $3,7019% a yearadds $1,50210% a yeara loss of $63112% a yeara loss of $4,71214% a yeara loss of $8,562

No table gives you the rate, so write it with its origin. Use the higher of two figures. One is the full yearly cost of the loan that would pay for the purchase, fees included. The other is what the money earns where it sits today. In the example the dealer’s loan costs 9% a year and the savings account pays 4%, so the base is 9%.

Then add a premium if the project is riskier than the farm’s ordinary work. Damodaran states the principle: The hurdle rate should be higher for riskier projects. The dryer’s saving depends on how wet the corn comes in and on the elevator’s drying charge, so the farmer adds 1 point, writes 10% and dates it.

A written rate can be set above the minimum. Bravo Motiño, in a thesis on an organic cacao farm in Honduras, put the owners’ opportunity cost (what the money would earn in another use) at 12.57% and used 15% anyway. The thesis judged 12.57% low for the risk of farm businesses and wanted to be stricter and more conservative.

One check catches a common mistake. Damodaran writes that if the cash flows are nominal (real), the discount rate has to be nominal (real). Nominal means with price rises included, and real means in today’s money. A bank rate that already carries inflation, applied to savings written without it, makes you reject good purchases while every step looks right.

What cash do you count, and what do you keep about the option you ruled out?

If the farmer picks the new dryer, the quote lists $200,000. It leaves out the concrete pad, the gas line and the wiring, which an installer prices at $30,000 in this example. With them the money out on day one is $230,000, the payback moves from 2.5 to 2.9 years, and the net present value falls from $226,794 to $196,794.

What the quote leaves out (invented example)
Money out on day one, with and without installationThe quote is $200,000. With $30,000 of installation the money out on day one is $230,000, and the payback moves from 2.5 to 2.9 years.Money out on day one$200,000$230,000The quotepayback 2.5 yearsWith installationpayback 2.9 yearsInstallation $30,000

Count the cash that changes because of the decision, and all of it. Damodaran: Use cash flows rather than earnings. You cannot spend earnings. Depreciation is not cash that leaves, and the farm’s whole result is not the flow either, because part of it would have happened without the dryer.

Set the horizon too, the last year that enters the sum. Use the years you can defend as years the machine works and the saving continues (here 3 and 8), not the loan term and not the seller’s promise. Each extra year in the horizon raises the net present value, so write why it ends where it ends. If the machine has resale value, it goes in as cash in the last year.

Money tied up while the machine works (working capital) belongs on the list as well. Inputs bought ahead, animals being raised and grain waiting for a price leave at the start and come back at the end. For the dryer it is the propane stored before harvest. The example leaves that amount out to keep the sum short; your sheet does not. Damodaran warns that the failure to consider working capital in a capital budgeting project will overstate cash flows on that project and make it look more attractive than it really is. When the saving is in fuel or electricity, take the yearly figure from the farm’s own bills, which where the farm’s energy goes month by month lays out.

Beside each year’s saving, write who it depends on. Here the saving is the drying charge the elevator stops billing, so it depends on the elevator’s price list. A saving 10% lower, from a lower charge or a dry fall, takes the net present value from $196,794 to $154,115 and the payback to 3.2 years. A good result that rests on a single outside party is only as good as that party. The authors of an Embrapa study of a goat milk system in Rio Grande do Norte, Brazil call their good results worrying. They depend entirely on the purchase guarantee and the subsidized prices of the government’s Programa do Leite (milk program).

Give the option you turned down one line. Nobody pays an invoice for what the farm decided not to do, so the figure that ruled it out is lost unless someone writes it on the day. Write three things.

  • The figure that ruled it out, with its unit. Here the option turned down is to keep paying the elevator to dry the corn, and the figure is the cents per bushel the elevator charges against the farm’s own cost of drying.
  • Where that figure came from: a contract, a written quote or the name of whoever said it. Say so when it came from the party selling the machine.
  • How far it was from flipping: how much the price or the cost must move for the decision to reverse.

A written investment plan keeps the condition of a purchase before the money goes out. This line keeps what ruled an option out.

Will the cash cover the loan and the credit line?

Value and cash are two separate questions. The new dryer passes on value, with a net present value of $196,794. On cash, first find the lowest point of the running cash, the day when the most money has gone out and the least has come back. Here it is day one, with $230,000 out. The farm’s credit line is $260,000, so that outlay fits.

Then compare the time the money takes to come back with the loan term. The discounted payback is the time until the savings, each cut to today’s money at your rate, add up to the price. For the new dryer it is 3.6 years. The dealer’s loan for the full $230,000 runs 3 years at 9% a year, which costs $90,863 a year against $80,000 saved. The last installment falls due before the money is back, and the difference comes out of the cash of another activity on the farm.

Two checks on the cash (invented example)
Cash against the credit line and the loan termThe lowest point of the running cash, $230,000 out on day one, is below the $260,000 credit line. The discounted payback of 3.6 years is longer than the 3-year loan.The new dryerCash against the credit lineLowest point of the running cash$230,000 out on day oneCredit line$260,000Money back against the loan termDiscounted payback3.6 yearsLoan term3 years

The same payback can be comfortable or dangerous, depending on the loan beside it. In the Embrapa goat milk study, recovering the extra investment takes 7.3 years. The authors assume a ten-year loan at zero charges. Its yearly repayment of R$ 2,650 takes 51.8% of the net margin (the study’s yearly income minus its total operating cost), which they call comfortable for the farmer and accepted by the lending banks. Those ten repayments add up to R$ 26,500. Paid in five equal installments, also at zero charges, they would be R$ 5,300 a year, more than the study’s yearly net margin of R$ 5,115.67 (Rurivia calculation). The investment is the same, and the loan is what makes it dangerous.

Reading value (the NPV is positive) and cash (the money fits the credit line and the loan term) together gives four answers.

  • Value yes, cash yes: sign.
  • Value yes, cash no: the purchase is sound and the financing is wrong. If the term fails, ask for a longer term, not a lower price; if the credit line fails, cut what goes out on day one. In the example a 5-year loan costs $59,131 a year, which the savings cover.
  • Value no, cash yes: the money comes back fast, but the machine lasts too short a time to earn your rate. Sign only if the money buys something other than a return, such as a legal requirement, and write that reason on the sheet.
  • Value no, cash no: drop it.

Is the value positive, and does the cash fit?

Value yes, cash yes

Sign

Value yes, cash no

Change the financing

A longer term, or less out on day one

Value no, cash yes

Sign only for another reason

Such as a legal requirement, written on the sheet

Value no, cash no

Drop it

Value yes or no and cash yes or no give four answers, each with what to do.

When two purchases compete for one credit line, the larger net present value can mislead. Damodaran divides each net present value by the initial investment. In his example a $1,000,000 project has an NPV of $467,937, which is 46.79% of the investment. A $10,000,000 project has an NPV of $1,358,664, which is 13.59%. The smaller project scores higher, even though the larger one has the larger net present value. The example’s IRR (33.66% against 20.88%) also puts the smaller one ahead, but the two figures measure different things: the NPV is a dollar surplus value, whereas the IRR is a percentage measure of return. If you do not yet know how much debt the farm can carry, start with whether your farm debt fits what it earns.

What do you write first, and how long does it take?

Write the rate first, before you read any quote. The rest takes about two hours with the quotes, the loan terms and last year’s actual figures at hand.

Order of the one-page sheet
The one-page sheet in six stepsSix steps in three groups: the rate and the cash before any quote, the ruled-out option with the results and the verdict, and the signature with a blank line.Before you see any quote1. Rate, with origin and date2. The cash, and who it depends onWith the numbers3. The option you ruled out4. NPV, payback, deepest point5. Discounted payback and verdictAt the foot of the sheet6. Sign, date, blank line, year 1

The blank line is the only part of the sheet that anyone can check later. The rate was a choice and the horizon was a judgment, and no net present value will appear on a bank statement. The first year’s actual cash against your forecast will.

Renting or buying land runs the same arithmetic on the biggest purchase most farms make, and has its own article: rent the land or buy it. The farm management page covers running the whole farm as a business. Other articles on farm money are in the finance section of the library.

Tool

The tool does the arithmetic and leaves the judgment to you.

Type your own numbers and the result updates as you go. Nothing you enter leaves your device.

Provenance

Derives from
  1. Damodaran, Measuring Investment Returns, Stern School of Business, New York University (open teaching material by the author)
  2. Graham and Harvey, The theory and practice of corporate finance: evidence from the field, Journal of Financial Economics 60(2-3), 2001 (peer reviewed, open copy on the author's university server)
  3. Bravo Motiño, Plan de inversión de una finca de cacao orgánico en la Aldea de Ticamaya, Honduras, Escuela Agrícola Panamericana Zamorano, 2018
  4. França, Martins, Holanda Junior and Sousa Neto, Indicadores de viabilidade financeira e econômica do sistema de produção familiar de leite de cabra no Rio Grande do Norte, Embrapa Caprinos, 2006
What this article covers
Writing down the rate you accept with its origin and its date, listing only the cash that changes because of one decision, including what the dealer's quote leaves out, setting a horizon you can defend, reading net present value, the internal rate of return and both paybacks together, checking the lowest point of the running cash against your real credit limit, setting the discounted payback beside the loan term, and leaving a dated line for the actual cash of the first year.
What it does not cover
It does not price machines, forecast yields, forecast prices or say what any investment will return. It does not choose between renting and buying, which is a decision of its own, and it does not rank two projects beyond saying which figure to rank them by. Tax treatment, depreciation schedules and the terms a lender will actually offer belong to whoever keeps the books and to the lender, and are not covered here. Nothing here says any particular investment should be made.
Published
Updated
Error found
Point out an error and the article is corrected with a note on what changed.

How to cite this article

Rurivia. (2026, September 1). Does a machine pay for itself? Payback, NPV and your rate. https://rurivia.com/en/library/finance/does-this-investment-pay-for-itself/


Keep reading

Finance

Farm machinery cost per hour: own it or hire the job?

Neither the tax return nor a published cost table holds the hourly cost of your own machine. The purchase invoice, the hour meter and the dealer's repair history do, and with them you can tell whether hiring the job out would cost less.

Aug 27, 2026
Finance

What is the cost per bushel of each field on your farm?

Add up what each field cost, invoices plus your own machine hours, and divide by the bushels weighed off it. A published cost per bushel is that of a model or an average, not that of your farm.

Oct 27, 2026
Finance

Is your farm's margin really behind a public reference?

Your margin is 12% and a published figure for farms like yours is 15%: are you behind? One table answers it, with your number for each of three to five years beside the published figure for the same year, and how each side counts cost.

Oct 27, 2026
Finance

How to split shared farm costs between crops and cattle

A split rule is the written statement of what each shared cost is divided by. Written before the arithmetic, it stops the choice of basis from deciding which enterprise looks profitable.

Aug 27, 2026

Farm Management

If this article were a plant, farm management would be the whole field.

Planning, organizing, leading and controlling: the four functions, what each one decides, and a farm example for each, all on one page.